Table 3.
Study number | Reference | Country | Sample size | Period | Main outcomes |
1 | Adler-Milstein et al [24] | United States | 191 hospitals | 2 years | EHRa adoption is associated with better performance in terms of payment and length of stay in well-run institutions. EHR adoption may be associated with worse performance in poorly run institutions. |
2 | Adler-Milstein et al [25] | United States | 2591 hospitals (2011) | 4 years | Degree of EHR adoption is positively correlated with process adherence, patient satisfaction, and efficiency. |
3 | Castellanos et al [26] | Germany | Not indicated | 6 years | Small increase in profit in the year after the introduction of the patient data management system. |
4 | DesRoches et al [27] | United States | 3049 hospitals | 6 months | Presence of clinical decision support is associated with small quality gains. No relationship between EHR level and overall risk-adjusted length of stay, risk-adjusted 30-day readmission rates, and risk-adjusted inpatient costs. |
5 | Elnahal et al [28] | United States | 3101 hospitals | 9 months | Higher rates of adoption of key EHR functions among high-quality hospitals. |
6 | Encinosa and Bae [29] | United States | 2619 hospitals | 1 year | EMRsb do not reduce the rate of patient safety events. In case of patient safety events, EMRs reduce deaths, readmissions, and spending. |
7 | Feblowitz et al [30] | United States | Not indicated | 2 years | Length of stay increased after implementation of an electronic documentation. Mean time to disposition for admitted patients remained stable. |
8 | Furukawa et al [31] | United States | 5066 hospitals | 10 years | Advanced EMR applications may increase hospital costs and nurse staffing levels, as well as increase complications and decrease mortality for some conditions. |
9 | Furukawa et al [32] | United States | 509 hospitals | 5 years | Nurse-sensitive patient outcomes improved. EMR implementation may be associated with reduced demand for nurses. |
10 | Himmelstein et al [33] | United States | 4000 hospitals | 6 years | Hospital computerization has not achieved savings on clinical or administrative costs. More computerized hospitals might have a slight quality advantage for some conditions. |
11 | Jarvis et al [34] | United States | 2988 hospitals | 1 year | Most advanced EHRs have the greatest payoff in improving clinical process of care scores. |
12 | Jones et al [35] | United States | 6057 hospitals | 4 years | Availability of basic EHR is associated with a significant increase in health care quality for heart failure. |
13 | Joynt et al [36] | United States | 1236 hospitals | 4 years | Patients with stroke are more likely to receive guideline-driven components of care at hospitals with EHRs. Patients are slightly less likely to have a hospital stay longer than 4 days at hospitals with EHRs. |
14 | Kazley et al [37] | United States | 1000 hospitals | 1 year | In hospitals with advanced EHRs, patient costs are less compared with hospitals without advanced EHRs. |
15 | Lee et al [38] | United States | 708 hospitals | 8 years | Hospitals adopting EMRs experience shorter length of stay and lower 30-day mortality. |
16 | McCullough et al [39] | United States | 3401 hospitals | 4 years | Use of EHRs results in improvements in process-of-care measures for patients with heart failure or pneumonia. |
17 | Nakagawa et al [40] | Japan | Not indicated | 7 years | EMR may decrease medical risks, but profitability does not rise more than the investments. |
18 | Schenarts et al [41] | United States | Not indicated | 40 months | Implementation of the EMR is associated with an improvement in several complications and process measures. |
19 | Teufel et al [42] | United States | 2307 hospitals | 1 year | Advanced-stage EMR is associated with greater costs per case. |
20 | van Poelgeest et al [43] | Netherlands | 67 hospitals | 1 year | No statistically significant association between a hospital’s EMR adoption and an overall quality or safety performance. |
21 | Xue et al [44] | China | 251 physicians and 298,760 patient visits | 5 years | Length of stay declines and mortality rate decreases with EMR. An EMR has no positive effect on patient costs. |
22 | Yanamadala et al [45] | United States | 448,767 patients | 1 year | Patients at hospitals with full EHR have the lowest rates of inpatient mortality, readmissions, and patient safety indicators. |
23 | Zlabek et al [46] | United States | Not indicated | Not indicated | Implementation of an inpatient EHR results in a rapid improvement in measures of cost of care. |
aEHR: electronic health record.
bEMR: electronic medical record.