Table 1.
Study (Year) | Patients Included (Etiology) |
Swallowing Assessment Method | Inspector | Reference Test | Outcome | Sensitivity | Specificity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Water Swallowing Test | |||||||
Wakasugi et al. [14]. (2008) | 107 (MD) |
Single sips 3 mL, Total amount 3 mL | NR | VFSS, FEES | Aspiration | 69 | 97 |
Momosaki et al. [15]. (2013) | 110 (CVA) |
Single sips 4 mL, Total amount ≤12 | SLP | FEES | Aspiration | 93 | 79 |
McCullough et al. [16]. (2005) | 165 (CVA) |
Single sips 5 mL, Total amount ≤10 | Doctor | VFSS | Aspiration | 44 | 94 |
Single sips 10 mL, Total amount ≤20 | Doctor | VFSS | Aspiration | 37 | 96 | ||
Suiter et al. [17]. (2008) | 3000 (MD) |
Consecutive sips 90 mL | Doctor | FEES | Aspiration | 97 | 49 |
Zhou et al. [18]. (2011) | 107 (CVA) |
Consecutive sips 90 mL | Doctor | VFSS | Aspiration | 87 | 42 |
Patterson et al. [19]. (2011) | 126 (HNC) |
Consecutive sips 100 mL | NR | FEES | Aspiration | 80 | 77 |
Hey et al. [20]. (2013) | 80 (HNC) |
Progressive amounts 2, 5, 10, 20 mL Total amount ≤51 mL |
SLP | FEES | Aspiration | 100 | 61 |
Somasundaram et al. [21]. (2014) | 67 (CVA) |
Progressive amounts 5, 10, 20 mL Total amount ≤50 mL |
SLP | VFSS | Aspiration | 70 | 81 |
Hassan et al. [22]. (2014) | 74 (MD) |
Progressive amounts 5, 20, 50 mL Total amount ≤75 mL |
NR | FEES | Aspiration | 74 | 70 |
Mann et al. [23]. (2000) | 128 (CVA) |
MASA | SLP | VFSS | Swallowing disorder | 73 | 89 |
González-Fernández et al. [24]. (2011) | 133 (MD) |
MASA | SLP | VFSS | Aspiration | 39.6 | 59 |
Antonios et al. [25]. (2010) | 150 (CVA) |
Modified MASA | Doctor | MASA | Swallowing disorder | 87~92 | 84.2~86.3 |
Trapl et al. [26]. (2007) | 50 (CVA) |
GUSS | SLP Nurse |
FEES | Aspiration | 100 | 50~69 |
Warnecke et al. [27]. (2017) | 100 (CVA) |
GUSS | SLP | FEES | Aspiration | 96.5 | 55.8 |
Said Bassiouny et al. [28]. (2017) | 40 (CVA) |
GUSS | SLP | FEES | Aspiration | 93.8 | 96.1 |
CVA: cerebrovascular accident, HNC: head and neck cancer, MD: mixed-disease. SLP: speech-language pathologist, NR: not reported. VFSS: videofluoroscopic swallow study, FEES: fiberoptic endoscopic swallow study; MASA: Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability, GUSS: Gugging Swallowing Screen. All solids in the GUSS were dry bread.