Skip to main content
. 2004 Jul 19;2004(3):CD004327. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004327.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
AANTTAS 1990 Allocation: Not randomized
Adams 1993 Allocation: Not randomized
Adams 1995 Allocation: Random 
 Participants: Adults with spasmodic dysphonia 
 Interventions: Unilateral versus bilateral botulinum toxin injections
Adams 1996 Allocation: Not randomized
Aronson 1993 Allocation: Not randomized
Benninger 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
Bhattacharyya 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
Bielamowicz 2000 Allocation: Not randomized
Bielamowicz 2001 Allocation: Random 
 Participants: Adults with abductor spasmodic dysphonia 
 Interventions: Percutaneous versus transnasal injection of botulinum toxin
Bielamowicz 2002 Allocation: Not randomized
Blitzer 1985 Allocation: Not randomized
Blitzer 1988 Allocation: Not randomized
Blitzer 1991 Allocation: Not randomized
Blitzer 1992a Allocation: Not randomized
Blitzer 1992b Allocation: Not randomized
Blitzer 1998 Allocation: Not randomized
Brin 1988 Allocation: Not randomized
Brin 1989 Allocation: Not randomized
Brin 1998b Allocation: Not randomized
Brin 2001 Allocation: Random 
 Participants: Adults with spasmodic dysphonia 
 Interventions: Unilateral versus bilateral botulinum toxin injections
Cannito 1994 Allocation: Not randomized
Ceballos 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Courey 2000 Allocation: Not randomized
Crevier‐Buchman 1997 Allocation: Not randomized
Cyrus 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
Davidson 1996 Allocation: Not randomized
Devriese 1994 Allocation: Not randomized
Finnegan 1999 Allocation: Random 
 Participants: Adults with spasmodic dysphonia 
 Interventions: Botulinum toxin injections into both intrinsic and extrinsic laryngeal muscles versus botulinum toxin injections into intrinsic plus saline into extrinsic muscles
Fisher 1996 Allocation: Not randomized
Fisher 1999 Allocation: Not randomized
Ford 1990 Allocation: Not randomized
Ford 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Galardi 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
George 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Green 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Inagi 1996 Allocation: Not randomized
Jankovic 1990 Allocation: Not randomized
Klap 1991 Allocation: Not randomized
Klap 1993 Allocation: Not randomized
Kobayashi 1993 Allocation: Not randomized
Koriwchak 1996 Allocation: Not randomized
Langeveld 1998 Allocation: Not randomized
Langeveld 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
Lees 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Liu 1996 Allocation: Not randomized
Loven 1993 Allocation: Not randomized
Loven 1994 Allocation: Not randomized
Ludlow 1988 Allocation: Not randomized
Ludlow 1990 Allocation: Not randomized
Ludlow 1991 Allocation: Not randomized
Ludlow 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Lundy 1998 Allocation: Not randomized
Maloney 1994 Allocation: Not randomized
Marion 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Maurri 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Mehta 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
Meleca 1997 Allocation: Not randomized
Miller 1987 Allocation: Not randomized
Murry 1995 Allocation: Not randomized
Papathanasiou 1997 Allocation: Not randomized
Poungvarin 1995 Allocation: Not randomized
Rhew 1994 Allocation: Not randomized
Rodriguez 1994 Allocation: Not randomized
Rontal 1991 Allocation: Not randomized
Rosen 1999 Allocation: Not randomized
Ruiz 1998 Allocation: Not randomized
Sapienza 2002 Allocation: Not randomized
Schonweiler 1998 Allocation: Not randomized
Smith 2000 Allocation: Not randomized
Teive 2001 Allocation: Not randomized
Thomas 2006 Allocation: Randomized
Participants: Adult patients with adductor spasmodic dysphonia
Interventions: Frozen versus fresh reconstituted botulinum toxin type A
Tish 2003 Allocation: Not randomized
Whurr 1993 Allocation: Not randomized
Whurr 1997 Allocation: Not randomized
Whurr 1998 Allocation: Not randomized
Wong 1995a Allocation: Randomized 
 Participants: Adults with spasmodic dysphonia 
 Interventions: Botulinum toxin with vocalization versus botulinum toxin without vocalization
Wong 1995b Allocation: Randomized 
 Participants: Adults with spasmodic dysphonia 
 Interventions: Botulinum toxin with vocalization versus botulinum toxin without vocalization
Zwirner 1991 Allocation: Not randomized
Zwirner 1992 Allocation: Not randomized
Zwirner 1993a Allocation: Not randomized
Zwirner 1993b Allocation: Not randomized
Zwirner 1997 Allocation: Not randomized