TABLE 3.
Study | Behavioral determinants identified | Behavior change techniques a applied | Contextual influencers applied | Did the behavior change techniques applied address all determinants? b | Was the intervention effective? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bourdeaux et al. (2014) | -Memory attention and decision processes | Intervention 1: 7.1 Prompts/cues | Defaults | Not possible | Yes |
Intervention 2: 7.3 Reduce prompts/cues | Defaults | Not possible | Yes | ||
Harewood et al. (2011) | -Environmental context and resources | 12.1 Restructuring the physical environment | Defaults and Priming | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | |||||
Isenberg et al. (2018) | -Environmental context and resources | 2.2 Feedback on behavior | Messenger, Defaults, and Salience | Completely | Yes |
-Knowledge | 4.1 Instruction on how to perform behavior | ||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
12. Adding objects | |||||
Lemiengre et al. (2018) | -Emotions | Intervention 1: | Affect | Partially | No |
-Environmental context and resources | 4.1 Instruction on how to perform behavior | ||||
-Knowledge | 4.2 Information about antecedents | ||||
-Social influences | 12.5 Adding objects | ||||
Intervention 2: 3.2 Social support (practical) | Affect | Partially | No | ||
3.3 Social support (emotional) | |||||
12.5 Adding objects | |||||
Intervention 3: 3.2 Social support (practical) | Affect | Completely | No | ||
3.3 Social support (emotional) | |||||
4.1 Instruction on how to perform behavior | |||||
4.2 Information about antecedents | |||||
12.5 Adding objects | |||||
Mafi et al. (2018) | -Knowledge | 1.9 Commitment | Messenger, Norms and Commitments | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 2.2 Feedback on behavior | ||||
4.1 Instruction on how to perform behavior | |||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
Malhotra et al. (2016) | -Memory attention and decision processes | 7.1 Prompts/cues | Defaults and Salience | Not possible | Yes |
-Social influences | |||||
Meeker et al. (2014) | -Goals | 1.9 Commitment | Norms, Salience and Commitments | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 2.1 Monitoring of behavior, without feedback | ||||
-Social influences | 3.2 Social support (practical) | ||||
-Social/Professional Role and Identity | 3.3 Social support (emotional) | ||||
5.1 Information about health consequences | |||||
6.3 Information about others’ approval | |||||
Musgrove et al. (2018) | -Knowledge | 4. Information about antecedents | Salience | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 7.1 Prompts/cues | ||||
O’Connor (2009) | -Memory attention and decision processes | 7.1 Prompts/cues | Defaults | Not possible | YES |
Patel et al. (2018) | -Environmental context and resources | Intervention 1: 4.2 Information about antecedents | Norms and Defaults | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 6.3 Information about others’ approval | ||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
12.5 Adding objects | |||||
Intervention 2: | Norms and Defaults | Not possible | Yes | ||
2.2 Feedback on behavior | |||||
4.2 Information about antecedents | |||||
6.2 Social comparison | |||||
6.3 Information about others’ approval | |||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
12.5 Adding objects | |||||
Patel et al. (2017) | -Environmental context and resources | 4.2 Information about antecedents | Defaults and Salience | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 7.1 Prompts/cues | ||||
Presseau et al. (2018) | -Beliefs about capabilities | 1.1 Goal setting behavior | Messenger | Not possible | No |
-Emotions | 1.6 Discrepancy between behavior and goal | ||||
-Goals | 1.2 Problem solving | ||||
-Memory attention and decision processes | 4.1 Instruction on how to perform behavior | ||||
6.1 Demonstration of the behavior | |||||
8.7 Graded tasks | |||||
8.1 Behavioral practice/rehearsal | |||||
8.3 Habit formation | |||||
9.1 Credible source | |||||
10.8 Incentive outcome | |||||
12.5 Adding objects to the environment | |||||
15.1 Verbal persuasion about capability | |||||
Sacarny et al. (2018) | -Beliefs about consequences | 2.1 Monitoring of behavior without feedback | Messenger, Incentives and Norms | Partially | Yes |
-Social influences | 2.2 Feedback on behavior | ||||
6.2 Social comparison | |||||
6.3 Information about others’ approval | |||||
Shakespeare et al. (2019) | -Knowledge | 5.1 Information about health consequences | Messenger, Defaults and Salience | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 6.3 Information about others’ approval | ||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
12.1 Restructuring the physical environment | |||||
Yadav et al. (2019) | -Knowledge | Intervention 1: | Messenger, Salience, Priming and Commitments | Not possible | Yes |
-Memory attention and decision processes | 1.9 Commitment | ||||
-Social influences | 2.2 Feedback on behavior | ||||
3.1 Social Support (unspecified) | |||||
6.3 Information about others’ approval | |||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
12.5 Adding objects to the environment | |||||
Intervention 2: | Messenger, Norms, Salience, Priming and Commitments | Not possible | Yes | ||
1.9 Commitment | |||||
2.2 Feedback on behavior | |||||
3.1 Social Support (unspecified) | |||||
6.2 Social comparison | |||||
6.3 Information about others’ approval | |||||
7.1 Prompts/cues | |||||
12.5 Adding objects to the environment |
Each number represents a behavior change techniques cluster, and the technique within that number (Michie et al., 2013). The clusters are as follows: 1 = Goals and Planning, 2 = Feedback and Monitoring, 3 = Social Support, 4 = Shaping Knowledge, 5 = Natural Consequences, 6 = Comparisons of Behavior, 7 = Associations, 8 = Repetition and Substitution, 9 = Comparisons of Outcomes, 10, Reward and Threat, 11 = Regulation, 12 = Antecedent, 13 = Identity, 14 = Scheduled Consequences, 15 = Self-Belief, 16 = Covert Learning.
Completely = A sufficient array of techniques was applied to influence all identified determinants, Partially = Some identified determinates were not targeted by any recommended techniques, Not possible = No techniques are recommended to influence an identified determinant.