Table 2.
Subgroup analysis of incivility prevalence according to characteristics of included studies
|
Type of
Incivility |
Subgroup |
Number of
Studies |
Prevalence | (95% CI) |
Heterogeneity %
(P- Value) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Verbal | Country Classification | ||||
| Developed | 14 | 15.70% | 29.57, 58.81 | 98.99% (< 0.001) | |
| Developing | 21 | 15.59% | 49.26, 68.69 | 99.17% (< 0.001) | |
| Instrument | |||||
| WHO | 25 | 75.57% | 49.22, 65.87 | 98.93% (< 0.001) | |
| NAQ | 1 | 76.45% | 70.71, 81.35 | 0% (< 0.001) | |
| Verbal scale | 1 | 24.96% | 92.77, 98.08 | 0% (< 0.001) | |
| Other | 8 | 17.74% | 55.98, 88.86 | 99.24% (< 0.001) | |
| Setting | |||||
| General | 25 | 62.69% | 53.48, 71.45 | 99.15% (< 0.001) | |
| Emergency/Acute Care | 4 | 74.29% | 47.20, 93.97 | 98.18% (< 0.001) | |
| Psychiatric | 6 | 60.25% | 41.67, 77.43 | 99.12% (< 0.001) | |
| Sampling Method | |||||
| Random | 18 | 66.22% | 55.28, 76.35 | 99.28% (< 0.001) | |
| Convenience | 10 | 60.99% | 49.36, 72.02 | 98.09% (< 0.001) | |
| Not Reported | 7 | 60.29% | 38.19, 80.39 | 99.23% (< 0.001) | |
| Physical | Country Classification | ||||
| Developed | 14 | 25.54% | 14, 39.13 | 99.29% (< 0.001) | |
| Developing | 20 | 21.23% | 15, 32.38 | 99.17% (< 0.001) | |
| Instrument | |||||
| WHO | 24 | 20.15% | 13.71, 27.46 | 99.06% (< 0.001) | |
| NAQ | 1 | 72.31% | 66.36, 77.57 | 0% (< 0.001) | |
| Verbal scale | - | - | - | - | |
| Other | 9 | 30.58% | 16.28, 47.11 | 99.21% (< 0.001) | |
| Setting | |||||
| General | 24 | 20.18% | 14.36, 26.69 | 98.89% (< 0.001) | |
| Emergency/Acute Care | 5 | 19% | 8.78, 31.91 | 94.91% (< 0.001) | |
| Psychiatric | 5 | 51.42% | 24.91, 77.51 | 99.54% (< 0.001) | |
| Sampling Method | |||||
| Random | 20 | 24.54% | 15.52, 34.85 | 99.44% (< 0.001) | |
| Convenience | 9 | 24.12% | 11.01, 40.32 | 99.03% (< 0.001) | |
| Not Reported | 5 | 22.75% | 7.73,42.68 | 98.83% (< 0.001) | |
| Sexual | Country Classification | ||||
| Developed | 9 | 20.67% | 9.26, 35.12 | 98.91% (< 0.001) | |
| Developing | 13 | 9.57% | 5.41, 14.74 | 97.42% (< 0.001) | |
| Instrument | |||||
| WHO | 17 | 10.25% | 6.11, 15.28 | 97.97% (< 0.001) | |
| NAQ | - | - | - | - | |
| Verbal scale | - | - | - | - | |
| Other | 5 | 28.04% | 13.28, 45.73 | 97.99% (0.00) | |
| Setting | |||||
| General | 16 | 13.18% | 7.53,20.10 | 98.71% (0.00) | |
| Emergency/Acute Care | 4 | 14.09% | 2.71, 31.93 | 96.85% (0.00) | |
| Psychiatric | 2 | 22.61% | 19.37, 26.02 | 0% (0.00) | |
| Sampling Method | |||||
| Random | 14 | 13.48% | 8.23, 19.77 | 98.02% (0.00) | |
| Convenience | 6 | 11.63% | 0.89, 31.42 | 98.02% (0.00) | |
| Not Reported | 1 | 24.63% | 21.43, 27.97 | 0% (0.00) | |
| Mobbing | No Subgroup | 10 | 35.69% | 21.23, 51.60 | 98.77% (0.00) |
| Psychological | No Subgroup | 7 | 54.27% | 30.65,76.92 | 99.58% (0.00) |