Table 5.
The main oocyte and embryo biopsy approaches to conduct preimplantation genetic testing
PB biopsy | Blastomere/cleavage-stage biopsy | Blastocyst/TE biopsy | |
---|---|---|---|
Fragment origin | Waste products of maternal meiosis | Totipotent cells | TE gives origin to the placenta and the extraembryonic membranes |
Number of cells 2 (both required) retrieved | Two might be “one” retrieved, but it is discouraged | 5-10 trophectoderm cells | |
Complexity in the acquisition of the skill | Day 0+ day 1 approach | Moderate | Day 3 hatching-based strategy: Low-to-moderate |
Moderate | |||
Day 1 only approach | Morula hatching-based strategy: Low to moderate | ||
Same day hatching-based strategy: Low to moderate | |||
Moderate to high (PB1 and PB2 should be reliably recognized) | Simultaneous ZP opening and TE cells retrieval strategy: Moderate to high | ||
Complexity in the performance of tubing | Moderate to high | Moderate | Moderate to high |
Embryo developmental competence | Unpredictable at this stage | Unpredictable at this stage | Only embryos developing to the blastocyst stage are biopsied |
Laboratory workload | High (all oocytes/zygotes should be biopsied regardless of their developmental competence) | Moderate (all oocytes/zygotes/cleavage-stage embryos should be biopsied regardless of their developmental competence) | Multiple time slots required (day 5-7) and cryopreservation mostly mandatory |
Day 3 hatching-based strategy: Moderate to high (all embryos should undergo ZP opening at the cleavage stage regardless of their developmental competence) | |||
Morula hatching-based strategy: Moderate to high (all morulae should undergo ZP opening regardless of their developmental competence) | |||
Same day hatching-based strategy: Moderate to high (all blastocysts should undergo ZP opening and monitoring of TE cells hatching) | |||
Simultaneous ZP opening and TE cells retrieval strategy: Moderate | |||
Extended embryo culture | Suggested but not mandatory | Suggested but not mandatory | Not mandatory |
Cryopreservation following biopsy | According to laboratory policy | According to laboratory policy | Mostly mandatory |
Meiotic errors assessed | Only maternal | Yes | Yes |
Mitotic errors assessed | Not | Not | Possible within given technical, methodological, and biological limitations (e.g., molecular platform and bioinformatic parameters - dependent, inevitable sampling bias) |
Inconclusive diagnosis (%) | 10 | 10 | <10 |
Impact on reproductive competence | Not reported, but more data are still required | Reduced implantation potential post biopsy | Not reported, but more data are still required |
The parameters “low,” “moderate,” and “high” were agreed unanimously after a thorough discussion among all the components of the working group. TE=Trophectoderm, PB=Polar body, ZP=Zona pellucida