Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 9;29(10):15117–15126. doi: 10.1007/s11356-021-16536-0

Table 1:

Summary of six articles included in the systematic review.

Study citation information and setting Exposure Outcome
ID Authors(year) Location Study design, Time-span Study Size Population (years old) Mean/median concentration Unit of increment (μg/m3) Exposure type Health outcome Outcome level Effect (95% CI) Controlled variables
1 Wang et al. (2021b) Hefei, China Time series, 2016–2018 15683 0-17 31.00 10.00 Short-term, lag0 Pneumonia Hospital admission, ICD-10 6.82(3.85–9.88) * Yes
2 Zhang et al. (2021) Wuhan, China

Cross-sectional,

2014–2018

5788 3-5 37.40 10.00 Long-term Asthma Incidence 1.54(0.82–2.90) ** Yes
3 Zhang et al. (2020) Shenzhen, China Case-crossover, 2015–2016 6078 All 19.00 10.00 Short-term, lag0-2 TRD Hospital admission, ICD-10 1.09(1.04–1.14) *** Yes
147 All 19.00 10.00 Short-term, lag0-2 Asthma Hospital admission, ICD-10 1.12(0.85–1.47) *** Yes
1661 All 19.00 10.00 Short-term, lag0-2 Pneumonia Hospital admission, ICD-10 1.12(1.02–1.22) *** Yes
4 Yu et al. (2020) Liaoning, China

Cross-sectional,

2012–2013

59754 2-17 44.90 11.40 Long-term, 2009-2012 Current asthma Prevalence 1.55(1.38–1.75) *** Yes
5 Luong et al. (2016) Hanoi, Vietnam

Case-crossover,

2010–2011

8934 0-5 54.00 42.00 Short-term, lag0 TRD Hospital admission, ICD-10 1.03(1.01–1.04) *** Yes
6 Michaud et al. (2004) Hawaii, America

Time series,

1997–2001

4339 NA 1.97 10.00 Short-term, lag0 Asthma Emergency department visit, ICD-9 1.03(0.90–1.42) **** Yes

*PC; **:HR; ***OR; ****Effect; TRD total respiratory diseases, PCpercentage change, OR odds ratio, HR hazards ratio.

HHS Vulnerability Disclosure