Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov;9(22):1662. doi: 10.21037/atm-21-5081

Table 1. The basic characteristics of the included literature.

Author Year Region Field focused Method of study Types of AI systems Type of lesions Type of images Testing objects
Liu WN (9) 2020 China Detection Real-time use 3D-CNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Misawa (12) 2021 Japan Detection Videos verification YoloV3 Polyps of any size WLI AI system
Urban (13) 2018 USA Detection Images and videos verification DCNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Qadir (20) 2021 Norway Detection Image verification F-CNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Guo (21) 2021 Japan Detection Videos verification YoloV3 Polyps of any size NA AI system/expert/nonexpert
Jia (22) 2020 Hong Kong, China Detection Image verification CNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Liu P (23) 2020 China Detection Real-time use Deep learning Polyps of any size NA AI system
Poon (24) 2020 Hong Kong, China Detection Images and videos verification CNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Shin (25) 2018 Norway Detection Images verification Dictionary learning scheme Polyps of any size NA AI system
Su (26) 2020 China Detection Real-time use DCNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Wang (27) 2019 China Detection Real-time use DCNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Wang (28) 2020 China Detection Real-time use Deep learning Polyps of any size NA AI system
Wang (29) 2018 China Detection Image and video verification Deep learning Polyps of any size NA AI system
Yu (30) 2017 Hong Kong, China Detection Image verification 3D-FCN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Zhang (31) 2018 Hong Kong, China Detection Images verification DCNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Byrne (32) 2019 Canada Classification Video verification DCNN Polyps that ≤5 mm NA AI system
Chen (33) 2018 Taiwan, China Classification Video verification DCNN Polyps that ≤5 mm NA AI system/expert/nonexpert
Kominami (34) 2016 Japan Classification Image verification SVM Polyps of any size NA AI system
Kudo (35) 2020 Japan Classification Image verification NA Polyps that ≤10 mm WLI/EC NBI/EC methylene blue staining AI system/expert/nonexpert
Mori (36) 2016 Japan Classification Image verification SVM Polyps of any size EC images AI system/expert/nonexpert
Mori (37) 2018 Japan Classification Real-time use NA Polyps that ≤5 mm EC NBI/EC methylene blue staining AI system/expert/nonexpert
Mori (38) 2015 Japan Classification Image verification NA Polyps that ≤10 mm WLI/EC images AI system/expert/nonexpert
Patel (39) 2020 America Classification video verification CNN Polyps of any size NA AI system
Renner (40) 2018 Germany Classification Image verification DCNN Polyps of any size NA AI system/expert
Yamada (41) 2019 Japan Classification Image verification NA Polyps of any size NA AI system
Ozawa (42) 2020 Japan Detection and Classification Image verification CNN Polyps of any size NA AI system

DCNN, deep convolutional neural network; CNN, convolutional neural network; YoloV3, a deep learning–based common object detection algorithm; NBI, narrow band imaging; 3D-FCN, three-dimensional fully convolutional network; F-CNN, fully convolutional neural network; 3D-CNN, three-dimensional convolutional neural network; SVM, support vector machine; WLI, white light imaging; EC, endocytoscopy; NA, not available.