Table 2.
GRADE assessment of the included trials, observational studies and case series
No. of patients | Population | Dates | Pathogen | Design | Outcome | Death OR (95% CI) |
Quality of evidence | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rayamajhi et al. [11] | 22 (11 IVIG, 11 placebo) | Pediatric | 05–09/2009 | JE | Prospective trial |
Death/survival; neurological outcome; adverse effects; duration of hospital stay; Glasgow Coma Score |
At discharge: 3⋅29 (0⋅12–89⋅82) at 3–6 months: 0⋅45 (0⋅01–8⋅4) |
Very lowa, b, j |
Zhang et al. [13] | 80 | Pediatric | 03—09/2014 | EV | Prospective case series | Clinical outcome; adverse effect | nck | Very lowc |
Odessky et al. [15] | 41 (27 IVIG, 14 controls) | Pediatric | 1952 | Measles | Observational study | Death/survival; neurological sequelae; adverse effects | 0⋅75 (0.11–5⋅11) | Very lowb, c, g |
Neu [14] | 72 | Adults | 1970-1979 | Mixed | Observational study | Death/survival; neurological sequelae | 0⋅032 (0⋅0033–0⋅3024) | Very lowb, d, e, f, g |
Wang et al. [80] | 97 (Treatment/outcome data on 34 patients: 14 IVIG, 20 no IVIG) | Pediatric | 04–12/1998 | EV | Observational study | Survival/death | 1⋅2 (0⋅26–5⋅59) | Very lowb, c, g, h, i, j |
Legend see Table 1. nc not calculable
aUnclear risk of detection bias
bSmall sample size
cNo control group and/or no randomized design
dHeterogeneous cohort
eHigh risk of selection or allocation bias
fHigh risk of detection bias
gRetrospective design
hLack of information on part of cohort
iLack of information in treatment protocol; possibly heterogenous treatment
jLoss to follow-up
kStudy designed as a randomized controlled trial for the use of methylprednisolone in enteroviral encephalitis; no control intervention for IVIG—> study classified as case series