Table 3.
A review of some of the larger recent series of transoral approach with complications and outcomes
| Author and year | Number of cases | Complications | Outcomes | Levels fused | Remarks | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crockard et al. (1986)[6] | 68 | Vertebral artery injury-1, cord damage-1 Palatal dehiscence-2 CSF leaks-6 |
61 (90%) improved, 3 (4%) deteriorated, 1 died | Occipito-C2/C3 fusion | Transoral decompression relieve ventral compression in rheumatoid arthritis | - |
| Hadley et al. (1989)[7] | 53 | 5.6% wound dehiscence with CSF leak | 94% neurological improvement | Occipito-C3 levels | Good result for ventral pathology | 2 years |
| Dickman et al. (1992)[8] | 27 | None | 22 (81%) improved, 5 (19%) stabilized | 9 (33%) fusion of C1–C2, 10 (37%) occipitocervical fusion | Transoral decompression relieves decompression and fusion required in >70% patients and 90% of rheumatoid arthritis patients | 14 months |
| Tuite et al. (1996)[9] | 27 | Neurological deterioration-4 (15%), CSF leak-2, wound infection-3, palatal fistula-2 | 9 (33%) improved, 4 (15%) worse, 15 (52%) remained same | Occipito-C3/C5/T4 (1 patient) | Transoral surgery in congenital diseases requires less extensive surgery compared to oncological condition but associated with worse neurological outcomes | 4.6 years |
| Jain et al. (1999)[10] | 74 | Pharyngeal wound sepsis leading to dehiscence (20.3%) and hemorrhage (4%), velopharyngeal insufficiency (8.1%), CSF leak (6.7%) and inadequate decompression (6.7%) | 26 (55.3%) showed improvement from their preoperative status while 14 (29.8%) demonstrated stabilization of their neurological deficits. 7 (14.9%) of them deteriorated | C1-2-3 | TOD is logical and effective in relieving ventral compression due to craniovertebral junction anomalies; it carries the formidable risks of instability, incomplete decompression, neurological deterioration, CSF leak, infection and palatopharyngeal dysfunction | 3–24 months |
| Menezes (2008)[11] | 28 | Wound dehiscence 2, velopalatine insufficiency 5, retropharyngeal infection 1 | Neurological improvement in all patients | C1, C2, and C2–3 disc pathology | Indicated in irreducible pathology | - |
| Mouchaty et al. (2009)[12] | 53 | 2 mortality, 8 patients had morbidity – CSF leak, wound dehiscence, meningitis | 51 patients had improvement | C1, C2 | Indicated in severe BI | 4–96 months |
| Shousha et al. (2014)[13] | 139 | 3.6% wound infection early, late in 1 patient | 94% neurological improvement | - | Postoperative infections higher in rheumatic disease group | 4.5 years |
| Elbadrawi and Elkhateeb (2017)[14] | 20 | CSF leak wound dehiscence | Improvement in VAS and Nurick score | C2 | Safe and effective surgical method for the direct decompression of ventral midline extradural compressive disease of the craniovertebral junction | 29.4±3.8 months |
VAS – Visual analog scale; CSF – Cerebrospinal fluid