Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 17;106(3):1257–1278. doi: 10.1007/s00253-021-11757-2

Table 1.

List of specimens used in this study and their classification with different methods

Number Sample number1 Collection year2 Host Origin3 Collector/source Classification germination HCA cluster DAPC cluster Classification MALDI-TOF MS Classification morphology Final classification
1 AA7 2015 T. aestivum4 AUT A. E. Müllner Cb5 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
2 AA8 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
3 AA9 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
4 AA10 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
5 AA11 (CBS 144,825)6 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
6 AA12 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
7 AC 2015 T. aestivum DEU H. Spieß Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
8 AD 2014 T. aestivum DEU S. Schumann Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
9 AER 2016 T. aestivum DEU S. Weller Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
10 AES 2016 T. aestivum DEU S. Weller Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
11 AEZO 2016 T. spelta DEU S. Weller Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
12 AGW 2016 T. aestivum DEU B. Schwab Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
13 AHW 2016 T. aestivum DEU S. Weller, H. Eichinger Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
14 AI (CBS 145,171) 2015 T. durum ITA V. Weyermann Cb 2 3 Cb T. laevis > T. caries7 Cb
15 AKW 2016 T. aestivum DEU S. Weller Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
16 AL 2010 T. aestivum DEU H. Mitterer Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries Cb
17 AL14 2014 T. aestivum DEU H. Mitterer Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries > T. controversa Cb
18 AL15 2015 T. aestivum DEU H. Mitterer Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries Cb
19 AN 2014 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries Cb
20 AN15 2015 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries Cb
21 AO (CBS 145,172) 2014 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries Cb
22 AOA 2016 T. aestivum DEU B. Schwab Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries > T. controversa Cb
23 ARW 2016 T. aestivum DEU S. Weller Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries > T. laevis Cb
24 AS14 2014 T. aestivum DEU B. Pölitz Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
25 AW 2014 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries Cb
26 AZH1 2015 T. aestivum CHE V. Weyermann Cb 1 (b)8 3 Cb T. caries > T. laevis Cb
27 AZH2 2015 T. aestivum CHE V. Weyermann Cb 1 (b) 2 Cb T. caries > T. laevis Cb
28 AZH3 (CBS 145,166) 2015 T. aestivum CHE V. Weyermann Cb 1 (b) 1 (b) Db T. caries > T. laevis Cb
29 AZH4 2015 T. aestivum CHE V. Weyermann Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries > T. controversa Cb
30 AZH5 2015 T. aestivum CHE V. Weyermann Cb 2 3 Cb T. caries > T. controversa Cb
31 D-3 -9 T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Db10 1 4 (b) Db T. controversa Db
32 D-4 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Db 1 4 (b) Db T. controversa Db
33 D-7 1999 (a) T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Db 1 1 Db T. caries > T. controversa Db
34 D-12 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
35 D-13 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
36 D-17 1999 (a) T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
37 D-18 - T. aestivum USA B. J. Goates, R. J. Metzger Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
38 D-19 - T. aestivum TUR B. J. Goates, R. J. Metzger Db 1 1 Db T. controversa > T. caries Db
39 II7 2007 T. spp. IND P. Chhuneja NA11 outgroup outgroup Kb12 T. indica Kb
40 IM5 2005 T. spp. MEX G. Fuentes NA outgroup outgroup Kb T. indica Kb
41 L-1 1990 (a) T. aestivum - R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann ng13 0 (b) 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
42 L-10 1990 (a) T. aestivum - R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Cb 2 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
43 L-16 1984 (a) T. aestivum - R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Cb 2 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
44 L-18 - T. aestivum - R. J. Metzger Cb 2 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
45 L-19 (CBS 145,173) - T. aestivum - R. J. Metzger Cb 2 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
46 L-20 - T. aestivum TUR R. J. Metzger Cb 2 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
47 L-21 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger Cb 2 2 Cb T. laevis Cb
48 OA1 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
49 OA2 (CBS 145,169) 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
50 OA3 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
51 OA4 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Db 1 1 Db T. controversa > T. caries Db
52 OA5 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
53 OA6 2015 T. aestivum AUT A. E. Müllner Db 1 1 / 4 (bc)14 Db T. controversa Db
54 OC1 2015 T. aestivum DEU H. Spieß Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
55 OC2 2015 T. aestivum DEU H. Spieß Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
56 OL 2013 T. aestivum DEU H. Mitterer Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
57 OL14 (CBS 145,167) 2014 T. aestivum DEU H. Mitterer Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
58 OL16 2016 T. aestivum DEU M. K. Forster Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
59 OMO 2016 T. spelta DEU R. Klügl Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
60 OR (CBS 144,827) 2013 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
61 ORB 2016 T. aestivum DEU S. Weller Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
62 OV (CBS 145,170) 2011 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
63 OW15 2015 T. aestivum DEU R. Bauer Db 1 1 Db T. controversa Db
64 T-2 1989 (a) T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Cb 2 2 Cb T. caries Cb
65 T-15 1978 (a) T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Cb 2 4 Cb T. caries Cb
66 T-19 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Cb 2 2 Cb T. caries Cb
67 T-30 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger, J. A. Hoffmann Cb 2 2 Cb T. caries > T. laevis Cb
68 T-33 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger Cb 2 2 Cb T. caries Cb
69 T-34 - T. aestivum USA R. J. Metzger Cb 2 2 Cb T. caries > T. laevis Cb

1Sample numbers/collection numbers are sorted alphabetically, sample number of T. caries specimens start with A or T, T. controversa specimens starts with D or O, T. indica specimens with I, and T. laevis specimens starts with L

2(a) Year of original collection, samples constantly recultivated until 2012 by B. J. Goates

3International abbreviations used: AUT, Austria; CHE, Switzerland; DEU, Germany; IND, India; ITA, Italy; MEX, Mexico; TUR, Turkey; USA, United States of America

4T. = Triticum

5Cb, common bunt

6CBS = single teliospore culture produced and stored at strain collection of Westerdijk Fungal Biodiversity Institute, Utrecht, The Netherlands

7T. laevis > T. caries = T. laevis rather than T. caries

8(b) = false classification

9No information available

10Db, dwarf bunt

11NA, not analyzed

12Kb, karnal bunt

13ng, no germination

14(bc) = false classification (N = 67 + outgroup), true classification (N = 52 + outgroup, reference samples)