Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 9:10.1111/scs.13038. Online ahead of print. doi: 10.1111/scs.13038

TABLE 3.

Coding list of experiences potentially challenging/supporting dignity

Initial categories and themes analytical framework Refined themes Final themes
Individual level
Illness‐related concerns:
  • Existential/Spiritual distress (loss of identity, loss of meaning etc.)
  • Psychological distress (medical uncertainty, death anxiety etc.)
  • Physical distress (pain, short of breath etc.)
  • Loneliness of the patient (‐)

  • Patients losing meaning in life and giving up (‐)

  • Missing physical contact by patients and relatives(‐)

  • Meaningful moments for relatives and patients (+)

  • Relatives anxious about patients dying alone

  • Relatives’ fear of coming too late (‐)

  • Relatives’ uncertainty and having to make decisions related to patient's treatment (‐)

  • Fear of patients and themselves becoming infected (‐)

  • Relatives advocating comfort for the patient (‐)

  • Patients with dementia not understanding the situation (‐)

  • Unrecognised symptoms of COVID‐19 by GP (‐)

  • Relatives’ concerns about patient not wanting to eat (‐)

  • Rapid physical deterioration of the patient (‐)

  • Relatives not understanding end of life is near (‐)

  • Burdensome symptoms of patient (shortness of breath, agitation and pain) (‐)

  • Patients not receiving physical care or treatment (‐)

  • Good palliative treatment for comfort (+)

Dealing with an unknown illness
  • Relatives overwhelmed by the rapid process of the disease
  • GPs unfamiliar with COVID‐19
  • Nurses not taking the risk of infection seriously
  • Relatives’ concerns about medical treatment
  • Relatives’ fear of vulnerable family members becoming infected
Being isolated
  • Relatives unable to visit patient in nursing homes
  • Missing physical contact
  • Patients being alone and isolated
  • Parents separated from each other
  • Not understanding ‘window visits’ by patients with dementia
  • Relatives failing to stay in contact at distance: video calls did not work out
  • Patients losing meaning and courage to go on
  • Patients not wanting to eat anymore
  • Accumulation of factors leading to death
Restricted farewells
  • Saying farewell at the ambulance
  • Relatives’ fear of themselves becoming infected
  • Abrupt farewells
  • Patients dying alone
  • Fear of being absent or too late
  • Family frictions; having to choose who is going
  • Relatives having to wear gloves, masks and suits
Lack of attentiveness and communication
  • Relatives missing attention and attentiveness from HCP
  • Relatives wishing more contact with GP or Physician
  • Relatives and patients losing role in the decision‐making process
  • Relatives having to make decisions about to stop the oxygen
  • Relatives making an effort to speak the GP
  • Relatives’ limited contact with GP/HCP through telephone or video calls
  • Nontactical communication from HCP to relatives
Meaningful end‐of‐life moments
  • Extended visiting opportunities
  • Relatives’ gratefulness for certain moments
  • Relatives’ broader perspective of death
  • Further suffering of patient has been spared
  • Patients’ wishes were fulfilled
  • Relatives’ and patients’ spiritual/religious belief
  • Relatives’ overall acceptance
Compassionate professional support
  • Compassionate nursing care for patients and relatives
  • Nurses stood up for relatives’ emotions and needs
  • Open and clear communication
Dignity‐conserving repertoire:Personal characteristics and perspectives
  • Personal protective practices
  • Patient's wish/promise fulfilled (+)

  • Relatives acceptance of the COVID‐situation (+)

  • Relatives grateful for certain moments or that the suffering of the patient has been spared (+)

  • Relatives’ or patients’ spiritual or religious believes (+)

  • Relatives picking up daily life (+)

  • Relatives sharing their story (+)

  • Relatives’ meaningful moments (+)

Relational level
Social Dignity
  • Social support (feeling connected and supported by essential others)
  • Interactions with family and friends
  • Virtual calls
  • Not being able to physically see each other (‐)

  • Relatives not being able to embrace the patient (‐)

  • Staying in contact via window contact (+ ‐)

  • Saying farewell at the ambulance (‐)

  • Contact possibilities at the end of patient's life (+‐)

  • Not saying goodbye at end of life (‐)

  • Saying goodbye at end of life via phone (‐)

  • Relatives saying goodbye in protective equipment (‐)

  • Fear within the family of becoming infected (‐)

  • Support within the family (‐)

  • Relatives staying in contact with the patient by telephone or video calls (+‐)
  • Virtual calls not facilitated by nursing staff (‐)
Professional support (Being taken seriously, being respected, feeling burdened):
  • Interaction with health care professionals (HCP), such as nurses
  • Interaction with GP, medical specialist, physician.
  • Less contact or communication with HCP (‐)
  • Relatives effort needed to get contact with HCP (‐)
  • Communication via mail, app, phone (‐)
  • No communication between disciplines (‐)
  • Clear communication with HCP(+)
  • Relatives felt compassion from HCP (+)
  • Relatives felt no compassion (‐)
  • No respectful interaction with HCP (‐)
  • HCP being lax and not acting appropriately in care situation (‐)
  • HCP standing up for relatives’ needs and emotions (+)
  • Not receiving attention and care for the patient that was needed (‐)
  • Loving care for the patient (+)
  • Less contact with GP (‐)
  • Difficult for relatives to speak/reach GP (‐)
  • Regular contact with GP (+)
  • Nontactical communication from GP toward relatives and patients (‐)
  • Less compassion (‐)
  • Patients and relatives not taken seriously by GP (‐)
Societal/organisational level
COVID−19 Policy:
  • Visiting rules and possibilities
  • Isolation rules and Personal Protective Equipment
  • No visits anymore after the lockdown (‐)

  • Relatives being present by the patient all day (+)

  • Visiting possibilities were extended in terminal phase (+)

  • Relatives not being able to be present during decease (‐)

  • Visitor policies differed between organisations/departments and changed over time (‐)

  • Limited number of visitors; relatives had to make choices and not everyone could say goodbye (‐)

  • Relatives’ appreciation of nursing staff's handling of visitor policy (+)

  • Limited or no protective equipment for relatives and nursing staff (‐)

  • Unprotected care was provided by nurses (‐)

  • Relatives saying farewell in protective equipment (‐)

  • Not being able to touch/embrace each other (‐)

  • Relative not recognisable in PPE by patient (‐)