Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 5;13(12):2090. doi: 10.3390/pharmaceutics13122090

Table 3.

Advantages and disadvantages of non-amplifying mRNA Vaccines and SAM Vaccines.

mRNA Vaccines Structure Advantages Disadvantages References
Non-amplifying mRNA Vaccines Basic structure of the mRNA, with a coding region for the desired antigens. - Relatively small mRNA size (~2–3 kb).
- Absence of additional proteins, minimizing unwanted immune interactions.
- Relatively easy to produce and amplify.
- Simplified sequence engineering.
- Direct antigen expression.
- Potential toxicity from modified nucleotides.
- Short duration of expression.
- Need for high RNA doses.
- Low antigen quantity.
[8,86]
SAM Vaccines Encode a manipulated RNA virus genome (replicon). It generally contains two different protein coding regions, one encoding nonstructural proteins involved in mRNA capping and replication, and the other in antigen expression. - High yield of target antigen.
- Enhanced and prolonged antigen expression.
- Lower effective RNA doses (more safe).
- Intrinsic adjuvant effect.
- Potential apoptosis of vaccine-carrying cells due to vaccine self-amplification (enhanced cross-presentation).
- Option for single-vector delivery of multiple or complex antigens.
- RNA replicons are not able to tolerate many of the synthetic nucleotide modifications and sequence alterations.
- Inclusion of unrelated proteins, which may increase unwanted immunogenicity.
- Large replicon size (~10 kb), decreasing cell internalization efficiency.
- Interaction between nsPs and host factors yet to be addressed.
- Longer RNA length (more difficult production).
- Potential elevated inflammation.
[8,13,29,86,93]