Coultas 2005.
Study characteristics | |
Methods | Design: RCT Follow‐up: 6 months Intervention 1: nurse‐assisted medical management (MM) Intervention 2: nurse‐assisted collaborative management (CM) Control group: usual care |
Participants |
Recruitment: primary care clinics Assessed for eligibility: 217 Randomly assigned: MM: 72; CM: 72; UC: 73 Completed: MM: 49; CM: 51; UC: 51 Mean age: MM: 68.3 (SD 6.6) years; CM: 70.1 (SD 7.0) years; UC 68.8 (SD 10.4) years Gender (% male): MM: 42.9%; CM: 32.7%; UC: 53.8% COPD diagnosis: COPD‐related diagnosis code (International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision: codes 491, 492, 496), FEV1 < 80%; FEV1/FVC < 70%, confirmed by authors Inclusion of participants in acute phase: no Major inclusion criteria: current or former smoker with at least a 20‐pack‐year smoking history, at least one respiratory symptom (e.g. cough, shortness of breath or wheeze), airflow obstruction (i.e. FEV1/FVC ratio, 70%; and FEV1, 80% predicted) during the past 12 months Major exclusion criteria: not reported |
Interventions |
Mode: MM: enhance participant knowledge. CM: enhance participant knowledge and facilitating the adoption of healthy behaviour including lifestyle and self‐management skills Duration: 1 face‐to‐face individual session (mean 64 min ± 23.1), mean 6.0 ± 1.8 telephone calls (10.0 min ± 5.4) Professional: nurse Assignment of case manager: no Self‐management components: smoking cessation (optional), self‐recognition of COPD exacerbations (optional), use of a COPD exacerbation action plan (optional), COPD medication intake (i.e. adherence, inhalation technique) (optional) Self‐management topics: coping with breathlessness, review of symptoms and medications, education about COPD symptoms and medications Behavioural change techniques: MM: 2 clusters: goals and planning, feedback and monitoring. CM: 3 clusters: goals and planning, feedback and monitoring, social support |
Outcomes | 1. Health status 2. SGRQ 3. SF‐36 4. Perceived illness intrusiveness 5. Doctor visits 6. ER visits 7. Hospital admissions |
Notes |
Note 1: baseline characteristics are given only for the group of participants who completed the six‐month follow‐up period.
Note 2: dropout percentages are high: MM: 32.0%; UC: 30.1%.
Note 3: participants who dropped out of the study had more severe airflow obstruction, higher levels of distress and lower quality of life compared with participants who completed the study.
Note 4: content of the interventions is not described properly, whereas the training of the nurses providing the intervention was described in detail.
Note 5: outcome measures of self‐efficacy and social support and BSI‐18 and CES‐D scores were measured but not reported in the article. Source of funding: a grant from Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Conflict of interest: not reported |