Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 30;11(1):38. doi: 10.3390/pathogens11010038

Table 1.

Current knowledge and research gaps for childhood tuberculous meningitis.

Research Area Current Knowledge Research Gaps
Pathogenesis
  • Novel biomarker and host genotype studies offer new insight into TBM pathophysiology

  • Young age is a major determinant of progression from TB infection to TBM

  • BCG vaccination and TB preventive therapy for children exposed to TB cases are important preventative strategies

  • Further understanding of the mechanism of TB dissemination from lungs to CSF and CSF invasion

  • Further understanding of host and pathogen factors that determine why some children develop TBM

Epidemiology
  • More than half of all children with TB globally are undiagnosed or unreported

  • Infants have an up to 20% risk of developing TBM following TB infection

  • Advanced disease stage at diagnosis is associated with high mortality and morbidity

  • The number of children with TBM are currently unknown, and modelling studies are needed to provide estimates of the burden, morbidity, and mortality in children globally

  • Operational research can help to identify and mitigate the impact of drivers behind diagnostic delays and missed opportunities for prevention

  • Improve mechanisms for reporting of TBM in all age groups to national TB surveillance programs

Diagnostics
  • TBM can be diagnosed with reasonable confidence with clinical, laboratory, and neuroimaging findings

  • MRI is superior to CT imaging for children being evaluated for TBM, both from a diagnostic perspective but also to delineate pathological and prognostic features

  • M. tuberculosis detection remains the ‘gold standard’ diagnostic test but is limited by poor sensitivity

  • Biomarkers have potential to improve our ability to discriminate children with TBM from children with other causes for their symptoms and signs

  • Establish validated clinical case definitions in adults and children taking into account different settings stages of TBM and HIV-status

  • Investigate the ability of MRI CSF flow imaging and thin slice CT to differentiate communicating and non-communicating hydrocephalus

  • Investigate utility of other modalities (e.g., 18F-PET/CT) to identify early small infarctions missed with conventional imaging

  • Develop new adequately sensitive, accessible, and rapid diagnostic tests, especially at point of care to allow prompt diagnosis

  • Further investigate the role of non- or less invasive TB testing (e.g., serum, urine, or saliva) in diagnosing TBM in patients where CSF is difficult or cannot be obtained

  • Further investigate the utility of new omic technology, transcriptional and metabolomic biomarkers in diagnosing TBM from other non-TBM CNS infections, including in various populations, stages of TBM, and HIV-status

Treatment
  • Current recommended doses of TB drugs to treat TBM do not reach optimal CSF levels

  • Higher doses of rifampicin are required to penetrate the blood CSF barrier

  • High CSF concentrations of isoniazid are associated with improved survival

  • To date, the only adjuvant therapy proven to reduce mortality in TBM is corticosteroids for up to 8 weeks

  • Neurocritical care in severe or complicated disease should be part of routine management of TBM

  • What is the optimal dose, drug regimen, and duration of TB drugs to adequately treat TBM? Is shortened therapy non-inferior to the standard 12 months?

  • Should patients who are fast acetylators receive different doses of isoniazid than slow acetylators?

  • Besides rifampicin, isoniazid, and pyrazinamide, which first or second-line TB drug is the most optimal 4th drug in a drug-susceptible TBM regimen?

  • When is the optimal time to start TB treatment in HIV-positive children?

  • Do the new second line TB drugs (bedaquiline, delamanid, and pretomanid) have a role in treating drug-resistant TBM?

  • Can new host-direct therapy (e.g., high-dose aspirin, thalidomide, and monoclonal-antibodies such as TNF-alpha inhibitors) reduce mortality or neurodisability in children with TBM?

  • What is the optimal management for CNS complications in TBM? (e.g., hydrocephalus, tuberculomas, and paradoxical reactions)

  • What is the optimal supportive and critical care in low-resourced settings to improve mortality and morbidity?

Long term morbidity
  • Morbidity and mortality from TBM remain unacceptably high, even if treated

  • Reasons for poor outcome are multifactorial; however, the most important predictor of poor outcome is diagnostic and treatment delay

  • Although the array of long-term sequelae is broad, the most common long-term outcomes are physical and developmental disability

  • Neurocognitive deficits can occur without physical disability and have important psychosocial and educational consequences for children, especially those with immature brains

  • Establish validated and culturally appropriate tools to assess neurodevelopment and function in children with TBM

  • Standardisation of patient follow up and strengthened surveillance to include physical, neurocognitive, and neurodevelopmental assessments

  • Evaluation of whether optimised anti-TB therapy and host-directed therapy could improve long-term neurodevelopmental and neurocognitive outcomes across various paediatric age ranges

  • Evaluation and characterisation of early intervention and targeted neurorehabilitation services to improve long-term outcomes

TBM: tuberculous meningitis; TB: tuberculosis; BCG: bacille Calmette–Guérin; CSF: cerebrospinal fluid; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; CT: computerised tomography; PET: positron emissions tomography; CNS: central nervous system; TNF: tumour necrosis factor.