Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 21;269(2):654–663. doi: 10.1007/s00415-021-10436-6

Table 3.

Studies reporting patients with functional or psychiatric disorder misdiagnosed as MS

Study Year data collected Methodology Total misdiagnosed Proportion misdiagnosed with FND, functional disorder or psychiatric disorder
Hankey and Stewart-Wynne [30] 1981 Reviewed records of patients either diagnosed with or told they might have MS 69/387 (17%)

All categories: 35/69 (51%)

Functional disorder (n = 16), anxiety/hyperventilation (n = 14), hysterical conversion (n = 3), depression (n = 2)

Rudick et al. [31] 1986 Case series of ten patients who were misdiagnosed with MS 10 (n/a) “Hysteria”: 1/10 (10%)
Poser [32] 1997 Review of patients with MS diagnosis referred for second opinion 130/366 (36%)

All categories: 36/130 (28%)

Chronic fatigue syndrome (n = 28), post-traumatic syndrome (n = 5), psychiatric disorders (n = 3)

Walzl et al. [34] 2002–2004 Prospective cohort study of new neurology outpatients including 209 with MS 9/209 (4%)

All categories: 3/9 (33%)

Anxiety (n = 2), chronic fatigue syndrome (n = 1)

Solomon et al. [6] 2014–2015 Multicenter case series comprised of patients misdiagnosed with MS 110 (n/a)

All categories: 28/110 (25%)

Fibromyalgia (n = 16), conversion or psychogenic disorder (n = 12)

De Seabra et al. [36] 2009–2016 Retrospective study reviewing patient records at an MS clinic between 2009 and 2016 by applying 2010 McDonald criteria 44/635 (7%)

All Categories: 2/44 (5%)

Dissociative disorder (n = 1), fibromyalgia (n = 1)

Kaisey et al. [35] 2016–2017 Patients with a prior established diagnosis of MS were reviewed in clinic and evaluated for fulfilment of 2010 McDonald criteria 43/241 (18%) Fibromyalgia: 2/43 (5%)