Table 2.
Paper and system description | Device location | Video type | System type | System metrics (hand hygiene opportunities) | ||
Auditor (human) | ||||||
|
Brotfain et al [34] | |||||
|
|
RGBa camera | Patient room | Streaming | Research | WHOb 5 moments |
|
Sánchez-Carrillo et al [35] | |||||
|
|
RGB camera | Patient room | Recorded | Research | WHO 5 moments |
|
Diller et al [36] | |||||
|
|
RGB camera (with infrared lens) | Patient room | Recorded | Research | WHO 5 moments |
|
Armellino et al [38,39] | |||||
|
|
RGB camera | Sink and sanitizer dispenser | Recorded | Commercial (Arrowsight) | Patient room entry/exit events |
|
|
Motion sensor | Patient room entrance | Recorded | Commercial (Arrowsight) | Patient room entry/exit events |
|
Diefenbacher et al [37,40] | |||||
|
|
RGB camera | HCWsc (chest) | Recorded | Research | WHO 5 moments |
Auditor (algorithm) | ||||||
|
Zhong et al [41] | |||||
|
|
RGB camera | HCWs (chest) | Recorded | Research | Hand hygiene events |
|
Snoek et al [42] | |||||
|
|
RGB camera | Sink | Recorded | Research | Hand hygiene events (5 states related to faucet interaction) |
|
|
Microphone | Sink | Recorded | Research | Hand hygiene events (5 states related to faucet interaction) |
|
Awwad et al [43] | |||||
|
|
RGB depth camera | Patient bed | Recorded | Research | Moment 1 (before touching a patient) |
aRGB: red green blue.
bWHO: World Health Organization.
cHCW: health care worker.