SPPF-Dex nps |
Plasmid |
Photothermal regulation |
12.8% indel mutation rate in HCT 116-GFP cells |
Low toxicity, endolysosomal escape, payloads release |
Less loading |
In cell, in vivo
|
Li et al. (2019)
|
Au nanorod (APC) |
Plasmid |
Photothermal regulation |
18.0% indel mutation rate in Hepa1-6 cells, 6.7% indel mutation in the liver tissue |
Specific binding |
Surface modification is needed to bind genes effectively |
In cell, in vivo
|
Chen X. et al. (2020)
|
AR@PSS@PCM(ANP) |
Plasmid |
Photothermal regulation |
39.7% indel mutation rate in B16F10 cells, 21.5% in tumor |
Good biocompatibility, promote intracellular delivery |
prone to negatively charge cells and proteins |
In cell, in vivo
|
Tang et al. (2021)
|
Protamine–AuNCs |
Plasmid |
Cationic protamine facilitates release |
27.5% indel mutation rate in HeLa cells |
Cell-penetrating properties, nucleus-targeting |
Reunion |
In cell |
Tao et al. (2021)
|
Photolabile semiconducting polymer nanotransducer |
Plasmid |
Photosensitive regulation |
Indel 15- and 1.8-fold enhancements in cells and living mice |
Efficient release of gene vectors |
Low particle surface potential |
In cell, in vivo
|
Lyu et al. (2019)
|
NTA-SS-PEG-PCL/Ce6 Complex |
Cas9 RNP |
Photosensitive regulation |
42.6% indel mutation rate in CNE-2 cells, 31.2% indel mutation rate in tumor |
Stability, low toxicity, tumor targeting |
Cytotoxicity |
In cell, in vivo
|
Deng et al. (2020)
|
UCNPs-Cas9@PEI |
Cas9 RNP |
Photosensitive regulation |
Inhibited cancer cell proliferation and tumor growth |
Endosomal escape |
Low particle surface potential, less loading |
In cell, in vivo
|
Pan et al. (2019)
|
Upconversion nanoparticles |
Plasmid |
Photosensitive regulation |
Inhibited cancer cell proliferation and tumor growth |
Light stability, low potential toxicity, no background light interference |
Low particle surface potential |
In cell, in vivo
|
Chi et al. (2021)
|
Au nanoparticles |
Plasmid |
Photothermal regulation |
1.24% indel mutation rate inA375 cells, sustainable tumor inhibition |
High loading efficiency, good stability, good repetition |
Surface modification is needed to bind genes effectively |
In cell, in vivo
|
Wang et al. (2018)
|
NIR light-triggered thermo-responsive copper sulfide (CuS) |
Cas9 RNP |
Photothermal regulation |
37.3%indel mutation rate in A375 cells, 23.8% indel mutationin in tumor |
Assist endosomal escape |
Reunion, cytotoxicity |
In cell, in vivo
|
Chen et al. (2021)
|
Electroporation |
RNP, plasmid |
Transient transfection, easy to cause damage to cell membranes |
High transfection efficiency |
Small dependence on cell types, equipment cost |
Easy to cause damage to cell membranes |
In cell |
Chen S. et al. (2019)
|
Viral vector (AAV, LV, AdV) |
Plasmid |
Has been approved for human clinical trials, cause virus contamination |
Stable, high transfection efficiency |
High capacity |
Introduce virus contamination, immune response |
In cell, in vivo
|
Moreno et al. (2020)
|
Lipofectamine |
RNP, plasmid |
Simple preparation, good safety, low cost |
High transfection efficiency |
Simple preparation, good safety |
Prone to immune response |
In cell, in vivo
|
Liu et al. (2020)
|