Table 1.
Method | Label | Precision (%) | Recall (%) | Accuracy (%) | F-measure (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
SVM | 1 | 76.34 | 99.42 | 82.3 | 86.37 |
2 | 99.48 | 62.07 | 92.31% | 76.45 | |
3 | 100.0 | 57.75 | 98.04 | 73.21 | |
4 | 96.84 | 58.2 | 91.75 | 72.71 | |
KNN | 1 | 88.04 | 86.32 | 85.66 | 87.17 |
2 | 83.09 | 83.23 | 93.19 | 83.16 | |
3 | 78.05 | 86.49 | 98.17 | 82.05 | |
4 | 65.98 | 67.96 | 87.58 | 66.96 | |
LR | 1 | 83.46 | 88.4 | 83.8 | 85.86 |
2 | 76.93 | 75.3 | 89.83 | 76.11 | |
3 | 66.67 | 52.11 | 96.58 | 58.5 | |
4 | 55.86 | 50.27 | 83.7 | 52.92 | |
GaussianNB | 1 | 88.57 | 59.6 | 72.88 | 71.25 |
2 | 42.62 | 62.72 | 75.52 | 50.75 | |
3 | 14.64 | 86.62 | 76.01 | 25.05 | |
4 | 37.82 | 10.19 | 79.89 | 16.05 | |
QDA | 1 | 95.14 | 36.67 | 63.72 | 52.94 |
2 | 39.1 | 97.27 | 66.82 | 55.78 | |
3 | 100.0 | 99.3 | 99.97 | 99.65 | |
4 | 43.38 | 48.66 | 79.07 | 45.87 | |
DT | 1 | 91.85 | 92.57 | 91.49 | 92.21 |
2 | 91.53 | 87.21 | 95.53 | 89.32 | |
3 | 86.75 | 90.34 | 98.89 | 88.51 | |
4 | 78.36 | 79.93 | 91.79 | 79.14 | |
RF | 1 | 89.70 | 93.31 | 90.42 | 91.47 |
2 | 84.92 | 83.59 | 93.48 | 84.25 | |
3 | 86.11 | 87.94 | 98.79 | 87.02 | |
4 | 80.78 | 72.53 | 91.30 | 76.43 | |
HAFS-RF (our) | 1 | 92.21 | 95.52 | 93.06 | 93.84 |
2 | 93.17 | 91.58 | 96.84 | 92.37 | |
3 | 95.14 | 95.8 | 99.58 | 95.47 | |
4 | 88.43 | 80.75 | 94.3 | 84.42 |
Bold values indicate the maximum value of each type of lesion classification index