Chlorate induces failure of Closure 1 in Vangl2Lp/+ and Vangl2flox/− embryos. (A) Experimental litters were generated by Vangl2Lp/+×Vangl2+/+ matings within the CBA/Ca-derived genetic background. Percentage of open NT (grey bar sectors) versus closed NT (black bar sectors) at the Closure 1 site was determined in cultures treated with water (control groups), 10 mM chlorate (treatment groups) or 10 mM chlorate plus sodium sulfate (rescue groups). Embryo numbers are shown on bars. Treatment with chlorate prevents Closure 1 in a significantly greater proportion of Lp/+ than +/+ embryos (P<0.001). Closure 1 is successful in 100% of water-treated controls. Co-administration of sodium sulfate (SO4) significantly reduces the Closure 1 failure seen in Lp/+ embryos treated with 10 mM chlorate (P<0.001), but not in +/+ embryos (P>0.05). (B) Chlorate significantly inhibits Closure 1 in Vangl2flox/−embryos, compared with Vangl2flox/flox, although the penetrance of Closure 1 failure after 10 mM chlorate is significantly lower in Vangl2flox/− embryos (7/18) than in Vangl2Lp/+ embryos (A; 45/54; P<0.001). (C-E) Typical embryonic morphology after 24 h culture. Vangl2+/+ embryos show completion of Closure 1 in all treatment groups (C-i,D-i,E-i). Vangl2Lp/+ water-treated (C-ii) and chlorate+sulfate-treated embryos (E-ii) also show Closure 1, whereas a chlorate-treated Vangl2Lp/+ embryo shows entirely open neural tube (arrowheads in D-ii). *P<0.05; ***P<0.001 (Chi-square test). Scale bars: 0.5 mm.