Table 2.
Authors, ref | Year | Country | Study design | Data collection | Disease | Sample size | Medication | Follow-up year | % Dose escalation | % Efficacy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Afif et al. 11 | 2009 | USA | Observational | Medical records | UC | 20 | ADA | 0.46 | 35 | NA |
Amiot et al. 12 | 2016 | France | Prospective | 41 centres | UC | 121 | VDZ | 1 | up to 47 | NA |
Armuzzi et al. 13 | 2013 | Italy | Retrospective | 22 centres | UC | 88 | ADA | 1.29 | 35.2 | NA |
Baert et al. 14 | 2014 | Belgium | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 73 | ADA | 1.69 | 30.1 | NA |
Baki et al. 15 | 2015 | Germany | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 37/54 | ADA/IFX | 2.25 | 45.9/48.1 | NA |
Black et al. 16 | 2015 | England | Retrospective | Data base | UC | 191 | ADA | NR | 43.5 | NA |
Cesarini et al. 17 | 2014 | Europe | Retrospective | Data base | UC | 41 | IFX | 1 | All at LOR | 92 |
Christensen et al. 18 | 2015 | Denmark | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 33 | ADA | 0.62 | 21.2 | NA |
Dumitrescu et al. 19 | 2015 | France | Retrospective | Data base | UC | 157 | IFX | 1.8 | All at LOR | 55 |
Hussey et al. 20 | 2016 | Ireland | Retrospective | Data base | UC | 52 | ADA | 1 | 25 | NA |
Iborra et al. 21 | 2016 | Spain | Retrospective | Data base ENEIDA | UC | 263 | ADA | > 1 | 35.4 | NA |
Null et al. 22 | 2017 | USA | Retrospective | Data base | UC | 295 | ADA/IFX | 1 | 50/37.3 | NA |
Patel et al. 23 | 2017 | USA | Retrospective | Claims database | UC | 1699 | Anti-TNF | 3 | 16/44 | NA |
Rostholder et al. 24 | 2012 | USA | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 56 | IFX | 3.17 | 54 | 19 |
Sandborn et al. 25 | 2016 | USA | Retrospective | Chart reviews | UC | 804 | ADA/IFX | 1.5 | 5/11 | NA |
Taxonera et al. 26 | 2017 | Spain | Retrospective | 14 centres | UC | 79 | IFX | 1.25 | All at LOR | 58 |
Yamada et al. 27 | 2014 | Japan | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 33 | IFX | 3 | 70.8 | 94 |
Aguas et al. 28 | 2012 | Spain | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 29 | ADA | 1 | 17.2 | NA |
Amiot et al. 29 | 2015 | France | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 59 | IFX | 12 | 13 | NA |
Baert et al. 30 | 2013 | Belgium | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 720 | ADA | 1.2 | 68 | 67 |
Bhalme et al. 31 | 2013 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 54/76 | ADA/IFX | 7 | 20/6 | NA |
Bortlik et al. 32 | 2013 | Hungary | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 84 | IFX | 2 | 7 | NA |
Bouguen et al. 33 | 2015 | France | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 42 | ADA | 0.5 | All | 85 |
Bultman et al. 34 | 2012 | Netherlands | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 122 | ADA | 1.8 | 38 | 43 |
Castano-Milla et al. 35 | 2015 | Spain | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 46 | ADA | 1 | 20 | 33 |
Caviglia et al. 36 | 2007 | Italy | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 40 | IFX | 1.2 | 9 | NA |
Chaparro et al. 37 | 2012 | Spain | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 33 | IFX | 3 | 40 | NA |
Chaparro et al. 38 | 2011 | Spain | Prospective | Data base | CD | 15 | IFX | 0.5 | 17 | NA |
Echarri et al. 39 | 2015 | Spain | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 68 | ADA | 2 | 18 | 75 |
Fortea-Ormaechea et al. 40 | 2011 | Spain | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 174 | ADA | 1.5 | 33 | NA |
Gagniere et al. 41 | 2015 | France | Prospective | 4 centres | CD | 61 | IFX | 1.2 | 52 | NA |
Gonzalez-Lama et al. 42 | 2008 | Spain | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 169 | IFX | 0.5 | 13 | NA |
Ho et al. 43 | 2009 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 98 | ADA | 2 | 24–55 | NA |
Juillerat et al. 44 | 2015 | France | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 267 | IFX | 5 | 31 | NA |
Karmiris et al. 45 | 2009 | Belgium | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 168 | ADA | 2 | 60 | 76 |
Katz et al. 46 | 2012 | Multinational | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 168 | IFX | 1 | 32 | NA |
Kiss et al. 47 | 2011 | Hungary | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 201 | ADA | 1 | 16 | NA |
Kopylov et al. 48 | 2011 | Multinational | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 94 | IFX | 1 | All | NA |
Lees et al. 49 | 2009 | Scotland | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 202 | ADA/IFX | 2.4 | 53 | NA |
Lindsay et al. 50 | 2013 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 380 | IFX | 2 | 5 | NA |
Lopez Palacios et al. 51 | 2008 | Spain | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 22 | ADA | 4 | 27 | 67 |
Magro et al. 52 | 2014 | Portugal | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 148 | IFX | 12 | 19 | NA |
Molnár et al. 53 | 2012 | Hungary | Retrospective | Data base | CD | 61 | ADA/IFX | 1 | 62 | NA |
