Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 10;2022(1):CD002990. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002990.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Aboumatar 2019 No verification of COPD
ACTRN12616001039471 One intervention component
Akinci 2011 Included in previous review update; non‐RCT / CRT
Ali 2018 No stratification on COPD
Altenburg 2015 No iterative process
Anonymous 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Ansari 2017 Non‐RCT / CRT
Apps 2013 Non‐RCT / CRT
Arbillaga‐Etxarri 2018 One intervention component
Barberan‐Garcia 2014 Non‐RCT / CRT
Barnestein‐Fonseca 2011 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified (with spirometry)
Baron 2011 No usual care / control group
Barradell 2017 No usual care / control group
Barradell 2018 No usual care / control group
Basri 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Bausewein 2012 No stratification on COPD
Bavarsad 2015 One intervention component
Beekman 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Bentley 2014 One intervention component
Benzo 2017 No verification of COPD
Benzo 2019 No usual care / control group
Berkhof 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Berkhof 2015 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Bhadhuri 2019 Non‐RCT / CRT
Bi 2021 No usual care / control group
Billington 2015 No usual care / control group
Bischoff 2011 Non‐RCT / CRT
Blackstock 2016 No usual care / control group
Bohingamu 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Boland 2014 No iterative process
Bosma 2011 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Bove 2016 One intervention component
Bower 2012 No stratification on COPD
Browne 2013 No usual care / control group
Buckingham 2015 No verification of COPD
Bunker 2012 No verification of COPD
Cameron‐Tucker 2011 Abstract of pilot study; no published results available
Cameron‐Tucker 2016 No usual care / control group
Carcereny 2016 One intervention component
Casanas 2019 No stratification on COPD
Casas 2006 Included in previous review update; not all participants meet COPD spirometry criteria
Casey 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Cecere 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Chan 2011 One intervention component
Chan 2016 No usual care / control group
Chang 2019 No usual care / control group
Chatwin 2014 No usual care / control group; no self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Chavannes 2009 Included in previous review update; non‐RCT / CRT
Chen 2011 One intervention component
Cheng 2017 One intervention component
Christenhusz 2012 No usual care / control group
Chuang 2011 Included in previous review update; non‐RCT / CRT
Collinsworth 2018 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified by spirometry
Cordova 2016 One intervention component
Coultas 2013 No usual care / control group
Coultas 2014 No usual care / control group
Coultas 2016 No usual care / control group
Coventry 2019 Non‐RCT / CRT
Csikesz 2016 No abstract or published results available
Cully 2012 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Cully 2017 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Dabrowska 2017 One intervention component
Davis 2016 Study was stopped due to participant recruitment issues
De Jongh 2013 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Demeyer 2017a One intervention component
Demeyer 2017b No verification of COPD
Deng 2013 Non‐RCT / CRT
De Roos 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
De San Miguel 2013 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Dewan 2011b No stratification on COPD
Dimitri 2012 No usual care / control group
Dogan 2017 Non‐RCT / CRT
Donesky 2012 No usual care / control group
Doward 2017 Non‐RCT / CRT
Drennan 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
DRKS00006021 One intervention component
Due 2014 Non‐RCT / CRT
Durheim 2014 No usual care / control group
Durheim 2015 No usual care / control group
Dwinger 2013 No stratification on COPD
Effing 2009 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Effing 2011 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Emme 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Etxarri 2017 One intervention component
EUCTR2013‐002671‐18‐AT No usual care / control group
Fairbrother 2011 Non‐RCT / CRT
Fairbrother 2013 Non‐RCT / CRT
Farmer 2014 No usual care / control group
Faulkner 2010 Included in previous review update; no home‐based exercise component
Ferreira 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Fish 2012 No stratification on COPD
Fitzsimmons 2011 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Fitzsimmons 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Flink 2017 No stratification on COPD
Folch‐Ayora 2019 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified with spirometry
Foot 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Fors 2018 No iterative process
Fortin 2013 No stratification on COPD
Freund 2016 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Frith 2017a No usual care / control group
Frith 2017b No usual care / control group
Gaeckle 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Garcia‐Aymerich 2007 No verification of COPD
Gellis 2012 No stratification on COPD
Goossens 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Goris 2013 One intervention component
Grabenhorst 2013 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Granados‐Santiago 2019 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Gurgun 2011 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Hæsum 2017 No iterative process
He 2015 Abstract only; no full‐text article available
Heaton 2019 No iterative process
Hegelund 2019 No iterative process
Heslop‐Marshall 2018 No iterative process
Hilberink 2011 No verification of COPD
Ho 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Houben 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Houben 2019 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Howard 2014 No usual care / control group
Huang 2017 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified with spirometry
ISRCTN30110012 No usual care / control group
ISRCTN32281812 Study was stopped due to participant recruitment issues
ISRCTN77785397 No usual care / control group
Janaudis‐Ferreira 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Jarab 2012 No iterative process
Jennings 2015 One intervention component
Ji 2019 One intervention component
Jokar 2012 No verification of COPD
Jonkers 2012 No verification of COPD
Kalter‐Leibovici 2018 No usual care / control group
Kanabar 2015 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Kara 2004 Included in previous review update; no home‐based exercise programme.
