Table 2.
First Author, Country | Age, Years | Study Design | Sample Size | Method and Duration/ Time Period |
Database Used to Estimate the Intake | Source(s) of Choline | Choline Intake (mg/day) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fawcet et al. (2020), United States [34] | Not reported. | Prospective longitudinal study | n = 251 | 3 day food records completed during the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd trimester | Nutrient Data System for Research | FO | Mean (SD not reported) = 281 |
Moore et al. (2020), United Kingdom [35] | Mean (SD) = 31.4 (4) years | Be Healthy in Pregnancy (B-HIP) study, baseline data of a RCT | n = 232 | 3 day weighed diet record (2 week days and 1 weekend day) completed at 12–17 weeks gestation |
Nutritionist Pro™ diet analysis software | F+S | Median (min, max) = 338 (120, 1016) |
Zhu et al. (2020), China [36] | Mean (SD) = 28 (4) years | Case–control study (SQ FFQ retrospective collecting dietary intake during pregnancy) | Mothers of n = 157 term controls | SQ FFQ, validated, 120 food items including the most common foods in the Chinese diet conducted no later than 3 days after parturition | China Food Composition and the USDA Food Composition Database | FO | Energy-adjusted choline intake in the controls Median (IQR) = 255 (70) |
Probst et al. (2019), Australia [19] | Range 19–50 years |
Cross-sectional study based on data from the Australian National Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey 2011–12 | n = 116 | 2 day intake data (data filtered for women who were pregnant at the time of the survey) | Sourced studies and global food composition databases, compared with data for Australian foods to create a choline database | FO | Median (IQR) = 251 (111) |
Bailey et al. (2019), United States [16] | Range 20–40 years |
Cross-sectional study based on data from NHANES (2001–2014) | n = 533 | 24 h dietary recall ×2 (taking part in the What We Eat in America survey) | USDA Food Composition Database 2019 | FO | Mean (SD) = 321 (231) |
Pauwels et al. (2017), Belgium [37] | Range 25–41 years |
A longitudinal Maternal Nutrition and Offspring’s Epigenome study (MANOE) | 1st trimester: n = 94 2nd trimester: n = 85 3rd trimester: n = 82 |
FFQ, validated: 51 items completed at 11–13, 18–22, and 30–34 weeks of pregnancy | Not reported | F+S | Mean (SD) = 1st trimester: 274 (72); 2nd trimester: 268 (68); 3rd trimester: 280 (78) |
Wallace et al. (2017), United States [18] | Range 13–44 years |
Cross-sectional study based on data from the 2009–2014 and 2005–2014 NHANES (2009–2014 and 2005–2014) datasets | n = 593 | 24 h dietary recalls ×2 | Various USDA food composition databases used |
F+S | Mean (SD) = 319 (241) |
Groth et al. (2017), United States [38] | Range 18–36 years |
Prospective observational study, secondary analysis of the Limiting the Phenotypic Effect of Pregnancy-Related Weight Gain | 1st trimester: n = 90 2nd trimester: n = 68 3rd trimester: n = 67 |
24 h dietary recalls ×3 at three timepoints: early (<22 weeks), mid (24–29 weeks), and late (32–37 weeks) pregnancy. | Nutrition Data System for Research software 2009 | FO | Mean (SD) = 1st trimester: 318 (68); 2nd trimester: 289 (28); 3rd trimester: 306 (28) |
Masih et al. (2015), Canada [39] | Mean (SD) = 32 (5) years | Prospective observational study, the Prenatal Folic Acid Exposure on DNA Methylation in the newborn infant study | n = 290 | SQ FFQ, validated: 110 items; recall of habitual intakes between 0–16 and 23–27 weeks gestation | Nutrition Quest used the nutrient composition data primarily from version 1.0 of the USDA Food and Nutrient Database | F+S | Mean (SD) = 1st trimester: 306 (127); 3rd trimester: 302 (122) |
Goon et al. (2014), Bangladesh [40] | Range 21–25 years |
Cross-sectional study | n = 103 | 24 h dietary recall in the 7th, 8th, or 9th months of pregnancy | USDA Food Composition database | FO | Mean (SD) = 190 (98) |
Lewis et al. (2014), Canada [41] | Range 17–30 years (45.8%) 31–45 years (54.2%) |
Prospective cohort study, the Alberta Pregnancy Outcomes and Nutrition (APrON) cohort study | 1st trimester: n = 123; 2nd trimester: n = 562; 3rd trimester: n = 493 |
24 h dietary recall using the multiple-pass method in each trimester | The Alberta database used the USDA Database for the Choline Content of Common Foods, Release 2 (634 foods) |
F+S | Mean (SD) = 1st trimester: 340 (148); 2nd trimester: 349 (154); 3rd trimester: 353 (144) |
Mygind et al. (2013), New Zealand [20] | Range 18–40 years | Baseline part of dietary data collection for a folate intervention study | n = 125 | 3 day weighed food record Two weekdays and one weekend day | USDA Choline Content of Common Foods, Release 2, 2008 | FO | Median (IQR) = 310 (87) |
Wu et al. (2012), Canada [42] | Not reported | Prospective study | n = 154 | FFQ, women enrolled from 16 weeks gestation | USDA Choline Content of Common Foods, Release 2, 2008 | FO | Mean (SD) = 383 (99) |
Villamor et al. (2012), United States [43] | Mean (SD) = 33 (5) years | Project Viva longitudinal study | 1st trimester: n = 1148 2nd trimester: n = 1083 |
FFQ in the first and second trimester (26–28 weeks gestation) | Harvard nutrient composition database | F+S | Mean (SD) = 1st trimester: 332 (63); 2nd trimester: 325 (64) |
EFSA (2016), Latvia [12,44] | Range 15–45 years |
Food Consumption data from the EFSA European Comprehensive Food Consumption Database | n = 990 | 24 h dietary recall in pregnancy | Not reported | FO | Pregnant adolescents: Mean = 336; Pregnant women: Mean (5th, 95th percentiles) = 356 (200, 592) |
Gossell-Williams et al. (2005), Jamaica [45] | Range 18–32 years |
Observational study | n = 16 | FFQ (Jamaican foods) recruited at 10–15 weeks gestation | USDA Food Composition database | FO | Mean (SD) = 279 (116) |
EFSA, European Food Safety Authority; FFQ, food frequency questionnaire; FO, foods only; F+S, foods and supplements; IQR; interquartile range; NHANES, National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey; RCT, randomised controlled trial; SD, standard deviation; SQ FFQ, semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire; USDA, United States Department of Agriculture.