TABLE 2.
Studys | Rat strain | Rat age | Duration and type of habituation | Corticosterone levels | Respiration rate | Type of MRI study | Motion Levels |
Present study | Male Lister Hooded | 4 weeks | Gradually introduced rats to the experimental conditions, 3 weeks 20–60 min/day | FCM levels return to pre-handling values after habituation | 85 ± 7 breaths/min on last habituation day | Task-based auditory fMRI | Mean (± S.E.M.) SD of translations: 5.8 ± 0.9 μm (X), 9.3 ± 2.2 μm (Y). Mean (± S.E.M.) RMS: 0.9 ± 0.05 μm. Mean (± S.E.M.) FD: 11.6 ± 0.4 μm |
King et al., 2005 | Male Sprague Dawley | / | Rats exposed to the final experimental conditions, 8 days, 90 min/day | Plasma corticosterone levels significantly decreased on day 5 and 8 compared to day 1 of habituation. | ∼95 ± ∼7.5 breaths/min on day 8 | Resting state fMRI | Mean (± S.E.M.) SD of translations: ∼60 ± ∼50 μm (X), ∼150 ± ∼40 μm (Y). |
Febo, 2011 | Male Sprague Dawley | / | Rats exposed to the final experimental conditions, 5 days, 20–50 min/day | / | / | stimulus fMRI | / |
Chang et al., 2016 | Male Sprague Dawley | Adult | Rats exposed to the final experimental conditions, 8–10 days, 30 min/day | Plasma corticosterone levels showed a trend toward decreasing on day 8 of the habituation, but increased significantly during the fMRI scan. | 73.9 ± 6.1 breaths/min during fMRI experiments | Resting state and stimulus (air puff) fMRI | / |
Ferenczi et al., 2016 | Female Long-Evans TH-Cre rats and Wild-type male Sprague Dawley rats | / | Rats exposed to the final experimental conditions, 5–10 days, 5–45 min/day | / | > 100 breaths/min during fMRI experiments | Optogenetic fMRI | Mean (± S.E.M.) RMS: 65 ± 3 μm. |
Ma et al., 2017, 2020 | Male Long-Evans | Adult | Rats exposed to the final experimental conditions, 7 days | / | ∼ 82 breaths/min | Resting state fMRI | Mean (± S.E.M.) FD: 150 ± 20 μm (2017), 50 ± 3 μm (2020) |
Stenroos et al., 2018 | Male Wistar | Adult | Rats exposed to the final experimental conditions, 4–9 days, 15–45 min/day | Plasma corticosterone levels return to baseline by day 5 of habituation. | ∼ 160 breaths/min | Resting state fMRI | / |
In this table the habituation strategy presented in the current work (“present study”) is compared with other published strategies. With the exception of our study, none of the strategies used adapted a gradual habituation of the animals to the awake fMRI condition, rather the animals were habituated to all aspects of the final awake condition over a period of days. Differences in stress (reflected by corticosterone levels) and motion levels (far right column) are reported where available, as indicators of the final habituation outcome.