Table 2.
Overview of Barriers and Facilitators for Implementation of the PHQ-4
Theme | Construct CFIR | Barriers and Facilitators |
---|---|---|
1. Quality of the intervention | Design quality and packaging (+, −) | • Characteristics and content PHQ-4 (+, −)•Characteristics and content manual (+) |
Relative advantage (+) | •Lack of depression and anxiety questionnaire (+)•Limited guidelines discussing mental health (+)•Added value for follow-up care (+) | |
Evidence strength and quality (+, −) | •Increasing attention for mental health (+)•Tool to discuss depression and anxiety (+)•Outcome represents mental health (problems) (+, −) | |
2. Applicability for clients of LVS organizations | Patient needs and resources (+, −)Adaptability (+, −) | •Suitability for all clients of LVS organizations (−)•Standard administration (+, −)•Practical challenges administration (−)•Administration modes (+) |
3. Attitude and needs clients | Patients’ needs and resources (+, −) | •Defensive, practical, and closed attitude (−)•Willingness to discuss mental health (+, −)•Preferences for health care providers that administer PHQ-4 differ (−)•Preferred moment of administration differs (−)•Clients’ focus on practical support for VI (−)•Influence health care provider on openness clients (+, −) |
Relative advantage (+, −) | •Importance of implementation PHQ-4 (+)•Preferences for current practice (−) | |
4. Attitude health care providers | Self-efficacy (+, −) | •Need for various competencies (−)•Need for knowledge (−)•Confidence in discussing mental health (+, −) |
Knowledge and beliefs (+, −) | •Implementation is important and necessary (+)•Reluctance to use PHQ-4 (−) | |
Available resources (+) | •Availability of suitable professions that can administer the PHQ-4 within LVS organizations (+) | |
5. Support within low-vision organizations | External policy and incentives (−) | •No clear mutual perspective on procedures for intakes and mental health care (−)•No clear mutual perspective on the PHQ-4 (−) |
Tension for change (+) | •(Increased) current attention for mental health (+)•Current limited guidelines (+) | |
6. Embedding in current practice | Compatibility (+, −) | •Applicability existing procedures (+)•Intensive and exploratory nature of intake (−)•Lack of follow-up procedures (−) |
Patients’ needs and resources (+, −) | •Variety of follow-up care (−)•Possibility for periodical assessments (+)•Preferred interval periodical assessments differ (−)•Record results in medical file (+) | |
Available resources (+, −) | •Limited costs (+)•High workload (−)•Increased burden clients and health care providers (−)•Integration in digital medical files (+) | |
Structural characteristics (−) | •Differences between locations (−)•Organizational changes (−) |
(−), barrier; (+), facilitator; (+, −), barrier and facilitator.