Table 1:
Description of studies included in the qualitative metasynthesis.
Reference number | Authors | Study Purpose | Country | Study Design | Methods | Participants | Summary of Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Boltz et al. (2010) | To examine older adults perspectives on physical function during and after a hospital stay | USA | Descriptive | -Focus groups with semi-structured interviews | 24 older adults who had recently experienced a hospitalization | -Participants expected to go home feeling better than when initially hospitalized, but experienced a profound loss of physical function over the course of the hospital stay. -Participants experienced significant barriers to independence, but felt as though strong nursing care facilitated improvement. |
2 | Boltz et al. (2011) | To examine organizational factors that influence physical function in hospitalized older adults from the perspectives of nursing staff. | USA | Descriptive | -Focus groups with semi-structured interviews | 55 nurses, nurse supervisors, and personal care assistants from two hospitals | -Nursing staff identified both facilitators and barriers to improving physical function for hospitalized older adults. -Participants identified how older adults are particularly vulnerable to loss of physical function. -Nurses saw promotion of physical function as integral to their professional role. |
3 | Brown et al. (2007) | To compare barriers to mobility identified by patients, physicians, and nurses in the hospital setting | USA | Grounded theory | -One on one semi-structured interviews -Content analysis was used to determine perceived barriers to mobility |
10 patients (age 75 or older), 10 nurses, and 9 resident physicians | -All three groups identified barriers such as symptoms (i.e. weakness, pain, fatigue), having an intravenous line or urinary catheter, and concern about falling. -Lack of staff was noted by most nurses and physicians and some patients. -Clinicians identified low patient motivation as a potential barrier, but patients did not. |
4 | Chan et al. (2018) | To describe nurses’ perception of facilitators and barriers to older adult’s participation in physical activity during a hospital stay from an Asian context | Singapore | Phenomonology | -Focus group interviews with semi-structured interview guide, reflexivitiy employed throughout the study, theoretical thematic analysis | 30 registered or enrolled nurses from various general wards in a single hospital | -Physical activity was a fundamental aspect of nursing -Facilitators included premorbid functional state, a multidisciplinary approach, family support system -Barriers included adoption of ‘sick role’ behavior, prolonged bed rest, pain and unfamiliar medical devices, fear of falls, safety culture around falls and language differences |
5 | Doherty-King & Bowers (2012) | To explore nurses’ expectations around the responsibility for ambulating patients, as well as how this impacts their decision whether to ambulate | USA | Grounded dimensional analysis (grounded theory combined with dimensional analysis) | -Structured focus groups | 25 registered nurses on medical or surgical units from two hospitals | -Some nurses claimed that ambulation of patients was their own responsibility -Nurses who claimed responsibility tended to focus on patient independence and psychosocial well-being, interdisciplinary collaboration, determining appropriateness of activity orders, and adjusting to resource availability -others believed that it was the responsibility of other clinicians |
6 | Higgins et al. (2007) | To examine the negative attitudes of nurses towards older adults in their care | Australia | -descriptive qualitative study | -In-depth interviews -Nurses were provided scenarios that demonstrated both positive and negative aspects of care |
-9 nurses participated in this secondary study | -Nurses perceive older adults to be more difficult to work with than other patients -Lack of time for care leads to difficulty caring for this population -Stereotyping older patients was common |
7 | Kirk et al. (2019) | To explore how social contextual circumstances impact the mobility of older adults, and how it alters healthcare clinicians decisions whether to mobilize a patient | Denmark | Ethnographic field study | -Study authors followed participants and observed how they talked about mobility, interacted with patients, and how surrounding shaped their actions using an observation guide -Go-along interviews were also conducted |
61 Health professional (PTs, RNs, Nursing assistants) and 18 physicians from six departments in three public hospitals | -Professional roles appeared to be the most important factor for making decisions about mobility. Time pressure contributes to lack of mobility - Environment played a major role in lack of mobility -Encouraging patients was crucial for mobilization -Patients expected nurses to be too busy with other tasks -Mobility improved when connected with ‘transfer value’ (i.e. goals connected to home) |
8 | Koenders et al. (2018) | To understand attitudes, beliefs, thoughts and experiences related to physical activity from the perspectives of patients and healthcare clinicians | Norway | Interpretive Phenomono-logical study, | One on one semi-structured interviews, compared patients to health care clinicians | 42 total participants: 18 patients in cardiac care unit, cardiology, orthopedics or traumatology; 24 clinicians (nurses, nursing assistants, PTs, 1 physician assistant and 1 physician) | -Patients/clinicians commonly described physical activity as purposeful activity to achieve a goal -Physical and mental rest is needed to balance physical activity -The hospital environment was not conducive to physical activity -Ability to participate in physical activity was associated with feelings of freedom and autonomy |
9 | Masley et al. (2011) | To determine the role of PTs in the acute care setting and describe clinical reasoning processes | USA | Grounded-theory | Semi-structured interviews, used a constant comparative process to determine common themes, which lead to theoretical model | 18 PTs in three academic medical centers | -PTs collect and analyze medical information to determine appropriateness of therapy, apply specialized PT knowledge in mobility, movement dysfunction, and safety in a complex environment -PTs have patients do as much as they can on their own without physical help -PTs communicate with other professions, patients, and families |
10 | Ohlsson-Nevo et al. (2019) | To describe how nurses perceive and facilitate physical activity for hospitalized older adults | Sweden | Exploratory/ descriptive | Semi-structured focus group interviews, interaction analysis | 29 nursing staff in three hospitals | -Patients depend on nursing staff for mobility, although nursing staff does not always have time to help -Nurses see physical activity as a fundamental part of their professional role -Understanding patient expectations facilitates physical activity performance -A team approach involving the patient, family, and multiple healthcare professionals facilitates physical activity |
11 | So & Pierluissi (2012) | To describe the expectations, facilitators, and barrier around exercise in the hospital | USA | Framework theory/ framework method (familiarization, identifying thematic framework, indexing, charting, mapping and interpretation) | Semi-structured interviews at besides about attitudes/expectations regarding in-hospital exercise | 28 English or Spanish-speaking hospitalized older adults, | -Exercise was equated with walking for most participants -Few participants expected to be exercising -Motivating factors: avoiding negative effects of bed rest, promoting a sense of well-being, being asked to exercise -Barriers included symptoms, institutional barriers, fear of injury |