Table 1. EcoScale Analysis of the Proposed 2-GG Processa.
parameter | description | penalty points | |
---|---|---|---|
1. | Yield | 2-GG yield (83%) of the reaction was taken | 9 |
2. | Price of reaction components (to obtain 10 mmol of the end product) | ∼10 t product with a 2-GG content of 50 wt % is produced annually → 19.7 kmol 2-GG a–1 total raw material costs are 566,825 € a–1 | 0 |
3. | Safety | Hazard compounds: | |
Organic phase of the extraction processb | 15 | ||
1-Octanol | |||
n-Heptane (F, N)c | |||
Napthalene-2-boronic acid | |||
Aliquat 336 (N, T)c | |||
Stripping phase of the stripping process | 5 | ||
HNO3 (T)c | |||
4. | Technical setupd | Pressure equipment | 3 |
Packed-bed reactor | |||
Instruments for controlled addition of chemicals | 1 | ||
Pump (constant flow rate) | |||
5. | Temperature/time | Reaction temperature 40 °C (>1 h) | 3 |
6. | Workup and purification | Dilution (adding solvent) | 0 |
Extraction-stripping (liquid–liquid extraction) | 3 | ||
Ultrafiltration (filtration) | 1 | ||
Borate removal (solid phase extraction) | 2 | ||
Diafiltration (filtration) | 1 | ||
Permeate evaporation (removal of solvent with bp < 150 °C) | 0 | ||
Retentate evaporation (removal of solvent with bp < 150 °C) | 0 | ||
Ultrafiltration (filtration) | 1 | ||
Totale | 44 |
A detailed description of the EcoScale can be found in Van Aken et al. (2006).23
It was assumed that the organic phase is one entity. If two compounds shared the same hazard warning symbol, it was only counted as one.
F, highly flammable; N, dangerous to the environment; and T, toxic.
Technical setup of the biosynthesis is considered.
Ranking: <25 excellent, <50 acceptable, and >50 inadequate.