Table 2.
Delivery System/Scaffold |
System | Microorganisms | Findings | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
MW | ||||
DDA | ||||
Particles and carriers | CNPs: Chitosan 50–190 KDa DDA: 75–85% Antimicrobial peptide LL-37 |
MRSA | MRSA-infected wound model in mice: No growth of MRSA was observed in the group treated with LL-37 loaded CNPs after 7 days. This antibacterial effect was superior to all other treatment conditions. |
[64] |
CNPs: Chitosan 50–190 kDa DDA: n.a. Cefadroxil |
S. aureus |
S. aureus-infected wound model in rats: CNPs loaded with cefadroxil embedded in in situ poloxamer 407 hydrogel showed a significant reduction in the bacterial burden in the wounds and complete healing after 5 days. |
[184] | |
CNPs: Chitosan LMW DDA: 75–85% Vancomycin hydrochloride |
MRSA | MRSA-infected wound model in mice: the rats treated with pH-responsive CNPs comprising gemini surfactants loaded with vancomycin displayed a significantly reduced bacterial burden compared with both drug-free CNPs and free vancomycin. |
[185] | |
Excipient and coatings | Beads: Chitosan MW: n.a. DDA: 90% Zinc oxide NPs |
Noninfected wound model in mice: The bacterial growth in the wound without induced infections treated with any of the chitosan/PVA/zinc beads was lower than the control. Almost no growth was observed in mice treated with chitosan, chitosan/PVA, or the loaded beads. |
[176] | |
Chitosan-functionalized graphene quantum dots: Chitosan oligosaccharide MW: n.a. DDA: n.a. Graphene quantum dots |
S. aureus |
S. aureus-infected wound model in rats: the rats treated with the chitosan-functionalized quantum dots composite together with illumination exhibited improved wound healing compared to all the other groups. |
[186] | |
Polymer-based gels | Hydrogel: Chitosan LMW DDA: >85% Terbinafine hydrochloride |
C. albicans |
C. albicans-infected wound in rats: chitosan hydrogel loaded with vesicles comprising penetration enhancers produced a significant reduction of C. albicans in the wound bed. |
[187] |
Hydrogel: Cyclodextrin-modified chitosan 15–22 kDa DDA: 75−80% Diclofenac Silver ions |
P. aeruginosa |
P. aeruginosa-infected wound in a murine model: β-cyclodextrin modified chitosan supramolecular hydrogel loaded with diclofenac and silver ions displayed improved wound healing and reduced the bacterial load in the wound bed. |
[188] | |
Hydrogel: Chitosan MW: n.a. DDA: ≥95% Silver nitrate Calcium sulfate dehydrate Zinc nitrate hexahydrate Copper nitrate trihydrate |
S. aureus | S. aureus-infected wound model in mice: The chitosan/ion hydrogel in gauzes surpassed chitosan alone and the control group in wound healing. Additionally, the group treated with the chitosan/ion hydrogel in gauzes significantly reduced bacterial load in the wound bed compared with chitosan alone. | [189] | |
Hydrogel: Chitosan 300–450 kDa DDA: 85–95% Silver sulfadiazine |
S. aureus |
S. aureus-infected burn and wound model in mice: The healing rate of the wounds treated with the silver sulfadiazine nanocrystal in the hydrogel was faster, and the overall healing was superior to a cream formulation in both the burn and wound model. |
[190] | |
Hydrogel: Chitosan MW: 100−150 kDa DDA: 85% Ciprofloxacin Fluconazole |
S. aureus
E. coli C. albicans |
Polymicrobial wound model in rats: The ciprofloxacin and fluconazole-loaded fibrin NPs loaded in chitosan hydrogel bandage displayed a significant reduction in microbial load in the infected wound compared to the unloaded- fibrin NPs loaded in chitosan. However, there was still some microbial growth after 14 days. |
[191] | |
Hydrogel: Chitosan (maleic anhydride grafted chitosan) MW: n.a. DDA: n.a. Antimicrobial peptide Hydrogen peroxide |
