TABLE 3.
Cases in which results of conventional culture and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing were discordant
Sample | Conventional culture |
Age (mo) | Symptom(s) | Method of urine collection | Leukocyte esterase | WBC |
16S rRNA gene sequencing |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Organism(s) and CFU/ml | Interpretation | Count | Unit | Most abundant organism (relative abundance) | Interpretation | |||||
6355 | E. coli ≥100,000 | Likely | 6.0 | Fever | Catheter | Negative | 14 | WBC/mm3 | Escherichia (0.46) | Unlikely |
6407 | E. coli ≥100,000 | Likely | 11.4 | Fever | Catheter | Moderate (++) | 100 | WBC/mm3 | Escherichia (0.897) | Possible |
6038 | E. coli ≥100,000 | Likely | 47.6 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 100 | WBC/mm3 | Escherichia (0.61) | Possible |
9004 | E. coli ≥100,000 | Likely | 51.0 | Urinary symptomsa | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 277 | WBC/hpfb | Escherichia (0.37) | Unlikely |
6512 | No growth | Unlikely | 5.9 | Fever | Catheter | Moderate (++) | 25 | WBC/mm3 | Enterococcus (0.56) | Possible |
3004 | No growth | Unlikely | 41.5 | Urinary symptoms | Clean catch | Small (+) | Escherichia (0.82) | Possible | ||
9010 | No growth | Unlikely | 96.7 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 62 | WBC/hpf | Proteus (0.72) | Possible |
6401 | E. coli 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 9.8 | Fever | Catheter | Large (+++) | 23 | WBC/mm3 | Escherichia (0.99) | Likely |
6434 | E. coli 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 8.3 | Fever | Catheter | Small (+) | 33 | WBC/mm3 | Bacteroides (0.44)c | Unlikely |
9021 | Proteus 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 82.5 | Urinary symptoms | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 244 | WBC/hpf | Proteus (1.00) | Likely |
6382 | E. coli ≥100,000; Gram-positive cocci ≥100,000 | Possible | 76.2 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 100 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (0.37) | Unlikely |
1081 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 55.8 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 203 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (0.98) | Likely |
6175 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 93.4 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 135 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (1.00) | Likely |
6496 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 56.4 | Fever | Clean catch | Moderate (++) | 272 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (0.92) | Likely |
6322 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 57.9 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 100 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (0.98) | Likely |
6342 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 30.8 | Fever | Clean catch | Small (+) | 25 | WBC/mm3 | Lachnospiraceae (0.42) | Unlikely |
6353 | Pseudomonas ≥100,000; Klebsiella 10,000–50,000 | Possible | 8.8 | Fever | Catheter | Small (+) | 13 | WBC/mm3 | Pseudomonas (0.99) | Likely |
1082 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 63.5 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 400 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (0.99) | Likely |
6023 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 67.6 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 182 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (1.00) | Likely |
6418 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 43.7 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 100 | WBC/mm3 | Escherichia (0.94) | Likely |
6500 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 66.2 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 97 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (1.00) | Likely |
6521 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 40.1 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 377 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (1.00) | Likely |
9001 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 44.2 | Urinary symptoms | Clean catch | Moderate (++) | 58 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (0.96) | Likely |
9011 | E. coli ≥100,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 118 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 181 | WBC/hpf | Escherichia (1.00) | Likely |
6069 | E. coli ≥100,000; Gram-positive cocci <10,000 | Possible | 62.2 | Fever | Clean catch | Large (+++) | 100 | WBC/mm3 | Escherichia (0. 94) | Likely |
6446 | E. coli 10,000–50,000; multiple organisms <10,000 | Possible | 47.4 | Fever | Clean catch | Moderate (++) | 72 | WBC/mm3 | Ezakiella (0.24) | Unlikely |
Urgency, frequency, dysuria, hesitancy, or incontinence.
hpf, high-powered field.
E. coli relative abundance, 25%.