Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 15;117:98–107. doi: 10.1016/j.tranpol.2022.01.005

Table 4.

Results of the two-class latent class model.

Attribute Alternative Multinomial Logit Model
Error Component Latent Class Model
Class 1
Class 2
Estimate t-statistics Estimate t-statistics Estimate t-statistics
Travel context
COVID-19 restrictions policy
Lockdown Level 3 Not travel 1.07*** 14.1 2.09*** 9.79 2.5*** 3.73
Lockdown Level 2 Not travel 0.426*** 5.23 0.534*** 3.13 1.21** 2.06
Lockdown Level 1 Not travel −0.244*** −2.64 −0.676*** −3.77 −0.168 −0.373
Totally open Not travel −1.252 −1.95 −3.54
Travel Purpose
Work Not travel −0.209** −2.45 −0.589*** −3.12 0.817 1.64
Social Not travel 0.237*** 2.91 0.346* 1.87 0.869* 1.87
Shopping Not travel −0.181** −2.16 −0.18 −0.903 −0.945* −1.86
Leisure Not travel 0.153 0.42 −0.74
Alternative-specific attributes
Travel cost (€) Bus, Car, and SEB −0.178** −2.16 −0.267** −2.2 −0.048 −0.307
Travel time (min) All modes −0.304*** −6.15 −0.27*** −3.07 −0.52*** −4.4
Out-of-vehicle time (min) Bus −0.335 −1.12 −0.425 −0.8 −0.482 −0.553
Requirement of Facemask Bus 0.009 0.129 −0.173 −1.42 1.28 0.526
1.5-m social distance rule Bus −0.049 −0.721 −0.156 −1.24 1.24** 2.04
Offering hand rubs Bus −0.0381 −0.562 0.103 0.845 −0.23 −0.555
Onboard passengers' limitation (%)
25% of the total seats Bus 0.16 1.44 0.025 0.128 3.62** 2.26
50% of the total seats Bus 0.058 0.503 0.258 1.25 −1.54 −0.638
75% of the total seats Bus −0.045 −0.375 −0.0812 −0.388 −0.288 −0.116
100% of the total seats Bus −0.1731 −0.20 −1.79
Disinfection frequency
Every journey Bus 0.138 1.23 0.209 1.1 3.59 0.743
Once per 4 journeys Bus 0.19* 1.72 0.379* 1.9 4.48 0.945
Once per 8 journeys Bus −0.198 −1.55 −0.502** −2.15 −4.52 −0.94
Once a day Bus −0.13 −0.09 −3.55
ASCs
Constant 1 Car 0.494*** 4.13 2.92*** 3.08 5.26*** 3.17
Constant 2 Bus −0.781*** −3.58 −1.27 −0.968 −9 −0.507
Constant 3 Bike 1.38*** 15.3 3.4*** 4.47 5.78*** 3.75
Constant 4 SEB −2.12*** −11.3 −0.02 −0.0218 −0.221 −0.137
Constant 5 Walk 0.311 1.46 3.08*** 3.43 4.81*** 2.79
SD of the random panel effect parameter
Deviation 1 Car 6.69*** 3.57
Deviation 2 Bus 1.17 1.04
Deviation 3 Bike 7.5*** 3.2
Deviation 4 SEB 2.48* 1.9
Deviation 5 Walk 5.04*** 2.6
Error components for nests of alternatives parameters
Component Deviation Share Space 2.19* 1.82
Class membership
Constant 21.8*** 4.83 0 (fixed)
Education level (−1: HAVO/VWO and below, 1: Bachelor degree or above) −4.31*** −3.98 0 (fixed)
Gender (1: male, −1: female) 2.03*** 3.24 0 (fixed)
Job (−1: employed, 1: unemployed/retired) −0.244 −1.37 0 (fixed)
Marital (−1: single or couple with no children, 1: couple with one or more children) −2.38*** −3.69 0 (fixed)
Age (years) −0.877*** −4.79 0 (fixed)
Class probability 0.597 0.403
Goodness-of-fit
LL −4430.977 −4311.537
# of observations 3152 3152
# of parameters 23 58
ρ2 0.215 0.262
ρ2 0.211 0.252

Note: SEB means shared E-bike *** Estimates whose p-value are less than 0.01.** Estimates whose p-value are less than 0.05.* Estimates whose p-value are less than 0.10.