Table 1:
Description and summary of the included studies and quality assessment results
| Ref. No. | Sample size(n) | Sc | SDd | Participants | Incidence of delirium (%) | Instrument of delirium assessment | Qh | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||||
| Da/N-Db | D | N-D | ||||||||
| Gender (M/F) | Age (M±SD or Median or n) | Gender (M/F) | Age (M±SD or Median or n) | |||||||
| (1) | 133/33 | MICU | Re | 83/50 | 20–44: 17 45–64: 35 ≥65: 81 |
16/17 | 20–44: 8 45–64: 8 ≥65: 7 |
80.12 | Nu-DESC | 6 |
| (7) | 63/358 | CSICU | R | NRf | NR | NR | NR | 14.96 | Nu-DESC | 7 |
| (8) | 159/489 | CSICU | R | 85/74 | 65.7±11.70 | 305/184 | 59.4±12.90 | 24.54 | CAM-ICU | 5 |
| (9) | 23/170 | NICU | Pg | 9/14 | 71.09±12.18 | 78/92 | 61.43±13.63 | 11.92 | Korean CAM-ICU | 10 |
| (12) | 1398/2323 | MICU SICU |
R | 777/621 | pre-adolescence: 14 adolescence: 28 adult: 532 old: 824 |
1348/975 | pre-adolescence: 15 adolescence: 61 adult: 1125 old: 1122 |
37.57 | DOS | 8 |
| (23) | 688/2596 | MICU SICU |
R | 395/293 | 68.43±14.77 | 1915/1369 | 58.5±15.59 | 20.95 | CAM-ICU | 7 |
| (24) | 107/48 | MICU | R | 73/34 | 65.65±14.08 | 35/13 | 58.67±17.90 | 69.03 | CAM-ICU | 7 |
| (25) | 22/77 | MICU SICU |
R | 18/4 | 76.00 | 57/20 | 72.00 | 22.22 | CAM-ICU | 6 |
| (26) | 180/720 | MICU SICU |
Re | 82/98 | 73.37±11.97 | 424/296 | 59.65±15.18 | 20.00 | CAM-ICU | 7 |
| (27) | 63/51 | ICU | Pf | 26/25 | 65–74: 27 75–84: 21 ≥85: 3 |
19/44 | 65–74: 18 75–84: 23 ≥85: 22 |
55.26 | Korean CAM-ICU | 7 |
| (28) | 25/45 | MICU | P | 13/12 | ≥65: 17 ≤64: 8 |
23/22 | ≥65: 20 ≤64: 25 |
35.71 | CAM-ICU | 7 |
| (29) | 22/77 | ICU | P | 14/8 | ≥60: 16 ≤59: 6 |
44/33 | ≥60: 42 ≤59: 35 |
22.22 | CAM-ICU | 5 |
| (30) | 22/88 | SICU | P | 15/7 | 66.8±9.60 | 67/21 | 60.06±12.10 | 20.00 | CAM-ICU | 7 |
| (31) | 500/2000 | MICU | R | 204/296 | 67.29±15.31 | 879/1121 | 59.92±15.37 | 20.00 | CAM-ICU | 6 |
| (32) | 31/75 | ICU | R | 20/11 | 49.7±8.00 | 59/16 | 48.4±8.00 | 29.25 | CAM-ICU | 5 |
| (33) | 46/27 | SICU | R | 33/13 | 64.46±9.84 | 18/9 | 52.85±15.52 | 63.01 | CAM-ICU | 5 |
| (34) | 34/91 | MICU SICU |
R | 18/16 | 71.50 | 46/45 | 60.00 | 27.20 | CAM-ICU | 6 |
| (35) | 107/68 | ICU | R | 63/44 | 72.07±13.25 | 32/36 | 59.85±17.45 | 61.14 | CAM-ICU | 7 |
D=Delirium,
N-D=Non-Delirium,
S=Setting,
SD=Study design,
R=Retrospective survey,
P=Prospective survey,
Q=Quality