Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 14;26(1):89–103. doi: 10.1007/s40291-021-00567-x

Table 4.

Advantages and limitations of PCR-based methods identified by Genetic Testing Registry (GTR) screening for relevant biomarkers

PCR-based method Advantages Limitations Reference
ARMS (amplification refractory mutation system, allele-specific PCR)

Simple technique, quick, allele specific

Suitable to detect point mutations, small deletions and insertions

Determination of haplotypes in clinical diagnostics possible

Can also be multiplexed

Applicable also in resource-constrained circumstances due to low costs

Inefficient priming can occur Frayling et al. [18], Yang et al. [68], Little [69], Markou et.al [16]
ASPE Applicable for high-throughput analysis Further methods for analysis needed such as electrophoresise or matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI) mass spectrometry Breyer et al. [30]
KASP Identification of SNPs or InDels, cost-effective, can be multiplexed, applicable also in resource-constrained circumstances due to low costs Multiplexing limited to single bi-allelic SNP per reaction Suo et al. [70] , Shitaye [71], He et al. [72]
MLPA Fast, and relatively simple technique, low costs detection of CNVs and mosaic mutations

Sensitive to DNA quality and quantity

Ligation failure due to point mutations in probe binding site and therefore erroneously indication of deletions possible

No detection of balanced genomic rearrangements

Katsanis [38], Frayling et al. [18]
PCR–RFLP Simple and rapid technique for SNP genotyping, detection of point mutations and discrimination of homozygous and heterozygous samples Limited availability of suitable restriction enzymes Ota et al. [24]
QF-PCR Accurate and cost-effective method applied for detection of aneuploidy, detection of mosaicism No detection of structural abnormalities Mann and Ogilvie [73], Konjhodzic et al. [74]
qPCR

Closed-tube technique, limits danger of contamination

High sensitivity and specificity

Multiplexing of reactions and fast analysis possible

Limited combinations of fluorescent dyes for multiplexing Frayling et al. [18]
RT-PCR/q-RT-PCR Gene expression analysis Sensitive to RNA quality Murphy and Bustin [19]

Most frequenty applied techniques in both listings (‘Testing recommended’/‘Testing required’ and ‘Actionable PGx’) are shaded in bold

ARMS amplification refractory mutation system, ASPE allele-specific primer extension, KASP competitive allele-specific PCR, MLPA multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification, PCR polymerase chain reaction, QF-PCR quantitative fluorescent PCR, qPCR quantitative real-time PCR, RT-PCR reverse transcriptase PCR, RFLP Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis