Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 18;9:736948. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.736948

Table 2.

Summary of variables assessed, including strength of evidence for the relationship between each variable and non-receipt of mental health services.

Variable Total # of studies Total # of observations Direction (variable associated with non-receipt of mental health services) Total # of observations in this direction Summary of evidence for risk factors for non-receipt of mental health services
Demographic
  Sex 31 50 Male 31 Consistent evidence for male sex
   Null 19
  Age 23 30 Older age 10 Evidence for both younger and older age*
Younger age 8
Middle age 1
Bimodal (older and younger age) 2
Null 9
  Location 8 14 Rural location 8 Consistent evidence for rural location
Null 6
  Ethnicity 13 15 Non-White ethnicity 5 Some evidence for ethnic minority status
Indigenous 2
Null 8
  Employment status 7 10 Being employed 4 Some evidence for being employed
Being retired 1
Null 5
  Marital status 11 15 Being married 2 Unlikely association for marital status
Never having been married 1
Being widowed 2
Null 10
  Living situation 6 7 Living alone 2 Unlikely association for living situation
Null 5
  Education level 4 5 Low neighborhood education 2 Unlikely association for individual education level; insufficient evidence for neighborhood education level
Null 3
  Occupation 7 9 Farm laborer (compared to farm manager) 1 Insufficient studies (given heterogeneity among studies)
Non-farming/agriculture occupation among those living rurally 1
Marine Corp (compared to Army) 1
Null 6
  Income level 2 3 High income 2 Insufficient studies
Low neighborhood income 1
  Religion 2 2 Null 2 Insufficient studies
  Sexual orientation 1 2 Null 2 Insufficient studies
  Parental status 1 2 No children 2 Insufficient studies
  Perinatal status 1 5 Suicide death during perinatal period 1 Insufficient studies
Null 4
  Political views 1 1 Being socially conservative 1 Insufficient studies
Diagnostic
  Any MH diagnosis 8 10 Absence of any MH diagnosis 10 Consistent evidence for absence of any MH diagnosis
  Mood disorder/
depressed
mood
10 15 Absence of mood disorder/depressed mood 12 Consistent evidence for absence of mood disorder/depressed mood
Null 3
  Schizophrenia and
related disorders
6 13* Absence of schizophrenia and related disorders 11 Consistent evidence for absence of schizophrenia and related disorders
Null 2
  Alcohol/substance
abuse
10 15 Absence of alcohol/substance abuse 8 Consistent evidence for absence of alcohol/substance use
Null 7
  Family history of
mental illness/suicidality
4 6 Absence of family history of mental illness 1 Unlikely association for family history of mental illness/suicidality
  Anxiety 2 3 Absence of anxiety disorder 2 Insufficient studies
Null 1
  Personality disorder 2 2 Null 2 Insufficient studies
  Adjustment disorder 1 2 Absence of adjustment disorder 2 Insufficient studies
  Problem gambling 1 3 Absence of problem gambling 3 Insufficient studies
Suicide-related
  Method of suicide 20 24 Violent methods 15 Consistent evidence for violent methods of suicide
Carbon monoxide 2
Null 7
  Past suicidal behavior 16 20 Absence of past suicidal behavior 18 Consistent evidence for absence of past suicide attempts
Null 2
  Disclosure of suicide
intent to others
7 9 Absence of disclosure 4 Some evidence for the absence of disclosure
Null 5
  Location/time of death 4 4 Null 4 Unlikely association for location/time of death
  Suicide note 7 7 No suicide note 2 Unlikely association for no suicide note
Null 5
  Time from initial onset
of suicidal behavior
1 2 Short time period between initial onset of suicidal behavior and death 2 Insufficient studies
  Perceived suicide risk 2 2 Low perceived risk 1 Insufficient evidence
Null 1
Psychosocial stressors/precipitating events
  Any stressor 4 4 Presence of any recent stressor 2 Some evidence for presence of any stressor
Null 2
  Financial/job problems 9 13 Presence of financial/job problems 4 Some evidence for presence of financial/job problems
Null 9
  Criminal/legal
problems
5 6 Presence of criminal/legal problems 2 Some evidence for experiencing criminal/legal problems
  Physical health
problems
10 11 Absence of physical health problems 1 Unlikely association for physical health problems
Presence of physical health problems 3
Null 7
  Family or relationship or
interpersonal problems
6 8 Presence of family/relationship/interpersonal problems 1 Unlikely association for experiencing family or relationship or interpersonal problems
Null 7
  Recent loss (incl.
suicide or other death of
  close person)
6 7 Null 7 Unlikely association for experiencing recent loss
  Housing
problems/homelessness
2 2 Being homeless 1 Insufficient studies
Null 1
  Immigration 1 1 Null 1 Insufficient studies
  Life events in
childhood
1 1 Null 1 Insufficient studies
  Perpetuating violence 1 1 Perpetrator of violence 1 Insufficient studies
  Victim of violence 1 1 Null 1 Insufficient studies
Other variables
  Contact with other
services (e.g., GP, social
services)
6 10 Absence of contact with other services 8 Consistent evidence for absence of contact with other services
Null 2
  Family history of
  psychiatric contact
1 2 Absence of family history of psychiatric contact 1 Insufficient studies
Null 1
  Social problem-solving 1 1 Null 1 Insufficient studies
  Impulsivity 1 1 Null 1 Insufficient studies
  Academic
performance
1 1 Null 1 Insufficient studies