Table 1. Comparison of prediction performance under different classification models on 37 circRNA datasets.
dataset | CRBPDL | iCircRBP-DHN | PASSION | CRIP | CSCRites | CircSLNN |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AGO1 | 0.9232 | 0.898±0.003 | 0.909±0.003 | 0.905±0.002 | 0851±0.002 | 0.844±0.002 |
AGO2 | 0.8233 | 0.797±0.004 | 0.822±0.003 | 0.811±0.001 | 0.755±0.127 | 0.715±0.013 |
AGO3 | 0.9472 | 0.920±0.016 | 0.909±0.008 | 0.895±0.002 | 0.820±0.004 | 0.860±0.006 |
ALKBH5 | 0.9952 | 0.979±0.004 | 0.752±0.030 | 0.721±0.008 | 0.798±0.009 | 0.583±0.014 |
AUF1 | 0.9810 | 0.985±0.002 | 0.979±0.003 | 0.980±0.000 | 0.940±0.001 | 0.971±0.001 |
C17ORF85 | 0.9881 | 0.987±0.002 | 0.860±0.021 | 0.813±0.007 | 0.815±0.012 | 0.721±0.010 |
C22ORF28 | 0.9088 | 0.913±0.004 | 0.894±0.008 | 0.876±0.002 | 0.878±0.002 | 0.797±0.001 |
CAPRIN1 | 0.8765 | 0.858±0.012 | 0.860±0.009 | 0.843±0.003 | 0.827±0.002 | 0.745±0.008 |
DGCR8 | 0.9236 | 0.906±0.002 | 0.917±0.002 | 0.914±0.001 | 0.870±0.002 | 0.846±0.002 |
EIF4A3 | 0.853 | 0.799±0.003 | 0.823±0.004 | 0.812±0.001 | 0.820±0.001 | 0.717±0.005 |
EWSR1 | 0.9443 | 0.942±0.004 | 0.938±0.006 | 0.936±0.001 | 0.882±0.002 | 0.906±0.002 |
FMRP | 0.8966 | 0.892±0.002 | 0.900±0.002 | 0.898±0.001 | 0.890±0.001 | 0.826±0.003 |
FOX2 | 0.9618 | 0.958±0.005 | 0.830±0.034 | 0.815±0.006 | 0.755±0.010 | 0.602±0.033 |
FUS | 0.8618 | 0.855±0.004 | 0.859±0.002 | 0.858±0.002 | 0.799±0.003 | 0.770±0.003 |
FXR1 | 0.9948 | 0.994±0.001 | 0.959±0.009 | 0.952±0.003 | 0.871±0.003 | 0.942±0.004 |
FXR2 | 0.9518 | 0.939±0.009 | 0.941±0.003 | 0.938±0.002 | 0.868±0.002 | 0.896±0.004 |
HNRNPC | 0.9771 | 0.977±0.001 | 0.976±0.001 | 0.972±0.000 | 0.973±0.001 | 0.970±0.001 |
HUR | 0.8758 | 0.867±0.005 | 0.879±0.006 | 0.874±0.001 | 0.850±0.001 | 0.796±0.009 |
IGF2BP1 | 0.8554 | 0.843±0.002 | 0.845±0.003 | 0.843±0.001 | 0.835±0.003 | 0.760±0.009 |
IGF2BP2 | 0.8426 | 0.831±0.004 | 0.827±0.009 | 0.821±0.002 | 0.752±0.126 | 0.740±0.004 |
IGF2BP3 | 0.8229 | 0.816±0.004 | 0.831±0.003 | 0.822±0.002 | 0.754±0.122 | 0.706±0.003 |
LIN28A | 0.8751 | 0.857±0.007 | 0.875±0.005 | 0.865±0.001 | 0.840±0.002 | 0.777±0.003 |
LIN28B | 0.9014 | 0.892±0.004 | 0.889±0.005 | 0.882±0.001 | 0.758±0.129 | 0.822±0.003 |
METTL3 | 0.8649 | 0.852±0.009 | 0.878±0.010 | 0.854±0.003 | 0.808±0.003 | 0.772±0.007 |
MOV10 | 0.8674 | 0.838±0.006 | 0.845±0.005 | 0.849±0.001 | 0.778±0.004 | 0.777±0.008 |
PTB | 0.8347 | 0.822±0.006 | 0.829±0.004 | 0.826±0.001 | 0.692±0.157 | 0.738±0.007 |
PUM2 | 0.9758 | 0.970±0.004 | 0.952±0.004 | 0.953±0.001 | 0.936±0.001 | 0.932±0.002 |
QKI | 0.9879 | 0.971±0.006 | 0.927±0.005 | 0.921±0.003 | 0.866±0.004 | 0.866±0.007 |
SFRS1 | 0.9684 | 0.964±0.000 | 0.965±0.003 | 0.964±0.001 | 0.963±0.001 | 0.926±0.003 |
TAF15 | 0.9945 | 0.992±0.002 | 0.967±0.002 | 0.965±0.001 | 0.941±0.002 | 0.968±0.002 |
TDP43 | 0.9336 | 0.926±0.002 | 0.934±0.002 | 0.930±0.001 | 0.923±0.001 | 0.896±0.003 |
TIA1 | 0.9666 | 0.961±0.004 | 0.935±0.006 | 0.932±0.003 | 0.915±0.009 | 0.901±003 |
TIAL1 | 0.9249 | 0.917±0.003 | 0.906±0.003 | 0.902±0.001 | 0.898±0.002 | 0.871±0.005 |
TNRC6 | 0.9797 | 0.967±0.002 | 0.785±0.010 | 0.741±0.007 | 0.729±0.010 | 0.662±0.015 |
U2AF65 | 0.9306 | 0.926±0.002 | 0.930±0.002 | 0.928±0.001 | 0.911±0.001 | 0.899±0.004 |
WTAP | 0.9713 | 0.967±0.002 | 0.794±0.069 | 0.793±0.011 | 0.808±0.022 | 0.732±0.009 |
ZC3HB | 0.8151 | 0.804±0.003 | 0.804±0.005 | 0.792±0.002 | 0.794±0.004 | 0.697±0.008 |
AVG | 0.9188 | 0.908±0.06 | 0.884±0.06 | 0.876±0.07 | 0.842±0.07 | 0.809±0.010 |