MRSA | MRSA biofilm-infected wound model in mice: The hydrogel loaded with antimicrobial peptide and hydrogen peroxide displayed a significant reduction in bacterial viability compared to all other treatments; however, not complete eradication. Chitosan alone reduced bacterial viability. Wound closure also improved in the groups treated with the coloaded hydrogel. |
[192] | |
Scaffolds | Film: Chitosan 50–190 kDa DDA: 75–85% S-nitrosoglutathione |
MRSA | MRSA biofilm-infected wound model in mice: Both loaded and unloaded chitosan films reduced the bacterial burden in the wound and improved the healing rate compared to the control group. However, the NO-releasing film displayed a significantly improved healing and dispersal of the biofilm. |
[193] |
Film: Chitosan 200 kDa DDA: 85% Catechol |
MRSA | MRSA-infected wound model in rats: The bacterial load in the group treated with the catechol-chitosan film at a reduced state was significantly reduced compared with the other groups. Additionally, the tissue in this group appeared normal. |
[194] | |
Film: Chlorinated chitosan MMW DDA: 75–85% Chloramine |
MRSA | MRSA-infected wound model in mice: Chlorinated chitosan film produced with electrofabrication induced faster wound healing and reduced the wound’s bacterial burden, compared to the control and plain chitosan. |
[195] | |
Membrane: Chitosan MW: n.a. DDA: 87% Silver sulfadiazine |
P. aeruginosa,
S. aureus |
S. aureus and P. aeruginosa infected-wound model in rats: The membranes significantly reduced the bacterial load in the wounds compared to the control group with a rapid initial eradication. |
[196] | |
Dressing: Chitosan 190–310 kDa DDA: 75–85% Silver NPs |
P. aeruginosa |
P. aeruginosa-infected wound model in mice: The mice treated with the polyelectrolyte complex had a reduced bacterial load in the tissue after 14 days of treatment and higher survival than mice treated with gauze. |
[197] | |
Nanofibers: Chitosan ≈250 kDa DDA: n.a. Indocyanine green |
MRSA | MRSA-infected wound model in rats: The indocyanine green-loaded chitosan/PVA nanofibers and illumination demonstrated improved wound healing and reduced bacterial burden in the wound bed compared to all other treatment groups. |
[198] | |
Dressing loaded with microspheres: Chitosan MMW DDA: ≥85% Gentamycin sulfate |
S. aureus
E. coli |
S. aureus and E. coli-infected wound model in rats: The group treated with gelatin microspheres loaded with gentamycin and platelet-rich plasma on chitosan dressing displayed reduced bacterial load and a faster wound healing rate than the group treated with gauze. |
[199] | |
Dressing: Chitosan MMW DDA: 97% Graphene oxide Copper NPs |
S. aureus |
S. aureus-infected wound model in mice: The group treated with the graphene oxide–copper composite in chitosan/hyaluronic acid hydrogel improved wound healing compared with all other groups. |
[200] | |
Sponge: Chitosan 10–30 kDa DDA: ≥95% Silver NPs |
S. aureus |
S. aureus-infected wound model in rabbits: the group treated with the silver NP-sponge healed faster than the control group, and although not statistically significant, faster than the marketed silver dressing. |
[201] | |
Sponge: Chitosan MW: 500 kDa DDA: 90% Quaternary ammonium CNPs |
S. aureus |
S. aureus-infected wound model in mice: the chitosan sponges loaded with quaternary ammonium CNPs exhibited superior antimicrobial activity compared to sponges without CNPs and untreated mice on days 7 and 10. |
[202] |
n.a.: not applicable/not denoted; CNP: chitosan nanoparticles, DDA: degree of deacetylation, LMW: low molecular weight, MMW: medium molecular weight, MRSA: methicillin-resistant S. aureus, MW: molecular weight, PVA: poly(vinyl alcohol).