Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 19;13:100205. doi: 10.1016/j.mtbio.2022.100205

Table 1.

Comparison of MS, NMR and SERS in metabolite detection. The descriptions of MS and NMR are according to reference [58].

MS NMR SERS
Sensitivity High and the limit of detection (LOD) reaches nM Low but can be improved with high field intensity or low temperature High and LOD reaches the range of nM - pM
Selectivity Selective and non-selective analysis Generally for non-selective analysis Selective and non-selective analysis
Destruction Destructive but a small number of samples required Non-destructive and samples can be recycled after measurements Non-destructive and a small number of samples required
Reproducibility Moderate High Moderate, depending on substrate uniformity
Sample pretreatment Demanding Not necessary Not necessary but recommended
Sample analysis time Longer than NMR, and chromatography techniques required Fast and the whole sample can be analyzed simultaneously Fast and multiple analytes can be analyzed in one measurement
Targeted analysis Relatively better Not optimal Not optimal