Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 10;9:30551–30572. doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3058537

TABLE 4. Summary of Deep Learning Based COVID-19 Diagnosis in X-Ray Images Using Customized Network.

Authors Data Sources Number of images Number of classes Partitioning Techniques Performances (%)
Wang et al. [99] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88], RSNA Pneumonia Detection Challenge dataset [95] 13, 800 3 (COVID-19, non-COVID-19, normal) Training=90%, Testing=10% COVID-Net (CNN) Accuracy= 92.4, Sensitivity=80, Precision=88.9
Ucar and Korkmaz [124] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88], COVIDx Dataset [99], Kaggle chest X-ray pneumonia dataset [133] 2839 (COVID-19=45, normal=1203, pneumoniae] 591) 3 (COVID-19, normal, pneumonia) Training=80%, Testing=10%, Validation=10% Bayes-SqueezeNet Accuracy=98.26, Specificity=99.13, Fl-Score=98.25, MCC=97.39, Correctness=98.26, Completeness=98.2 6
Khan et al. [125] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88], Kaggle chest x-ray repository [93] 1251 (COVID-19=284, normal=310, pneumonia bacterial=330, pneumonia viral= 327) 4 (COVID-19, normal, pneumonia bacterial, pneumonia viral) Training=80%, Validation=20% CoroNet (CNN) Accuracy=89.5, Sensitivity=100, Precision=97, Fl-Score= 98
Rahimzade h and Attar [126] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88], RSNA Pneumonia Detection Challenge dataset [95] 15085 (covro-19=180, pneumonia= 6054, normal= 8851) 3 (COVID-19, pneumonia, normal) 5- fold cross-validation Concatenated CNN Accuracy=99.50, Sensitivity=80.53, Specificity=99.56, Precision=35.27
Mukheijee et al. [127] covid-chestxray-dataset [88], Kaggle chest x-ray repository [93] 260 (COVID-19=130, non-COVID=130) 2 (COVID-19, non-COVID) 5- fold cross-validation Shallow CNN Accuracy= 96.92, Sensitivity= 94.20, Specificity=100, Precision=100, Fl-Score=97.01, AUC=99.22
Li et al. [128] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88], Kaggle dataset [89], Kermany et al. [90] 2239 (COVID-19=239, pneumonia=1000, normal=1000) 3 (COVID-19, pneumonia, normal) 5-fold cross-validation DCSL Accuracy=97.01, Sensitivity=97.09, Precision=97, Fl-Score=96.98
Khobahi et al. [129] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88], RSNA Pneumonia Detection Challenge dataset [95], COVIDx Dataset [99] 18,529 (COVID-19=99, non-COVID-pneumonia=9579, healthy=8851) 3 (COVID-19, non-COVID pneumonia, healthy) Training=90%, Testing=10% CoroNet (AutoEncoders) Accuracy=93.50, Sensitivity=93.50, Precision=93.63, Fl-Score=93.51
Alqudah et al. [130] COVID-19 X-ray image database [88] 71 (COVID-19=48, non-COVID-19=23) 2 (COVID-19, non-COVID-19) Training=70%, Testing=30% CNN, SVM, RF Accuracy=95.2, Sensitivity=93.3, Specificity=100, Precision= 100
Farooq and Hafeez [131] COVIDx Dataset [99] 13, 800 4 (COVID-19, normal, bacterial, viral) Training=90%, Testing=10% COVID-ResNet (CNN) Accuracy= 96.23, Sensitivity=100, Precision=100, Fl-Score=100
Afshar et al. [132] COVIDx Dataset [99] 13, 800 3 (COVID-19, normal, non-COVID-19) Training=90%, Testing=10% COVID-CAPS (Capsule Network) Accuracy 95.7, Sensitivity=90, Precision=95.8, AUC=97