TABLE 2.
GP1 | GP2 | GP3 | GP4 | GP5 | |
First response | Not pathological. A moment later: depressive symptoms. It does not “feel” like a depression | Does not want to label. Determines a few minutes later a “possible depression” | If the complaints exceed 2 weeks, she meets the diagnosis of depression according to the DSM | Thinks a depression is unlikely | Mood disorder |
Diagnose | Using NHG standards. Not sure if symptoms meet the criteria “Maybe” | When the symptoms meet the NHG standards | A depression. Clearly, according to the DSM. | Does not use the NHG standards and DSM. No diagnosis by the GP. | Not yet. |
Action | At first, normalizing. Follow up contact or consult at PN-MH. | First exclude physical causes. Consult PN-MH when symptoms meet NHG standards | Depending on the complaints PN-MH, a psychologist, or psychiatrist. Possibly start with antidepressants |
Exclude physical causes. Further action depends on questionnaire completed by the patient | Follow up contact or consult at PN-MH for knowing the degree of severity |
Other | Prescribes less antidepressants than 10 years ago. GP has also a societal function | Argues to take life phase problem out of the medical domain | Important to use DSM criteria for the common understanding; otherwise, there will be confusion | Sees GP more as a guide. Diagnose and prescribing antidepressants belongs to the task of a psychiatrist | Thinks there needs to happen more on societal level regarding the subject |