Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 13;11(2):370. doi: 10.3390/jcm11020370

Table 1.

Dysphagia screening methods (sensitivity and specificity).

Study (Year) Patients Included
(Etiology)
Swallowing Assessment Method Inspector Reference Test Outcome Sensitivity Specificity
Water Swallowing Test
Wakasugi et al. [14]. (2008) 107
(MD)
Single sips 3 mL, Total amount 3 mL NR VFSS, FEES Aspiration 69 97
Momosaki et al. [15]. (2013) 110
(CVA)
Single sips 4 mL, Total amount ≤12 SLP FEES Aspiration 93 79
McCullough et al. [16]. (2005) 165
(CVA)
Single sips 5 mL, Total amount ≤10 Doctor VFSS Aspiration 44 94
Single sips 10 mL, Total amount ≤20 Doctor VFSS Aspiration 37 96
Suiter et al. [17]. (2008) 3000
(MD)
Consecutive sips 90 mL Doctor FEES Aspiration 97 49
Zhou et al. [18]. (2011) 107
(CVA)
Consecutive sips 90 mL Doctor VFSS Aspiration 87 42
Patterson et al. [19]. (2011) 126
(HNC)
Consecutive sips 100 mL NR FEES Aspiration 80 77
Hey et al. [20]. (2013) 80
(HNC)
Progressive amounts 2, 5, 10, 20 mL
Total amount ≤51 mL
SLP FEES Aspiration 100 61
Somasundaram et al. [21]. (2014) 67
(CVA)
Progressive amounts 5, 10, 20 mL
Total amount ≤50 mL
SLP VFSS Aspiration 70 81
Hassan et al. [22]. (2014) 74
(MD)
Progressive amounts 5, 20, 50 mL
Total amount ≤75 mL
NR FEES Aspiration 74 70
Mann et al. [23]. (2000) 128
(CVA)
MASA SLP VFSS Swallowing disorder 73 89
González-Fernández et al. [24]. (2011) 133
(MD)
MASA SLP VFSS Aspiration 39.6 59
Antonios et al. [25]. (2010) 150
(CVA)
Modified MASA Doctor MASA Swallowing disorder 87~92 84.2~86.3
Trapl et al. [26]. (2007) 50
(CVA)
GUSS SLP
Nurse
FEES Aspiration 100 50~69
Warnecke et al. [27]. (2017) 100
(CVA)
GUSS SLP FEES Aspiration 96.5 55.8
Said Bassiouny et al. [28]. (2017) 40
(CVA)
GUSS SLP FEES Aspiration 93.8 96.1

CVA: cerebrovascular accident, HNC: head and neck cancer, MD: mixed-disease. SLP: speech-language pathologist, NR: not reported. VFSS: videofluoroscopic swallow study, FEES: fiberoptic endoscopic swallow study; MASA: Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability, GUSS: Gugging Swallowing Screen. All solids in the GUSS were dry bread.