Kato 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Kenealy 2015 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Kennedy 2013 No stratification on COPD
Khan 2019 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Kheirabadi 2008 Included in previous review update; no verification of COPD
Khoshkesht 2015 No verification of COPD
Kiser 2012 No verification of COPD
Ko 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Koff 2009 Included in previous review update; no home‐based exercise programme
Korsbakke 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Kruis 2011 No iterative process
Kruis 2014a No iterative process
Kruis 2014b No iterative process
Labrecque 2011 Non‐RCT / CRT
Lahham 2018 No usual care / control group
Lainscak 2013 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Lam 2011 Non‐RCT / CRT
Larson 2017a No usual care / control group
Larson 2017b No usual care / control group
La Torre 2018 No stratification on COPD
Lavesen 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Lavesen 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Lee 2015 No iterative process
Leiva‐Fernandez 2011 One intervention component
Leiva‐Fernandez 2012 One intervention component
Leiva‐Fernandez 2014 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified with spirometry
Li J 2015 Abstract only; no full‐text article available
Lilholt 2015 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Lilholt 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Li P 2015 No iterative process
Li Z 2015 No published documents or information available
Lopez‐Lopez 2019 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Luhr 2018 One intervention component
Marchioro 2011 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Maricoto 2019 No stratification on COPD
Martinez 2014 Non‐RCT / CRT
Martinez 2019 One intervention component
McDonald 2011 Non‐RCT / CRT
Moayeri 2019 No verification of COPD
Monninkhof 2003 Included in previous review update; no home‐based exercise component
Morganroth 2011 No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Morganroth 2016 No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Moriyama 2015 Non‐RCT / CRT
Moullec 2008 Included in previous review update; non‐RCT / CRT
Moy 2015a No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Moy 2015b No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Moy 2016 No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Mozaffari 2018 No verification of COPD
Murphy 2011 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
NCT01543217 No usual care / control group
NCT01867970 No stratification on COPD
NCT01871025 One intervention component
NCT01897298 One intervention component
NCT01921556 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
NCT01985529 No usual care / control group
NCT02035566 No published documents or other information available
NCT02078622 No verification of COPD
NCT02085161 No usual care / control group
NCT02567474 No iterative process
NCT02742597 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
NCT02754232 Non‐RCT / CRT
NCT03387735 No stratification on COPD
NCT03654092 One intervention component
Ng 2017 No iterative process
Nguyen 2008 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Nguyen 2009 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Nguyen 2011 No usual care / control group
Nguyen 2012 No usual care / control group
Nguyen 2013 No usual care / control group
Nguyen 2016 One intervention component
Nguyen 2018 One intervention component
Nikoletou 2016 No usual care / control group
Ninot 2011 Included in previous review update; no home‐based exercise programme
NTR3945 One intervention component
Nyberg 2017 Non‐RCT / CRT
Nyberg 2019 Non‐RCT / CRT
O'Donnel 2018 Non‐RCT / CRT
O'Dwyer 2016 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Orme 2016 One intervention component
Orme 2018 No verification of COPD
Özkaptan 2016 Non‐RCT / CRT
Paneroni 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Papp 2017 No stratification on COPD
Pascual 2011 No stratification on COPD
Peian 2013 No verification of COPD
Perkins‐Porras 2018 No verification of COPD (physician diagnosis)
Phan 2015 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Pinnock 2012 Non‐RCT / CRT
Pinnock 2013 No usual care / control group
Pommer 2012 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Pothirat 2015 Non‐RCT / CRT
Poureslami 2016 No usual care / control group
Pradella 2015 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Rea 2004 Included in previous review update; no verification of COPD (by spirometry)
Renn 2018 No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Rice 2011 Non‐RCT / CRT
Ritchie 2012 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Ritchie 2016 No verification of COPD
Rixon 2017 No verification of COPD
Roberts 2011 No usual care / control group
Robinson 2019 No usual care / control group
Rojas‐Gomez 2014 No iterative process
Russo 2015 No usual care / control group
Saini 2018 Non‐RCT / CRT
Sanchez 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Sanders 2012 Non‐RCT / CRT
Sassi‐Dambron 1995 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Scalvini 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Schmidt 2018 No usual care / control group
Schou 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Schuz 2015 Non‐RCT / CRT
Scuffham 2018 No stratification on COPD
