Table 4.
Advantages and limitations of PCR-based methods identified by Genetic Testing Registry (GTR) screening for relevant biomarkers
| PCR-based method | Advantages | Limitations | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| ARMS (amplification refractory mutation system, allele-specific PCR) |
Simple technique, quick, allele specific Suitable to detect point mutations, small deletions and insertions Determination of haplotypes in clinical diagnostics possible Can also be multiplexed Applicable also in resource-constrained circumstances due to low costs |
Inefficient priming can occur | Frayling et al. [18], Yang et al. [68], Little [69], Markou et.al [16] |
| ASPE | Applicable for high-throughput analysis | Further methods for analysis needed such as electrophoresise or matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI) mass spectrometry | Breyer et al. [30] |
| KASP | Identification of SNPs or InDels, cost-effective, can be multiplexed, applicable also in resource-constrained circumstances due to low costs | Multiplexing limited to single bi-allelic SNP per reaction | Suo et al. [70] , Shitaye [71], He et al. [72] |
| MLPA | Fast, and relatively simple technique, low costs detection of CNVs and mosaic mutations |
Sensitive to DNA quality and quantity Ligation failure due to point mutations in probe binding site and therefore erroneously indication of deletions possible No detection of balanced genomic rearrangements |
Katsanis [38], Frayling et al. [18] |
| PCR–RFLP | Simple and rapid technique for SNP genotyping, detection of point mutations and discrimination of homozygous and heterozygous samples | Limited availability of suitable restriction enzymes | Ota et al. [24] |
| QF-PCR | Accurate and cost-effective method applied for detection of aneuploidy, detection of mosaicism | No detection of structural abnormalities | Mann and Ogilvie [73], Konjhodzic et al. [74] |
| qPCR |
Closed-tube technique, limits danger of contamination High sensitivity and specificity Multiplexing of reactions and fast analysis possible |
Limited combinations of fluorescent dyes for multiplexing | Frayling et al. [18] |
| RT-PCR/q-RT-PCR | Gene expression analysis | Sensitive to RNA quality | Murphy and Bustin [19] |
Most frequenty applied techniques in both listings (‘Testing recommended’/‘Testing required’ and ‘Actionable PGx’) are shaded in bold
ARMS amplification refractory mutation system, ASPE allele-specific primer extension, KASP competitive allele-specific PCR, MLPA multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification, PCR polymerase chain reaction, QF-PCR quantitative fluorescent PCR, qPCR quantitative real-time PCR, RT-PCR reverse transcriptase PCR, RFLP Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis