Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 6;7(6):811–833.

Table 4. Summary of studies investigating the safety and efficacy of SIRT.

Independent studies

Study Total CP ECOG PVTT Extra-hepatic involvement Tumor characteristic Safety and Efficacy
Kulik et al. 2008 [102] n=108 A/B/C=54/27/1 0–2 37 13 Unresectable
Intermediate-advanced
PR: WHO 42.2%, EASL 70%
No treatment-related complications or deaths
Mazzaferro et al. 2013 [103] n=52 A-B7 0–1 35 None Intermediate-advanced mOS=15 months
ORR=40.4%
TTP=11 months
Salem et al. 2010 [104] n=291 A=131
B=152
C=8
0–2 125 46 All stages ORR: WHO=42%, EASL=57%
TTP=7.9 months
mOS: CP A/B=17.2/7.7 months
Sangro et al. 2011 [105] n=325 A=268
B=57
0–3 76 30 All stages mOS=12.8 months
(BCLC A, B, C=24.4, 16.9, 10 months)
Lewandowski et al. 2018 [106] n=70 A NA 0 0 Early-stage
PVTT: absent
RR 6-months=EASL (86%), WHO (49%)
TTP=2.4 years

Meta-analysis

Lobo et al.[107] 2016 n=553 (5 comparative studies, with quality assessed by the STROBE criteria) CR and PR: No significant difference (vs cTACE)
Vs. cTACE: Less post-treatment pain, more subjective fatigue; no difference in nausea, vomiting, fever, or other complications
Massani et al. 2016 [108] n=1431 (8 studies) OS: No significant difference (vs. TACE)
Adverse events: Less than TACE
Yang et al. 2018 [96] n=1652 (11 studies, including 2 RCTs) OS: Increased 2-year OS
OR: Better (vs. TACE, mRECIST criteria)
Adverse events: Less than cTACE
Gardini et al. 2018 [109] n=97 (3 RCTs) OS, PFS: No significant difference at 1-year
Bridging: Higher proportion underwent transplant

c-TACE: Conventional TACE; CP: Child-Pugh; DEB-TACE: Drug-eluting bead TACE; ECOG: Eastern Co-operative Oncology Group performance status; ORR: Objective response rates; OS: Overall survival; PVTT: Portal vein tumor thrombosis; RCT: Randomized controlled trials; RR: Response rate: SIRT: Selective internal radiation therapy; TTP: Time to progression; STROBE: Strengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology criteria