Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 7;8:671951. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2021.671951

Table 4.

Risk of bias assessment.

Study participation Study attrition Prognostic factor measurement Outcome measurement Study confounding Statistical analysis and reporting Overall risk of bias Included in quantitative synthesis
Yang et al. (27) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Osterlind et al. (28) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Zarzecka et al. (29) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0003.jpg no
Hermes et al. (30) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Wang et al. (31) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Berardi et al. (32) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Sengupta et al. (33) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Kobayashi et al. (34) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Fucá et al. (35) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Alamoudi (36) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0003.jpg no
Hansen et al. (37) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Svaton et al. (38) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Allan et al. (39) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Li et al. (40) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Osterlind et al. (41) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Doshi et al. (42) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Johnson et al. (43) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Jacot et al. (45) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Umemura et al. (51) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Sagman et al. (44) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg no
Hong et al. (46) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Maestu et al. (47) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Kawahara et al. (48) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Cerny et al. (49) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg yes
Ma et al. (50) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg yes
Jacot et al. (52) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Rechnitzer et al. (53) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Bose et al. (54) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0003.jpg no
Rinaldi et al. (55) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Chan et al. (56) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
Huang et al. (57) graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg n.a. graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0001.jpg no
graphic file with name fmed-08-671951-i0004.jpg
[CHART]