Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 30;31:32–49. doi: 10.1016/j.jpra.2021.10.009

Table 2.

Study characteristics of all included studies

Treatment Modality Reference Design, N (# of patients) Intervention
Physical Therapy Ammitzbøll et al., 202011 Double-blinded RCT, 158 1-year progressive resistance training
De Groef et al., 201012 Double-blinded RCT, 143 8 sessions of myofascial therapy
Cognitive Therapy Lacroix et al., 201913 Prospective non-randomized study, 42 Perioperative hypnosedation
Garssen et al., 201014 RCT, 70 Pre-surgical stress management training
Nerve Blocks Besch et al., 201019 Retrospective comparative study, 191 GA with pectoral nerve block
Fujii et al., 201820 Double-blinded RCT, 80 PECS II Block
De Cassai et al., 201918 Prospective observational comparative study, 132 PECS II block
Strazisar et al., 201415 Prospective randomized study, 60 Wound catheter with continuous infusion of local anesthetic
Mohamed et al., 201817 Double-blinded RCT, 90 Wound irrigation with bupivacaine plus 5, 10, or 15 mg morphine
Albi-Feldzer et al., 200016 Double-blinded RCT, 236 Wound infiltration with repeated injections of local anesthetic
Shimizu et al., 201523 Retrospective cohort study, 46 Perioperative ultrasound-guided TPVB
Karmakar et al., 201724 Double-blinded RCT, 177 Single injection or continuous infusion with catheter of TPVB
Kamal et al., 201925 Double-blinded RCT, 80 TPVB of bupivacaine with 0.5 mg/kg or 1 mg/kg ketamine
Kairaluoma et al., 200626 Double-blinded RCT, 59 Pre-incisional PVB
Elkaradawy et al., 201228 RCT, 50 Ultrasound-guided TPVB with GA
Ilfeld et al., 201827 Double-blinded RCT, 60 Ultrasound-guided continuous PVB catheter
Gacio et al., 201821 Non-randomized prospective observational study, 66 GA and single-injection PVB
Qian et al., 201922 Double-blinded RCT, 184 Ultrasound-guided single-injection multilevel TPVB
Anesthesia Cho et al., 201229 Retrospective comparative study, 228 Propofol vs. sevoflurane anesthesia
Lefebvre-Kuntz et al., 201532 Prospective cohort study, 328 Halogenated anesthetic vs. propofol
Grigoras et al., 201330 Double-blinded RCT, 36 Perioperative IV lidocaine
Terkawi et al., 201738 Double-blinded RCT, 61 Intraoperative IV lidocaine infusion
Kim et al., 201737 Double-blinded RCT, 116 Intraoperative systemic lidocaine vs. magnesium
Kendall et al., 201834 Double-blinded RCT, 121 Perioperative IV lidocaine
Khan et al., 2019*35 Double-blinded RCT, 100 Perioperative pregabalin and lidocaine infusion
Jain et al., 201236 Double-blinded RCT, 69 Intraoperative IV dexmedetomidine
Kang et al., 202033 Double-blinded RCT, 168 Perioperative IV ketamine
Sun et al., 201231 Double-blinded RCT, 60 Perioperative IV flurbiprofen axetil
Oral medications Fassoulaki et al., 200239 Double-blinded RCT, 67 Perioperative oral mexiletine vs. gabapentin capsules
Lee et al., 201340 Single-blinded RCT, 51 Multimodal analgesia (perioperative pregabalin and PVB catheter of local anesthetic)
Vig et al., 201942 Double-blinded RCT, 71 Perioperative pregabalin
Reyad et al., 201943 Double-blinded RCT, 181 Perioperative pregabalin
Fassoulaki et al., 200144 Double-blinded RCT, 96 Perioperative mexiletine and regional ropivacaine block
Amr et al., 200946 Double-blinded RCT, 150 Perioperative gabapentin and venlafaxine
Khan et al., 2019*35 Double-blinded RCT, 100 Perioperative pregabalin and lidocaine infusion
Hah et al., 199645 Double-blinded RCT, 41 Perioperative gabapentin
Van Helmond et al., 201641 Double-blinded RCT, 94 Perioperative parecoxib injection and celecoxib
Fassoulaki et al., 200547 Double-blinded RCT, 44 Multimodal analgesia (Gabapentin, EMLA cream near incision, irrigation of brachial plexus block)
Na et al., 201848 Double-blinded RCT, 83 Intraoperative IV nefopam
Surgical interventions Salmon et al., 199855 Double-blinded RCT, 128 Preservation of ICBN
Torresan et al., 200751 Double-blinded RCT, 85 Preservation of ICBN
Freeman et al., 200353 Double-blinded RCT, 73 Preservation of ICBN
Taira et al., 201454 Non-blinded RCT, 140 Preservation of ICBN
Tasmuth et al., 199950 Retrospective observational study, 221 High-volume surgical units vs. small-volume units
Yang et al., 201252 Double-blinded RCT, 99 Spray of HA–CMC gel onto surface of pectoralis major and serratus anterior muscles
Topical medications Fassoulaki et al., 200056 Double-blinded RCT, 45 Intraoperative EMLA on sternal area

*Included in two categories

RCT – Randomized controlled trial

GA – Generalized anesthesia

TPVB – Thoracic paravertebral block

ICBN – Intercostal-brachial nerve

HA–CMC – Hyaluronic acid–carboxymethyl cellulose

IV – Intravenous