Skip to main content
. 2016 Jan 8;2016(1):CD012004. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012004
Study Reason for exclusion
Aasa 2015 Not MCE or mixed intervention
ACTRN12609000293268 Not MCE or mixed intervention
ACTRN12609000334202 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Aggarwal 2010 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Ahmed 2014 All groups received MCE
Ali 2006 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Allison 2012 Not a RCT
Aluko 2013 Acute LBP
Ammar 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Andrusaitis 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Appling 2009 Not a RCT
Barbosa 2013 Not a RCT
Belcher 1998 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Bentsen 1997 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Bi 2013 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Bilgin 2013 Not non‐specific LBP patients.
Bordiak 2012 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Brennan 2006 Acute LBP
Bronfort 1996 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Bronfort 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Brooks 2012 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Brox 2003 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Buchbinder 2002 Not a RCT
Byuon 2012 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Cairns 2003 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Chan 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Childs 2009 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Childs 2010 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Cho 2014 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Chung 2013 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Croft 1999 Not a RCT
Dehner 2009 Not a RCT
Descarreaux 2002 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Donzelli 2006 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Dufour 2010 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Durante 2010 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Dvorak 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Earde 2014 Did not evaluate any relevant outcome for this review
Ewert 2009 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Faas 1993 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Faas 1995 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Freitas 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Gagnon 2005 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Gatti 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
George 2011 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Gustafsson 2008 Not a RCT
Guven 2003 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Hagen 2010 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Hansen 1993 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Harkapaa 1989 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Harringe 2007 Not a RCT
Harts 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Helewa 1999 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Helmhout 2004 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Henchoz 2010 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Hides 1996 Patients with acute low back pain
Hides 2001 Patients with acute low back pain
Hides 2008 Not a RCT
Hunter 2012 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Hurwitz 2005 Not a RCT
Hwang 2013 Not MCE or mixed intervention
ISRCTN80064281 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Jang 2013 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Javadian 2015 Did not evaluate any relevant outcome for this review
Johannsen 1995 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Johnson 2007 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Jones 2007 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Kaapa 2006 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Karimi 2009 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Kladny 2003 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Kline 2013 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Kofotolis 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Koldas 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Kumar 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Kumar 2012 Not a RCT
Kuukkanen 1996 Not a RCT
Lee 2015 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Lewis 2005 All groups received MCE
Lie 1999 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Long 2004 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Magnusson 2008 Not a RCT
Mannion 1999 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Mannion 2009 Not a RCT
Mannion 2012 Not a RCT
Marshall 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Mohseni‐Bandpei 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Monteiro 2009 Not a RCT
Monticone 2004 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Moseley 2002b Not MCE or mixed intervention
Moseley 2003 All groups received MCE
Moussouli 2014 Not a RCT
Navalgund 2009 Not a RCT
NCT00624533 Not MCE or mixed intervention
NCT01061632 All groups received MCE
Nelson 1995 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Nelson‐Wong 2009 Not a RCT
Niemisto 2003 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Niemisto 2004 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Niemisto 2005 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Norris 2008 Not a RCT
O'Sullivan 1997 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Oguzhan 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Ota 2011 Not a RCT
Pereira 2010 Not a RCT
Riipinen 2005 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Rydeard 2006 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Saner 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Saner 2015 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Shakeri 2013 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Shnayderman 2012 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Shnayderman 2013 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Smeets 2009 Not a RCT
Smith 2011 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Sokunbi 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Streicher 2014 Not a RCT
Stuge 2004 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Suni 2006 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Teyhen 2010 Not non‐specific LBP patients
Torstensen 1998 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Trampas 2014 All groups received MCE
Wang 2012b Not MCE or mixed intervention
Willemink 2012 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Williamson 2008 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Xueqiang 2012 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Yang 2010 Not a RCT
Yelland 2004 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Yoo 2012 Not MCE or mixed intervention
You 2014 Not MCE or mixed intervention
Zhang 2015 Not MCE or mixed intervention

LBP: low back pain
 MCE: motor control exercise
 RCT: randomised controlled trial