Table 2.
Treatment Modality | Reference | Design, N (# of patients) | Intervention |
---|---|---|---|
Physical Therapy | Ammitzbøll et al., 202011 | Double-blinded RCT, 158 | 1-year progressive resistance training |
De Groef et al., 201012 | Double-blinded RCT, 143 | 8 sessions of myofascial therapy | |
Cognitive Therapy | Lacroix et al., 201913 | Prospective non-randomized study, 42 | Perioperative hypnosedation |
Garssen et al., 201014 | RCT, 70 | Pre-surgical stress management training | |
Nerve Blocks | Besch et al., 201019 | Retrospective comparative study, 191 | GA with pectoral nerve block |
Fujii et al., 201820 | Double-blinded RCT, 80 | PECS II Block | |
De Cassai et al., 201918 | Prospective observational comparative study, 132 | PECS II block | |
Strazisar et al., 201415 | Prospective randomized study, 60 | Wound catheter with continuous infusion of local anesthetic | |
Mohamed et al., 201817 | Double-blinded RCT, 90 | Wound irrigation with bupivacaine plus 5, 10, or 15 mg morphine | |
Albi-Feldzer et al., 200016 | Double-blinded RCT, 236 | Wound infiltration with repeated injections of local anesthetic | |
Shimizu et al., 201523 | Retrospective cohort study, 46 | Perioperative ultrasound-guided TPVB | |
Karmakar et al., 201724 | Double-blinded RCT, 177 | Single injection or continuous infusion with catheter of TPVB | |
Kamal et al., 201925 | Double-blinded RCT, 80 | TPVB of bupivacaine with 0.5 mg/kg or 1 mg/kg ketamine | |
Kairaluoma et al., 200626 | Double-blinded RCT, 59 | Pre-incisional PVB | |
Elkaradawy et al., 201228 | RCT, 50 | Ultrasound-guided TPVB with GA | |
Ilfeld et al., 201827 | Double-blinded RCT, 60 | Ultrasound-guided continuous PVB catheter | |
Gacio et al., 201821 | Non-randomized prospective observational study, 66 | GA and single-injection PVB | |
Qian et al., 201922 | Double-blinded RCT, 184 | Ultrasound-guided single-injection multilevel TPVB | |
Anesthesia | Cho et al., 201229 | Retrospective comparative study, 228 | Propofol vs. sevoflurane anesthesia |
Lefebvre-Kuntz et al., 201532 | Prospective cohort study, 328 | Halogenated anesthetic vs. propofol | |
Grigoras et al., 201330 | Double-blinded RCT, 36 | Perioperative IV lidocaine | |
Terkawi et al., 201738 | Double-blinded RCT, 61 | Intraoperative IV lidocaine infusion | |
Kim et al., 201737 | Double-blinded RCT, 116 | Intraoperative systemic lidocaine vs. magnesium | |
Kendall et al., 201834 | Double-blinded RCT, 121 | Perioperative IV lidocaine | |
Khan et al., 2019*35 | Double-blinded RCT, 100 | Perioperative pregabalin and lidocaine infusion | |
Jain et al., 201236 | Double-blinded RCT, 69 | Intraoperative IV dexmedetomidine | |
Kang et al., 202033 | Double-blinded RCT, 168 | Perioperative IV ketamine | |
Sun et al., 201231 | Double-blinded RCT, 60 | Perioperative IV flurbiprofen axetil | |
Oral medications | Fassoulaki et al., 200239 | Double-blinded RCT, 67 | Perioperative oral mexiletine vs. gabapentin capsules |
Lee et al., 201340 | Single-blinded RCT, 51 | Multimodal analgesia (perioperative pregabalin and PVB catheter of local anesthetic) | |
Vig et al., 201942 | Double-blinded RCT, 71 | Perioperative pregabalin | |
Reyad et al., 201943 | Double-blinded RCT, 181 | Perioperative pregabalin | |
Fassoulaki et al., 200144 | Double-blinded RCT, 96 | Perioperative mexiletine and regional ropivacaine block | |
Amr et al., 200946 | Double-blinded RCT, 150 | Perioperative gabapentin and venlafaxine | |
Khan et al., 2019*35 | Double-blinded RCT, 100 | Perioperative pregabalin and lidocaine infusion | |
Hah et al., 199645 | Double-blinded RCT, 41 | Perioperative gabapentin | |
Van Helmond et al., 201641 | Double-blinded RCT, 94 | Perioperative parecoxib injection and celecoxib | |
Fassoulaki et al., 200547 | Double-blinded RCT, 44 | Multimodal analgesia (Gabapentin, EMLA cream near incision, irrigation of brachial plexus block) | |
Na et al., 201848 | Double-blinded RCT, 83 | Intraoperative IV nefopam | |
Surgical interventions | Salmon et al., 199855 | Double-blinded RCT, 128 | Preservation of ICBN |
Torresan et al., 200751 | Double-blinded RCT, 85 | Preservation of ICBN | |
Freeman et al., 200353 | Double-blinded RCT, 73 | Preservation of ICBN | |
Taira et al., 201454 | Non-blinded RCT, 140 | Preservation of ICBN | |
Tasmuth et al., 199950 | Retrospective observational study, 221 | High-volume surgical units vs. small-volume units | |
Yang et al., 201252 | Double-blinded RCT, 99 | Spray of HA–CMC gel onto surface of pectoralis major and serratus anterior muscles | |
Topical medications | Fassoulaki et al., 200056 | Double-blinded RCT, 45 | Intraoperative EMLA on sternal area |
*Included in two categories
RCT – Randomized controlled trial
GA – Generalized anesthesia
TPVB – Thoracic paravertebral block
ICBN – Intercostal-brachial nerve
HA–CMC – Hyaluronic acid–carboxymethyl cellulose
IV – Intravenous