TABLE 3.
PROM | Article | Structural validity | Internal consistency | Cross-cultural validity | Reliability | Measurement error | Criterion validity | Construct validity | Responsiveness | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Convergent validity | Known groups validity | Comparison with gold standard | Comparison with other instruments | Comparison between subgroups | Comparison before and after intervention | ||||||||
BCLE-SEI | Shi et al., 201621 | A | V | I | D | D | D | ||||||
FLQA-I | Augustin et al., 200522 | V | I | A | I | I | |||||||
FLQA-LS | Augustin et al., 201837 | I | V | D | |||||||||
LISS | Weiss and Daniel, 201528 | V | I | V | D | D | D | ||||||
Degirmenci et al., 201939 | D | V | I | D | |||||||||
Haghighat et al., 201840 | D | V | I | A | I | ||||||||
LLIS 2.0 | Weiss and Daniel, 201823 | V | I | I | I | A | |||||||
Orhan et al., 202041 | D | D | I | D | I | ||||||||
Abu Sharour, 202042 | I | V | D | ||||||||||
LSIDS-A | Ridner and Dietrich, 201529 | V | I | A | |||||||||
LSIDS-H&N | Deng et al., 201230 | ||||||||||||
LSIDS-L | Ridner et al., 201835 | V | D | D | |||||||||
Lymph-ICF | Devoogdt et al., 201131 | V | I | I | A | A | |||||||
Kostanoglu et al., 201643 | V | I | I | I | A | ||||||||
Grarup et al., 201944 | V | I | I | ||||||||||
Lymph-ICF-UL | De Vrieze et al., 201927 | V | I | I | A | ||||||||
Lymph-ICF-LL | Devoogdt et al., 201432 | V | I | I | A | ||||||||
Kostanoglu et al., 201745 | V | I | A | ||||||||||
Wang et al., 201846 | I | V | I | D | |||||||||
LYMQOL | Keeley et al., 201033 | V | I | I | D | I | D | ||||||
LYMQOL-arm | Bakar et al., 201747 | I | V | D | I | I | D | ||||||
Borman et al., 201848 | A | V | I | V | |||||||||
Karayurt et al., 201949 | A | V | I | ||||||||||
LYMQOL-leg | van de Pas et al., 201650 | I | V | I | I | A | |||||||
Bakar and Tuğral, 201951 | I | V | D | V | |||||||||
Borman et al., 202052 | A | V | I | A | D | ||||||||
LyQLI | Klernäs et al., 201538 | D | V | I | A | ||||||||
Klernäs et al., 201836 | A | V | |||||||||||
PBI-L | Blome et al., 201424 | A | V | A | I | ||||||||
Duygu et al., 202053 | V | I | D | ||||||||||
(S)LQOLI | Klernäs et al., 201025 | D | A | ||||||||||
ULL-27 | Launois and Alliot 200034 | I | V | I | D | I | I | ||||||
Launois et al., 200218 | V | V | I | V | A | D | D | ||||||
Viehoff et al., 200854 | V | D | D | D | |||||||||
ULLQoL | Williams et al., 201826 | A | V | I | A | D |
Empty cells indicate that no information was available on this item
PROM patient-reported outcome measure, V very good, A adequate, D doubtful, I inadequate