Table 7.
Quantitative comparison of COVID-19 detection methods. Accuracy (Acc.), F1-score, and the area under curve (AUC) are reported for comparison. SGD is the abbreviation for stochastic gradient descent, ReLu for rectified linear unit, lr for learning rate, and AF for activation function
| Method | Optimizer | AF | LR Scheduling | Images size | Pre-processing step | Dataset | Technique | Acc. | F1-Score | AUC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DL [125] | Adam | ReLu | lr = 0.0001 | 224 224 | Image resizing and data augmentation with rotation | COVID-19 | VGG-16, transfer learning | 97.97 | – | – |
| DL [107] | Adam | ReLu, Softmax | lr = 0.0001 and it reduces when there is no improvement for continuous three epochs | 224 224 | Image resizing, scaling, and data augmentation | COVID-19 | EfficientNet-B4, transfer learning, cross-validation | 96.70 | 97.11 | 96.66 |
| DL [76] | Adam | LeakyReLU, Softmax | lr = 0.001 | 128 128 | Image resizing, and data augmentation such as rotation and zoom | COVID-19, Kaggle [112] | InceptionNet-V3, XceptionNet, ResNext, transfer learning | 97.0 | 95.0 | – |
| DL [58] | Adam | ReLu | lr = 0.00001 with rate decay of 0.1 | 224 224 | Image resizing and data augmentation | COVID-19, Kermany [83] | SE-ResNext-50, transfer learning | 97.55 | – | – |
| DL [190] | Adam | ReLu | lr = 0.0001 | 224 224 | Image resizing, normalization, and data augmentation technique such as random rotation, width shift, height shift, horizontal flip | COVID-19, Kaggle[112] | VGG16, ResNet50, EfficientNetB0, synthetic image generation, cross-validation | 96.8 | – | – |
| DL [127] | Adam | – | lr = 0.0001 | 512 512 | Image normalization and resizing | CheXpert, Private | DenseNet-121, PCAM, Vision Transformer | 86.4 | – | 94.1 |
| DL [171] | Adam | ReLu, Softmax | lr = 0.000001 for 20 epochs and then 0.0000001 | 224 224 | Image resizing, normalization and data augmentation | COVID-19, RSNA, CheXpert, MC | ResNeXt-50, Inception-v3, DenseNet-161, transfer learning | 98.1 | – | – |