Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 16;14(Suppl 1):S31–S47. doi: 10.4103/0974-1208.330503

Table 5.

The main oocyte and embryo biopsy approaches to conduct preimplantation genetic testing

PB biopsy Blastomere/cleavage-stage biopsy Blastocyst/TE biopsy
Fragment origin Waste products of maternal meiosis Totipotent cells TE gives origin to the placenta and the extraembryonic membranes
Number of cells 2 (both required) retrieved Two might be “one” retrieved, but it is discouraged 5-10 trophectoderm cells
Complexity in the acquisition of the skill Day 0+ day 1 approach Moderate Day 3 hatching-based strategy: Low-to-moderate
 Moderate
Day 1 only approach Morula hatching-based strategy: Low to moderate
Same day hatching-based strategy: Low to moderate
 Moderate to high (PB1 and PB2 should be reliably recognized) Simultaneous ZP opening and TE cells retrieval strategy: Moderate to high
Complexity in the performance of tubing Moderate to high Moderate Moderate to high
Embryo developmental competence Unpredictable at this stage Unpredictable at this stage Only embryos developing to the blastocyst stage are biopsied
Laboratory workload High (all oocytes/zygotes should be biopsied regardless of their developmental competence) Moderate (all oocytes/zygotes/cleavage-stage embryos should be biopsied regardless of their developmental competence) Multiple time slots required (day 5-7) and cryopreservation mostly mandatory
Day 3 hatching-based strategy: Moderate to high (all embryos should undergo ZP opening at the cleavage stage regardless of their developmental competence)
Morula hatching-based strategy: Moderate to high (all morulae should undergo ZP opening regardless of their developmental competence)
Same day hatching-based strategy: Moderate to high (all blastocysts should undergo ZP opening and monitoring of TE cells hatching)
Simultaneous ZP opening and TE cells retrieval strategy: Moderate
Extended embryo culture Suggested but not mandatory Suggested but not mandatory Not mandatory
Cryopreservation following biopsy According to laboratory policy According to laboratory policy Mostly mandatory
Meiotic errors assessed Only maternal Yes Yes
Mitotic errors assessed Not Not Possible within given technical, methodological, and biological limitations (e.g., molecular platform and bioinformatic parameters - dependent, inevitable sampling bias)
Inconclusive diagnosis (%) 10 10 <10
Impact on reproductive competence Not reported, but more data are still required Reduced implantation potential post biopsy Not reported, but more data are still required

The parameters “low,” “moderate,” and “high” were agreed unanimously after a thorough discussion among all the components of the working group. TE=Trophectoderm, PB=Polar body, ZP=Zona pellucida