Table 6.
Reference | Data sources | No. of samples | Model | Performance |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ardakani et al. [84] | Real-time data from the hospital environment. | Total: 1,020 COVID-19 : 510 Non-COVID-19 : 510 |
AlexNet, VGG-16, VGG-19,… |
Accuracy: 99.51 Recall: 100 Specificity: 99.02 |
Chen et al. [29] | Renmin Hospital of Wuhan University. | Total: 35,355 | UNet++ | Accuracy: 98.85 Recall: 94.34 Specificity: 99.16 |
Cifci [73] | Kaggle benchmark dataset [85] | Total: 5,800 | AlexNet, Inception-V4 | Accuracy: 94.74 Recall: 87.37 Specificity: 87.45 |
Javaheri et al. [36] | Five medical centers in Iran, SPIE-AAPM-NCI [86], LUNGx [87] | Total: 89,145 COVID-19 : 32,230 Non-COVID-19 : 56,915 |
BCDU-Net (U-Net) | Accuracy: 91.66 Recall: 87.5 Specificity: 94 |
Jin et al. [74] | Wuhan Union Hospital, LIDC-IDRI [88], ILD-HUG [89] |
Total: 1,881 COVID-19 : 496 Non-COVID-19 : 1,385 |
ResNet152 | Accuracy: 94.98 Recall: 94.06 Specificity: 95.47 F1: 92.78 |
Jin et al. [65] | Five different hospitals of China. | Total: 1,391 COVID-19 : 850 Non-COVID-19 : 541 |
DPN-92, Inception-v3, ResNet-50 |
Recall: 97.04 Specificity: 92.2 |
Li et al. [66] | Multiple hospitals environment. | Total: 4,536 COVID-19 : 1,296 Non-COVID-19 : 1,325 |
ResNet50 | Recall: 90 Specificity: 96 |
Wu et al. [67] | China Medical University, Beijing Youan Hospital. |
Total: 495 COVID-19 : 368 Non-COVID-19 : 127 |
ResNet50 | Accuracy: 76 Recall: 81.1 Specificity: 61.5 |
Xu et al. [79] | Zhejiang University, Hospital of Wenzhou, Hospital of Wenling. | Total: 618 COVID-19 : 219 Non-COVID-19 : 399 |
ResNet18 | Accuracy: 86.7 Recall: 81.5 F1: 81.1 |
Yousefzadeh et al. [75] | Real-time data from the hospital environment. | Total: 2,124 COVID-19 : 706 Non-COVID-19 : 1,418 |
DenseNet, ResNet, Xception, EcientNetB0 |
Accuracy: 96.4 Recall: 92.4 Specificity: 98.3 F1: 95.3 |
| ||||
ADA-COVID | SARS-CoV-2 CT scan dataset | Total: 2,482 COVID-19 : 1,252 Non-COVID-19 : 1,229 |
ResNet50 | Accuracy: 99.96 Recall: 99.80 Specificity: 99.80 F1: 99.90 |