Table 2.
Reference | Study Type | Participants | Methods (Stress Fracture Diagnosis) | Occupational Training Program | Methodological Quality Rating (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cosman et al. (2013) [15] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 891 | Orthopedist assessment X-ray | United States Military Academy Cadet Training | High (91) |
U.S. Military Academy cadets | |||||
Male: n = 755 | |||||
Mean ± SD Age: 18.7 ± 0.8 years; | CT scan or MRI | ||||
Female: n = 136 | |||||
Mean ± SD Age: 18.4 ± 0.8 years | |||||
Cowan et al. (2012) [22] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 1568 | At least two encounters with the same diagnosis, using ICD-9 codes 733.93 (tibia or fibula), 733.94 (metatarsals) and 733.95 (other bone) | Army Basic Training | Good (73) |
Females entering the U.S. Army | |||||
Dixon et al. (2018) [1] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 1065 | Not detailed | 32 Week Royal Marine Training Program | High (82) |
UK Royal Marine recruits | |||||
Knapik et al. (2012) [3] | Retrospective cohort | Total: n = 583,651 | ICD-9 codes | 10 weeks of basic training | High (100) |
U.S. military recruits from databases of the Armed Forces Health Surveillance | |||||
Females: n = 10,706 | |||||
Males: n= 475,745 | |||||
Knapik et al. (2018) [38] | Cross-sectional | Total: n = 583,651 | ICD-9 codes 733.1–733.19 and 733.93–733.98 | Army Basic Training | High (85) |
U.S. military recruits | |||||
Males: 475,745 | |||||
Females: 107,906 | |||||
Kucera et al. (2016) [27] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 9811 U.S. military cadets | ICD-9 codes | 2-month U.S. cadet Basic Training | Good (73) |
Lappe et al. (2001) [34] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 3758 female U.S. military recruits | Clinical assessment X-ray or CT scan |
8-week U.S. Basic Military Training including: | High (82) |
(1) March 225 km on gravel roads carrying a 10 kg pack and rifle | |||||
(2) Run 135 km on asphalt roads | |||||
(3) Approximately 1 h/day of physical training | |||||
(4) Traverse an ‘agility course’ four times during the last 4 weeks | |||||
Nunns et al. (2015) [9] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 1065 UK Royal Marine recruits | Medical examination | Royal Marine 32-week training program | Good (73) |
Logistic regression analysis to assess potential risk factors focused on subsamples of recruits who sustained a tibial stress fracture (n = 10) and an injury-free group (n = 120) | MRI | ||||
Pihlajamäki et al. (2019) [35] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 4029 male Finnish military recruits | ICD-9 or ICD-10 diagnosis codes indicating stress fracture | 8 weeks of basic military training including: | High (82) |
-17 h per week of combat skills, marching and other physically demanding training | |||||
-Carrying heavy loads | |||||
Pihlajamaki et al. (2006) [37] | Retrospective cohort | Total: n = 4029 male Finnish military recruits | Clinical examination | 8 weeks of basic military training including: | Good (73) |
X-ray | -17 h per week of combat skills, marching and other physically demanding training | ||||
MRI or CT scan | -Carrying heavy loads | ||||
Rauh et al. (2006) [8] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 824 female U.S. Marine Corps recruits | Clinical examination | Marine Corps Recruit depot basic training | High (91) |
X-ray | |||||
CT scan | |||||
Schaffer et al. (2006) [18] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 2962 female U.S. Marine Corps recruits | Clinical presentation with diagnostic imaging (X-ray, bone scan or both) | 13-week U.S Marine Corps basic training | High (82) |
Aged 17–33 years | |||||
Sanchez-Santos et al. (2017) [16] | Case-control | Total: n = 1082 UK Royal Marine recruits aged 16–33 years, including 86 cases with stress fractures | Clinical examination | 32 weeks of Royal Marine training | Good (77) |
X-ray | |||||
CT scan | |||||
Scheinowitz et al. (2017) [19] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 226 female Israeli military recruits | Clinical examination | 16-month combat Army Basic Training program in the Israeli Defense Forces | Good (64) |
X-ray | |||||
CT scan | |||||
Sormaala et al. (2006) [36] | Retrospective cohort | Total: n = 30 male Finnish military recruits, age range 18–26 years | Physical examination by orthopaedic surgeon | Military Training Program | High (82) |
X-ray | |||||
CT scan | |||||
Zhao et al. (2016) [21] | Prospective cohort | Total: n = 1398 male Chinese infantry recruits | Clinical examination | 8-week training program including marching, running, training exercises and stationary standing procedures | High (82) |
X-ray |