Seyedi 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Siddique 2012 No iterative process
Silva 2018 No usual care / control group
Silver 2017 No iterative process
Sinclair 2017 No stratification on COPD
Sink 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Slok 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Slok 2016a No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Slok 2016b No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Smidth 2014 No usual care / control group
Sohanpal 2012 No usual care / control group
Song 2014 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified with spirometry
Sorensen 2015 No verification of COPD; no iterative process
Soriano 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Stamenova 2019 No verification of COPD (by spirometry)
Steinhauser 2017 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Stenlund 2019 No verification of COPD
Steurer‐Stey 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Stolz 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Stoop 2015 No verification of COPD
Stulbarg 2002 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Talboom‐Kamp 2017a No RCT / CRT
Talboom‐Kamp 2017b Non‐RCT / CRT
Tang 2012 No verification of COPD
Tashkin 2012 One intervention component
Taylor 2012 No iterative process
Theander 2015 No stratification on COPD
Thom 2018 Not all participants have had their COPD diagnosis verified with spirometry
Thoonsen 2011 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Titova 2016 Non‐RCT / CRT
To 2019 One intervention component
Tommelein 2014 No verification of COPD
Tong 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Torres‐Sanchez 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Touchette 2012 No verification of COPD; no stratification on COPD
Trappenburg 2011 No usual care / control group
Troosters 2011 No usual care / control group
Tsai 2016 One intervention component
Udsen 2014 Study protocol; no iterative process
Ulrik 2013 Non‐RCT / CRT
Valderramas 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Valenza 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Van der Weegen 2015 No stratification on COPD
Van Wetering 2009 Included in previous review update; no home‐based exercise programme
Vasilopoulou 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Vayisoglu 2019 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Velardo 2017 No usual care / control group
Verwey 2014 No stratification on COPD
Vianello 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Vivodtzev 2012 One intervention component
Voncken‐Brewster 2015 No stratification on COPD
Vorrink 2016 One intervention component
Vorrink 2017 One intervention component
Wadell 2013 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wakabayashi 2011 Included in previous review update; no usual care / control group
Walker 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Walters 2012 Non‐RCT / CRT
Wan 2017 No usual care / control group
Wan 2019 No verification of COPD
Wang 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wang 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wang CH 2014 No usual care / control group
Wang H 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wang J‐X 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wang K 2017 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wang Y 2014 No iterative process
Wei 2014 One intervention component
Weldam 2016 No usual care / control group
Weldam 2017 No usual care / control group
Whelan 2019 No usual care / control group
White 2019 Non‐RCT / CRT
Wilson 2011 No usual care / control group
Wilson 2015 No usual care / control group
Windisch 2018 No usual care / control group
Wood‐Baker 2012 Non‐RCT / CRT
Wootton 2014 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wootton 2017 One intervention component
Wu M 2018 One intervention component
Wu W 2017 One intervention component
Wu W 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Wu X 2016 One intervention component
Xi 2015 No published documents or information available
Xin 2016 No iterative process
Yamaguti 2012 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Yan 2017 No published documents or information available
Yan 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Yan 2019 No usual care / control group
Yan J 2016 No usual care / control group
Yan XN 2016 No usual care / control group
Yazdani 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Yilmaz 2017 One intervention component
Ying 2013 One intervention component
Yu 2013 No usual care / control group
Yu 2014 Non‐RCT / CRT
Yuan 2015 No stratification on COPD
Zakrisson 2019 No verification of COPD (based on ICD codes)
Zambom 2011 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Zhai 2016 No published documents or information available
Zhang 2012 No published documents or information available
Zhang 2013 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Zhang 2014 No published documents or information available
Zhang H 2016 One intervention component
Zhang M 2016 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Zhao 2017 No published documents or information available
Zheng 2019 One intervention component
Zhou 2016 No usual care / control group
Zhu 2018 No self‐management / home‐based exercise programme
Zuo 2015 No published documents or information available
Zwar 2012 No verification of COPD
Zwar 2016 No verification of COPD
Zwerink 2013 No usual care / control group