Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 27;21(23):7921. doi: 10.3390/s21237921

Table 1.

Approaches for detecting driver’s drowsiness.

Methods Measurement Information Measurement Target Measurement
Method
Measurement
Index
Advantages Disadvantages
Contact method Biometric information Heartbeat, pulse wave, aspiration, brain wave, myoelectric, eye movement, etc. Heart rate monitor, pulse wavemeter, electroencephalograph, electromyograph, nystagmus, etc. Heart rate, chaos analysis, alpha wave, theta wave, muscle action potential, vestibular oculomotor reflex, etc. High drowsiness detection performance can be obtained [10]. Driver behavior adversely affects the reliability of the designed system [10].
Non-contact method Vehicle behavior Steering pattern,
distance between lane and vehicle,
speed, distance between vehicles, etc.
Steering angle sensor, white line recognition camera, laser radar, etc. Steering frequency, meandering rate, steering volume, monotonous steering Estimates can be obtained in a way that is unobtrusive to the driver [11]. The accuracy of detection and estimation depends on road conditions and the environment. It is useful only when the driver is holding the steering wheel.
Driver’s graphic information Open rate of eyes, blink, pupil, voice, and expression Camera, microphone Opening and closing rates
of eyes, number of blinks, time of closing eyes, pupil fluctuation, chaos analysis of speech sound, drowsy categorization by expression, etc.
Intuitional index and easy-to-understand, high accuracy. Different lighting conditions may disrupt the detection performance [10].