Table 2.
Variable | Total # of studies | Total # of observations | Direction (variable associated with non-receipt of mental health services) | Total # of observations in this direction | Summary of evidence for risk factors for non-receipt of mental health services |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Demographic | |||||
Sex | 31 | 50 | Male | 31 | Consistent evidence for male sex |
Null | 19 | ||||
Age | 23 | 30 | Older age | 10 | Evidence for both younger and older age* |
Younger age | 8 | ||||
Middle age | 1 | ||||
Bimodal (older and younger age) | 2 | ||||
Null | 9 | ||||
Location | 8 | 14 | Rural location | 8 | Consistent evidence for rural location |
Null | 6 | ||||
Ethnicity | 13 | 15 | Non-White ethnicity | 5 | Some evidence for ethnic minority status |
Indigenous | 2 | ||||
Null | 8 | ||||
Employment status | 7 | 10 | Being employed | 4 | Some evidence for being employed |
Being retired | 1 | ||||
Null | 5 | ||||
Marital status | 11 | 15 | Being married | 2 | Unlikely association for marital status |
Never having been married | 1 | ||||
Being widowed | 2 | ||||
Null | 10 | ||||
Living situation | 6 | 7 | Living alone | 2 | Unlikely association for living situation |
Null | 5 | ||||
Education level | 4 | 5 | Low neighborhood education | 2 | Unlikely association for individual education level; insufficient evidence for neighborhood education level |
Null | 3 | ||||
Occupation | 7 | 9 | Farm laborer (compared to farm manager) | 1 | Insufficient studies (given heterogeneity among studies) |
Non-farming/agriculture occupation among those living rurally | 1 | ||||
Marine Corp (compared to Army) | 1 | ||||
Null | 6 | ||||
Income level | 2 | 3 | High income | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Low neighborhood income | 1 | ||||
Religion | 2 | 2 | Null | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Sexual orientation | 1 | 2 | Null | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Parental status | 1 | 2 | No children | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Perinatal status | 1 | 5 | Suicide death during perinatal period | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Null | 4 | ||||
Political views | 1 | 1 | Being socially conservative | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Diagnostic | |||||
Any MH diagnosis | 8 | 10 | Absence of any MH diagnosis | 10 | Consistent evidence for absence of any MH diagnosis |
Mood disorder/ depressed mood |
10 | 15 | Absence of mood disorder/depressed mood | 12 | Consistent evidence for absence of mood disorder/depressed mood |
Null | 3 | ||||
Schizophrenia and related disorders |
6 | 13* | Absence of schizophrenia and related disorders | 11 | Consistent evidence for absence of schizophrenia and related disorders |
Null | 2 | ||||
Alcohol/substance abuse |
10 | 15 | Absence of alcohol/substance abuse | 8 | Consistent evidence for absence of alcohol/substance use |
Null | 7 | ||||
Family history of mental illness/suicidality |
4 | 6 | Absence of family history of mental illness | 1 | Unlikely association for family history of mental illness/suicidality |
Anxiety | 2 | 3 | Absence of anxiety disorder | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Null | 1 | ||||
Personality disorder | 2 | 2 | Null | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Adjustment disorder | 1 | 2 | Absence of adjustment disorder | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Problem gambling | 1 | 3 | Absence of problem gambling | 3 | Insufficient studies |
Suicide-related | |||||
Method of suicide | 20 | 24 | Violent methods | 15 | Consistent evidence for violent methods of suicide |
Carbon monoxide | 2 | ||||
Null | 7 | ||||
Past suicidal behavior | 16 | 20 | Absence of past suicidal behavior | 18 | Consistent evidence for absence of past suicide attempts |
Null | 2 | ||||
Disclosure of suicide intent to others |
7 | 9 | Absence of disclosure | 4 | Some evidence for the absence of disclosure |
Null | 5 | ||||
Location/time of death | 4 | 4 | Null | 4 | Unlikely association for location/time of death |
Suicide note | 7 | 7 | No suicide note | 2 | Unlikely association for no suicide note |
Null | 5 | ||||
Time from initial onset of suicidal behavior |
1 | 2 | Short time period between initial onset of suicidal behavior and death | 2 | Insufficient studies |
Perceived suicide risk | 2 | 2 | Low perceived risk | 1 | Insufficient evidence |
Null | 1 | ||||
Psychosocial stressors/precipitating events | |||||
Any stressor | 4 | 4 | Presence of any recent stressor | 2 | Some evidence for presence of any stressor |
Null | 2 | ||||
Financial/job problems | 9 | 13 | Presence of financial/job problems | 4 | Some evidence for presence of financial/job problems |
Null | 9 | ||||
Criminal/legal problems |
5 | 6 | Presence of criminal/legal problems | 2 | Some evidence for experiencing criminal/legal problems |
Physical health problems |
10 | 11 | Absence of physical health problems | 1 | Unlikely association for physical health problems |
Presence of physical health problems | 3 | ||||
Null | 7 | ||||
Family or relationship or interpersonal problems |
6 | 8 | Presence of family/relationship/interpersonal problems | 1 | Unlikely association for experiencing family or relationship or interpersonal problems |
Null | 7 | ||||
Recent loss (incl. suicide or other death of close person) |
6 | 7 | Null | 7 | Unlikely association for experiencing recent loss |
Housing problems/homelessness |
2 | 2 | Being homeless | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Null | 1 | ||||
Immigration | 1 | 1 | Null | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Life events in childhood |
1 | 1 | Null | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Perpetuating violence | 1 | 1 | Perpetrator of violence | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Victim of violence | 1 | 1 | Null | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Other variables | |||||
Contact with other services (e.g., GP, social services) |
6 | 10 | Absence of contact with other services | 8 | Consistent evidence for absence of contact with other services |
Null | 2 | ||||
Family history of psychiatric contact |
1 | 2 | Absence of family history of psychiatric contact | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Null | 1 | ||||
Social problem-solving | 1 | 1 | Null | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Impulsivity | 1 | 1 | Null | 1 | Insufficient studies |
Academic performance |
1 | 1 | Null | 1 | Insufficient studies |