Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 21;12:1124. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-04967-9

Table 5.

WDUD values in the ablation study. Since the GNN-based vector-generation process has randomness, the results of all methods are shown by means and standard deviation over five trials.

SUBMO w/o N SUBMO w/ N MS w/o N
mu (Debye) 10.47±0.10 10.65±0.06 11.88±0.06
alpha (Bohr3) 38.76±0.47 37.03±0.07 37.64±0.49
HOMO (Hartree) 0.02931±0.00194 0.02786±0.00049 0.04135±0.00115
LUMO (Hartree) 0.02243±0.00212 0.02905±0.00133 0.03360±0.00058
gap (Hartree) 0.03542±0.00181 0.03541±0.00138 0.05428±0.00086
R2 (Bohr2) 373.4±18.6 359.0±7.8 211.2±4.2
ZPVE (Hartree) 0.02800±0.00125 0.02320±0.00118 0.01542±0.00097
U0 (Hartree) 93.39±2.08 85.09±1.47 68.82±0.62
U (Hartree) 93.39±2.08 85.09±1.47 68.82±0.62
H (Hartree) 93.39±2.08 85.09±1.47 68.82±0.62
G (Hartree) 93.40±2.08 85.10±1.47 68.83±0.62
Cv (cal/(mol K)) 5.788±0.155 5.593±0.129 4.893±0.091
ZPVE/Nmode (Hartree) 0.001572±0.000008 0.001533±0.000006 0.001547±0.000004
U0/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3956±0.0293 0.3848±0.0087 0.2163±0.0139
U/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3956±0.0293 0.3848±0.0087 0.2163±0.0139
H/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3956±0.0293 0.3848±0.0087 0.2163±0.0139
G/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3955±0.0293 0.3848±0.0087 0.2163±0.0139
Cv/Nmode (cal/(mol K)) 0.4419±0.0068 0.4681±0.0031 0.4521±0.0016
MS w/ N MM w/o N MM w/ N
mu (Debye) 11.21±0.21 11.15±0.14 10.69±0.18
alpha (Bohr3) 36.63±0.36 38.86±0.59 39.05±0.73
HOMO (Hartree) 0.03101±0.00128 0.03375±0.00147 0.03067±0.00100
LUMO (Hartree) 0.03385±0.00228 0.02422±0.00046 0.03140±0.00151
gap (Hartree) 0.04084±0.00300 0.04108±0.00159 0.04061±0.00267
R2 (Bohr2) 316.2±20.9 342.0±15.3 361.9±12.6
ZPVE (Hartree) 0.01677±0.00088 0.02501±0.00176 0.02896±0.00076
U0 (Hartree) 71.93±2.06 89.49±2.91 87.40±2.20
U (Hartree) 71.93±2.06 89.49±2.91 87.40±2.20
H (Hartree) 71.93±2.06 89.49±2.91 87.40±2.20
G (Hartree) 71.94±2.06 89.50±2.91 87.40±2.20
Cv (cal/(mol K)) 5.299±0.135 6.124±0.110 5.877±0.132
ZPVE/Nmode (Hartree) 0.001497±0.000006 0.001565±0.000011 0.001553±0.000006
U0/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3487±0.0407 0.3785±0.0194 0.4525±0.0141
U/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3487±0.0407 0.3785±0.0194 0.4525±0.0141
H/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3487±0.0407 0.3785±0.0194 0.4525±0.0141
G/Nelec (Hartree) 0.3487±0.0407 0.3784±0.0194 0.4525±0.0141
Cv/Nmode (cal/(mol K)) 0.4812±0.0013 0.4632±0.0051 0.4777±0.0036