Ng et al. 54 | 2009 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 34 | ADA/IFX | 1.5 | 29 | 100 |
Nichita et al. 55 | 2010 | Switzerland | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 55 | ADA | 3 | 24 | 15 |
Orlando et al. 56 | 2012 | Italy | Retrospective | Multi centres | CD | 110 | ADA | 1.4 | 9 | NA |
Oussalah et al. 57 | 2010 | France | Prospective | Medical records | CD | 88 | IFX | 2.5 | 17 | 86 |
Oussalah et al. 58 | 2009 | France | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 53 | ADA | 3 | 10–17 | NA |
Pariente et al. 59 | 2012 | France | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 76 | IFX | 3.5 | 51 | NA |
Peters et al. 60 | 2014 | Netherlands | Retrospective | Data Base | CD | 438 | ADA | 1 | 40 | NA |
Peyrin-Biroulet et al. 61 | 2007 | France | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 24 | ADA | 1 | 25 | NA |
Reenaers et al. 62 | 2012 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 207 | ADA | 6 | 81 | NA |
Riis et al. 63 | 2012 | Norway | Retrospective | Data base | CD | 83 | ADA/IFX1 | 1 | 5.3/17 | NA |
Russo et al. 64 | 2010 | England | Retrospective | Data base | CD | 61 | ADA | 0.7 | 16 | NA |
Schnitzler et al. 65 | 2009 | Belgium | Retrospective | Data base | CD | 614 | IFX | 5 | 49.8 | NA |
Sprakes et al. 66 | 2012 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 210 | IFX | 2 | 2 | NA |
Sprakes et al. 67 | 2011 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 44 | ADA | 2 | 18 | NA |
Viazis et al. 68 | 2015 | Greece | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 322 | ADA/IFX | 2.2 | 24 | NA |
West et al. 69 | 2008 | Netherlands | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 30 | ADA | 0.8 | 27 | 75 |
Ehrenberg et al. 70 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Insurance database | IBD | 2406 | IFX | 1 | 39 | NA |
Ehrenberg et al. 70 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Insurance database | IBD | 1966 | ADA | 1 | 28 | NA |
Ehrenberg et al. 70 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Insurance database | IBD | 1745 | VDZ | 1 | 23 | NA |
Ehrenberg et al. 70 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Insurance database | IBD | 472 | UST | 1 | 22 | NA |
Ehrenberg et al. 70 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Insurance database | IBD | 154 | GOL | 1 | 14 | NA |
Dignass et al. 71 | 2020 | Germany | Retrospective | Insurance database | UC | 125 | ADA | 3 | 73 | NA |
Dignass et al. 71 | 2020 | Germany | Retrospective | Insurance database | UC | 47 | GOL | 3 | 18.5 | NA |
Dignass et al. 71 | 2020 | Germany | Retrospective | Insurance database | UC | 114 | IFX | 3 | 65.3 | NA |
Church et al. 72 | 2019 | Canada | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 125 | IFX | 1 | 42 | NA |
Cesarini et al. 17 | 2014 | Italy | Retrospective | Multi centres | UC | 41 | IFX | 1 | All | NA |
Kósa et al. 73 | 2020 | Hungary | Retrospective | Nationwide | CD | 873 | IFX/ADA | 1 | 9/22 | NA |
Ungar et al. 74 | 2019 | USA | Retrospective | Medical records | IBD | 48 | IFX | 1 | ALL | NA |
Jasurda et al. 75 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Medical records | IBD | 380 | ADA | 1 | 52 | NA |
Duveau et al. 76 | 2017 | France | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 124 | ADA | 1 | ALL | NA |
Taxonera et al. 26 | 2017 | Spain | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 184 | ADA | 1 | 41 | NA |
Suzuki et al. 77 | 2019 | Japan | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 203 | ADA | 1 | 7 | NA |
Van de Vondel et al. 78 | 2018 | Belgium | Retrospective | 10 centres | UC | 231 | ADA | 1 | 56 | NA |
Shmidt et al. 79 | 2018 | Europe, USA | Retrospective | Multi centres | IBD | 788 | VDZ | 1 | 12 | NA |
Vaughn et al. 80 | 2020 | USA | Prospective | S +6erum level check |
IBD | 192 | VDZ | 0.5 | 30 | NA |
Perry et al. 81 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 90 | VDZ | 0.5 | 27 | NA |
Haider et al. 82 | 2020 | USA | Retrospective | Medical records | CD | 143 | UST | 1.5 | 19 | NA |
Fumery et al. 83 | 2020 | France | Retrospective | Multi centres | CD | 100 | UST | 0,7 | ALL | 61 |
Kopylov et al. 84 | 2020 | Multinational | Retrospective | Multi centres | CD | 142 | UST | 0.5 | ALL | 51 |
Ollech et al. 85 | 2021 | USA | Retrospective | Multi centres | CD | 506 | UST | 1 | 22 | NA |
Ma et al. 86 | 2017 | Canada | Retrospective | Multi centres | CD | 104 | UST | 1 | 16.3 | NA |
Honap et al. 87 | 2020 | England | Retrospective | Medical records | UC | 134 | TOF | 0.5 | 14 | NA |
Sands et al. 88 | 2020 | Multinational | Prospective | OLE OCTAVE | UC | 57 | TOF | 1 | ALL | 49 |
Sandborn et al. 89 | 2007 | Multinational | Prospective | CLASSIC | CD | 204 | ADA | 1 | 43.6 | 75 |
ADA, Adalimumab; CD, Crohn’s disease; GOL, Golimumab; IBD, Inflammatory bowel disease; IFX, infliximab; LOR, loss of response; TOF, Tofacitinib; UC, ulcerative colitis; UST, Ustekinumab; VDZ, Vedolizumab.
Dose escalation has been performed either increasing the dose or shortening the administration interval.