Transwell static |
Poly tetra fluoroethylene, Porous polycarbonate (PC) |
Rat brain endothelial cells GP8, RBE4, hCMEC/D3 |
Easy to set up, moderately scalable, low-cost |
Unable to simulate NVU dynamic model, lack of physiological shear stress to limit endothelial cell blood-brain barrier (BBB) phenotypic differentiation, relatively low endothelial resistance, and high permeability of hydrophilic substances |
Bian et al., 2019; |
|
|
|
|
|
Li et al., 2019; |
|
|
|
|
|
Brown et al., 2020; Rumianek and Greaves, 2020 |
Dynamic microfluidic device |
PC |
B.end3 endothelial cells or co-culture with astrocytes |
Real-time visualization BBB and transmembrane endothelial resistance (TEER) |
Weak ability to regulate microenvironment |
Booth and Kim, 2014 |
Dynamic synthetic microvascular device |
Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) |
RBE4 (intra luminal), astrocytes (extra luminal) |
Low cost, simulated microcirculation environment, physiological fluid flow, shear stress, allow long-term cell culture, real-time optical monitoring |
High throughput drug screening and TEER real-time detection are not available |
Prabhakarpandian et al., 2013 |
Dynamic NVU chip device |
PC |
RBE4, neurons, astrocytes and microglia |
Low cost, realize NVU interaction |
The apparatus is complicated and it is difficult to culture cells for a long time |
Achyuta et al., 2013 |
Dynamic New baby BBB chip device |
PDMS |
Rat brain endothelial cells, astrocytes |
Simulation of shear flow in vivo environment, real-time visualization, direct measurement of dynamic process |
Technology is not mature enough |
Deosarkar et al., 2015 |
Microfluidic-on-chip |
PDMS chip, porous polycarbonate film |
Human brain neurons, astrocytes, pericytes, and BMECs |
Low reagent consumption, high throughput, easy integration. Controllable physical parameters, accurate simulation of central nervous system environment. Low cost fabrication, flexibility in the design, visualization of cells is possible, consider the effect of sheer stress. Immediate permeability measurements. Improvement in paracellular barrier functions |
Highly specialized equipment, limited materials and expensive reagent consumption make it impossible to quantify cavity membrane shear stress and transendothelial resistance, lack of high-throughput, complex process technically, not ideal linear kinetic |
Sankar et al., 2017; Mittal et al., 2019; Bhalerao et al., 2020; Guo et al., 2021; Staicu et al., 2021 |
Three-dimensional printing |
Gelatin/alginate hydrogel, swarm hydrogel, collagen, gelatin, fibrin, gellan gum, hyaluronan, self-assembling peptide, elastinlike polypeptide, polyethylene glycol |
Neuroblastoma cell line (SH-SY5Y), induced pluripotent stem cells, and neural stem cells, Schwann cells |
Quickly, high cost performance, complex geometric features, low cost, multi-material and multi-function, elastic, high resolution |
High cell survival rate cannot be guaranteed. Bio-inks have a limited shelf life. A variety of cells in the system may cause an immune response. The mechanical strength of tissue scaffolds is low |
Potjewyd et al., 2018; Fantini et al., 2019; Gong et al., 2020 |
In-Silico |
|
|
Short time, low cost, low risk. Real-time observation of the interaction between NVU cells. Quantized molecular signal |
In vivo or in vitro verify are needed |
Katara, 2014; Li et al., 2020a |