Table 1.
Identification | Location | Sample | Method Used to Determine Prenatal Folate Level | Maternal Folate Assessment | Dose of Folic Acid Intake or Mean Levels in Blood | Offspring’s/Children’s Age at the Time of Assessment | Offspring’s/Children’s Assessment | Main Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Animal Studies | ||||||||
[48] Craciunescu et al., 2010 | United States | Fetal mice | Diet supplementation | Embryonic days 11–17 | Control diet: 2 mg folic acid/kg diet; 1.1 g choline chloride/kg diet |
Embryonic day 17 | Histological and immune-histochemical assays of fetal brain regions of interest | Folate-deficient mice had fewer neural progenitor cells undergoing mitosis in the septum and greater apoptosis rates in the septum and hippocampus compared to the control mice |
Folate-deficient diet: 10.0 mg folic acid/kg diet, 1 g choline chloride/kg diet | ||||||||
Folate-deficient choline-supplemented diet: 0.0 mg folic acid/kg diet, 4.95 g choline chloride/kg diet | ||||||||
[68] Jadavji et al., 2015 | Canada | Methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR)-deficient male mice | Diet supplementation | 6 weeks prior to breeding until the end of lactation | Folate-deficient diet: 0.3 mg folic acid/kg diet | 3-week-old male mice | Novel object recognition task, Y-maze task | Maternal folate deficiency in mice was associated with short-term memory impairment in offspring |
Folate sufficient diet: 2 mg folic acid/kg diet | ||||||||
[69] Ferguson et al., 2005 | United States | 20 female mice per group. 4 males and 4 females/litter were retained for initial behavioral testing. 1 male and 1 female pup/litter were used in postweaning behavioral testing | Diet supplementation | 8 weeks prior to breeding until the end of gestation | Folate-deficient diets: (1) 400 nmol folic acid/kg diet and (2) 600 nmol folic acid/kg diet |
Postnatal days 4–83 | Righting reflex, negative geotaxis, forelimb hanging, motor coordination using Rotarod apparatus, open field activity, elevated plus maze | Maternal folate deficiency in mice produced offspring who exhibited more anxiety-related behavior in the elevated plus maze |
Folate sufficient diet: 1200 nmol folic acid/kg diet | ||||||||
Human Studies | ||||||||
[70] Julvez et al., 2009 | Spain | 420 mother-child pairs | Maternal self-report questionnaire used to determine whether supplements containing folic acid were taken | First trimester | No or yes | 4 years of age | McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities, California Preschool Social Competence Scale | Verbal, motor-executive function, verbal-executive function, social competence and inattention symptom scores were positively associated with maternal use of folic acid supplements |
[71] Wehby and Murray 2008 | United States | 6774 mother-child pairs | National survey that included data as to whether supplements containing folic acid had been taken | First trimester | No or yes | 3 years of age | 16 items from the Denver Developmental Screening Test | Prenatal folic acid supplementation had a positive effect on children’s overall cognitive and gross motor development |
[72] McNulty et al., 2019 | United Kingdom | 37 mother-child pairs in the treatment group and 33 mother-child pairs in the placebo group | Supplements or placebos distributed to the women in 7-day pillboxes | 14 weeks gestation until the birth of the child | 400 ug/day supplement containing folic acid | 7 years of age | Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence, Third Edition, UK Edition (WPPSI-III) | Children of mothers who were in the treatment group had higher scores on the WPPSI-III compared to the children of mothers who were given a placebo |
Placebo containing no folic acid | ||||||||
[74] Chatzi et al., 2012 | Greece | 553 mother-child pairs | A questionnaire was administered by a trained research nurse that asked whether the women had taken a folic acid supplement since they became pregnant. Supplement users reported the brand name, the dose, and the frequency of intake, which was converted into a measure of daily intake. | 14–18 weeks gestation | No folic acid intake from supplements | 18 months of age | Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development, Third Edition (Bayley-III) | Children of mothers who reported taking a daily supplement of 5 mg of folic acid or more had a 5 unit increase on receptive communication and a 3.5 unit increase in expressive communication |
Daily intake of 5 mg of folic acid from supplements | ||||||||
Daily intake of folic acid from supplements higher than 5 mg | ||||||||
[75] Chen et al., 2021 | China | 32 cohort studies and 7 case–control studies | Systematic review and meta-analysis of research articles that examined the association between prenatal folic acid supplementation and postnatal neurodevelopmental outcomes. All studies discussed folic acid supplementation only | During pregnancy | Varied by study; some reported whether or not women were supplemented; others reported specific supplementation levels. | 18 months to 17 years |
Varied by study; different measures used to assess intelligence, risk of autistic traits, ADHD, behavior, language, and psychomotor problems | Appropriate maternal folic acid supplementation may have positive effects on children’s intelligence and development, and reduce the risk of autism traits, ADHD, and behavioral and language problems |
[76] Villamor et al., 2012 | United States | 1210 mother-child pairs | Food frequency questionnaires | First and second trimester | Mean estimated folate intake of 949 ± 390 ug/day | 3 years of age | Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Third Edition (PPVT-III), Wide Range Assessment of Visual Motor Abilities | For each 600 μg per day increase in total folate intake during the first trimester of pregnancy there was a 1.6-point increase in scores on the PPVT-III in the children |
[77] Boeke et al., 2013 | United States | 895 mother-child pairs | Food frequency questionnaires | First and second trimesters | Mean daily estimated folate intake of 972 ug/day in the first trimester and 1268 ug/day in the second trimesters | 7 years of age | Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning, Second Edition (WRAML2), Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test, Second Edition (KBIT-2) |
No associations were found between maternal folate intake and child cognitive outcomes |
[85] Veena et al., 2010 | India | 536 mother-child pairs | Maternal plasma/serum folate concentrations from blood samples | 28–32 weeks gestation | Mean plasma/serum folate concentrations of 34.7 nmol/L | 9 or 10 years of age | Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children | Positive association between maternal plasma/serum folate concentrations and children’s performance on the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children |
[88] Ars et al., 2019 | Netherlands | 256 mother-child pairs (62 in the low folate group and 194 in the normal folate group) | Maternal plasma/serum folate concentrations from venous blood samples | First trimester | Low folate group: plasma/serum folate levels below 8 nmol/L | 6 years of age | Neuroimaging and NEPSY-II-NL | Low maternal plasma/serum folate concentrations below 8 nmol/L were associated with smaller total brain volume and poorer language and visuospatial skills in children |
Normal folate group: plasma/serum folate levels above 8 nmol/L | ||||||||
[89] Wu et al., 2012 | United States | 154 mother-child pairs | Food frequency questionnaires and maternal plasma/serum folate concentrations from blood samples | 16 weeks gestation | Mean plasma/serum folate concentrations of 36.4 nmol/L | 18 months of age | Bayley Scales of Infant Development, Third Edition (Bayley-III) | No association found between maternal plasma/serum folate concentrations and child cognitive function |
[90] Tamura et al., 2005 | United States | 355 mother-child pairs | Maternal red blood cell folate concentrations from blood samples | Second and third trimesters | Mean red blood cell folate concentrations were 873 nmol/L, 1070 nmol/L, and 1096 nmol/L at 19, 26, and 37 weeks gestation, respectively | 5 years of age | Differential Ability Scales, Visual and Auditory Sequential Memory Tests, Knox Cube Test, Gross Motor Scale, and Grooved Pegboard Test | No association found between maternal red blood cell folate concentrations and child cognitive function |