Table 1.
Study | NS surgical technique | No. of patients | Mean/median age (years) | Potency definition | Potency 6 months, % | Potency 12 months, % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Menon et al.12 | High anterior release | 1142 (480 standard NS, 285 unilateral Veil, 377 bilateral Veil) | 60.2 | SHIM score ≥21 | Not reported | 40 vs 58 vs 70 |
Shikanov et al.22 | Extrafascial vs interfascial | 110 vs 703 | 58.5 | Erection firm enough for sexual activity or intercourse | 34 vs 47 | 40 vs 64 |
Potdevin et al.23 | Interfascial vs athermal intrafascial | 77 vs 70 | 58.6 vs 58.7 | SHIM score ≥20 | 81.8 vs 43.8 | 90.9 vs 66.67 (9 months) |
Kowalczyk et al.16 | Antegrade; no countertraction vs countertraction | 342 vs 268 | 59.6 vs 57.9 | Erection firm enough for sexual activity or intercourse | 45 vs 28.4 | 50 vs 54.2 |
Patel et al.25 | Retrograde | 332 | 58.5 | SHIM score ≥21 | 86.1 | 89.7 |
Patel et al.24 | Retrograde | 404 | 58 | SHIM score ≥21 | 81.7 | 91.5 |
Patel et al.14 | Prostatic vasculature as a landmark for NS | 133 | 60 | Not assessed | Not assessed | Not assessed |
Alemozaffar et al.18 | Antegrade | 400 | 59.8 | Erection firm enough for sexual activity or intercourse | 41 (17.82) | 53 (29.1) |
Ko et al.11 | Antegrade RARP vs retrograde RARP | 172 vs 172 | 57.9 vs 57.2 | Erections firm enough for >50% of attempts of sexual activity or intercourse | 72.1 vs 90.1 | 85.3 vs 92.9 |
de Carvalho et al.17 | Retrograde release of the NVB with preservation of the DVC | 128 | 63.5 | SHIM score ≥17 | 82.3 | 86.7 |
Moschovas et al.15 | Modified apical dissection and lateral prostatic fascia preservation vs standard RARP | 103 vs 103 | 58.5 vs 58.4 | Erection firm enough for sexual activity or intercoursea | 66.7 vs 49.3 | 77.9 vs 66.7 |
With or without the use of PDE5 inhibitors.
DVC = deep venous complex; RARP = robot-assisted radical prostatectomy; NS = nerve-sparing; NVB = neurovascular bundle; PDE5 = phosphodiesterase type 5; SHIM = Sexual Health Inventory for Men.